Maurice against the Benthamites: "the old English belief that the life of a people is a continuous life", and Eustace Conway (1834)
The Benthamites, he later wrote, were 'indifferent to the traditions of the past'; they were 'incredulous of anything but statistics'. 'The old English belief that the life of a people is a continuous life - the dream of a nation as anything but the sum of its inhabitants at any given time', he observed, 'was also scattered to the winds'.
[p. 191:] … The new class of Radical reformers — party they refused to call [p. 192:] themselves — was forming itself very slowly. Its maxims were not clearly defined. Sir Francis Burdett was a vehement admirer of Magna Charta; though the idol of a great city, his sympathies were with the land. But he was nearly alone in the House. He often divided with one other member in his motions for inquiry into the state of the representation, or for any specific change. Those who supported him outside of the House had a general conviction that it was corrupt, and that to set it right would be to set the nation right. They did not, perhaps, know themselves whether they wished to restore an old edifice, or to build a new one. In times of distress, the cry for reform among the suffering class assumed a revolutionary character; it was a cry for bread. Then came schemes for putting down seditious acts and words; supported commonly by the prosperous members of the middle class; increasing the disaffection of the lower. I do not imagine that the doctrine of the sovereignty of the people penetrated deeply into the minds of Englishmen during the reign of George III.; there was a habitual respect for the actual king which interfered with the spread of it. After the accession of George IV., especially after the trial of the queen, it must have made much more way; an energetic leader might cause it to take shape in the words or acts of a mob. But when it did take that shape, there was the interest of the middle class to fight against it. There came a time, however, when the middle class [p. 193:] began to share this feeling. A set of men joined the ranks of the Radical reformers in the House of Commons, who specially represented the temper of this class — men free from all fancy — devoted to figures — careful in noting and checking official abuses — indifferent to the traditions of the past — incredulous of anything but statistics — apt to measure all things by a pecuniary standard, but faithful and honest in the use of that standard. Such men had little in common with the reformers who spoke of Magna Charta and the Bill of Rights. Being more patient of details, and more occupied with the present, they acquired an influence which the others did not possess. They held that a better representation would promote economy and diminish taxation. And presently they learnt from men more educated and philosophical than they were, on what principles they might defend it. For more than half a century, Mr Bentham had been sending forth books on morals and jurisprudence. They had been translated from his own expressive and characteristic, but singular dialect, into thoroughly readable French by M. Dumont; in that form they had exercised an influence abroad which they had only possessed here over a few minds. They had a French side and an English side. The doctrine of the Revolution, that a man has any natural rights before he enters into society, was utterly discarded; all that romance which had delighted the early enthusiasts was stripped off; so Mr Bentham did homage to [p. 194:] the habits and instincts of the English citizen. But not only romance disappeared in his hands. The old English belief that the life of a people is a continuous life — the dream of a nation as anything but the sum of its inhabitants at any given time — was also scattered to the winds. The greatest happiness of the greatest number — the will of the majority — these were the formulas under which all ideas of society and government were comprehended; what could not be reduced to these must be fiction.