MxSMarx's Shakespeare
Companion to “Marx's Shakespeare in MEGA”

Marx's Excerpt Notebooks

What Marx excerpted and consulted, 1844–1855, from the MEGA² notebook volumes we hold. Then: what kind of research programme the notebooks show, and whether he studied feudalism, the common law and the antiquarian history of English institutions.

Sources: the tables of contents and texts of MEGA² IV/3, IV/7, IV/8, IV/9 and IV/12; the library catalogue IV/32; Capital 1867 (II/5); the articles in I/1–2, I/12–14 and I/18; the letters in III/1–13, MEW 33–39 and MEGAdigital. Translations are mine. Page numbers are MEGA² pages unless marked otherwise.

1. In brief

  • The list. The contents pages of the five notebook volumes give 288 excerpted works (IV/3 29, IV/7 67, IV/8 62, IV/9 71, IV/12 59), with continuations merged into one row. Marx's book lists of 1844–47 add 303 entries. Table C adds about thirty further excerpts and readings known only from IV/32 and the letters.
  • The programme. The notebooks are political economy carried back through history. Money and credit come first, as a response to the crisis of 1847. Value, rent and population follow, then labour, land, soil chemistry and colonies. The history he reads is economic history: prices, coinage, wages, poor laws, landed property and conquest. Each historical block is tied to an economic question he was working on at that moment.
  • Feudalism: yes, continuously from 1844 to 1882, but through economic and agrarian sources. 25 of the excerpted works carry feudal or institutional material. The fullest English medieval source in the notebooks is Tuckett's History of the Past and Present State of the Labouring Population (1846), and the ones after it are Jacob, Ruding and Thornton. None of them is a legal historian.
  • Common law: effectively absent. Coke, Littleton, Bracton, Glanvill, Hale, Selden and Spelman never appear in the notebooks, the articles, Capital or the letters. Blackstone appears once, and he is Engels's reading in 1871. Marx quotes Fortescue once in Capital, as evidence of fifteenth-century popular wealth.
  • Antiquaries and the ancient constitution: their facts, never their arguments. Marx used antiquarian work at second hand: Domesday through Ruding, Rymer through Tuckett, Madox and the Chronicon Preciosum through Jacob. The English “ancient constitution” debate, about Saxon liberties and the Norman yoke, does not appear. The ancient constitutions he does engage are the Spanish Cortes (1854) and the German Mark (1868). In the second case he replaces constitutional liberty with common property in land.
  • The exception. Marx excerpted Hallam's View of the State of Europe during the Middle Ages in 1851/52 and annotated his copy “auf fast allen Seiten” (on almost every page). That notebook (IISG B 60) is not in the volumes searched, so the largest unknown is what he took from Hallam's chapters on feudalism and the English constitution.
Yes, sustained

Feudalism, serfdom, landed property

1844 Roman clientage, 1850–51 English prices and labour statutes, 1851/52 Hallam, 1854 Thierry and the Cortes, 1867 Capital, 1868 Maurer, 1879–82 Kovalevsky and Morgan.

Partly, as legislation

English institutions

He read statutes and Parliament as instruments: the Statute of Labourers, the settlement and poor laws, game laws, enclosure acts, bank acts. His sources were secondary works, Hansard and the blue books.

No

Common law, antiquaries, ancient constitution

No legal treatises, no record editions, no Society of Antiquaries, no Saxon-liberty argument. Engels came closer: Eichhorn, Blackstone, Senckenberg's Corpus iuris feudalis.

2. The research programme

Subject classes of the 288 works in Table A. The classes are mine, assigned by keyword and corrected by hand.

1844–47
IV/3

Paris and Brussels: political economy in French. The British economists are read in French translation (Senior, MacCulloch, Babbage, Ure, Child), alongside the historians of political economy (Blanqui, Pecchio, Ganilh, Villegardelle) and Buret on the condition of the working class. Two items concern the ancient economy: excerpts from an unidentified Römische Geschichte (Roman history) and Moreau de Jonnès on Roman domestic economy. The habit of reading ancient institutions next to modern economics is there from the start.

The book lists in the same notebook show the shelf behind this. They include French Revolution sources (the États généraux in 15 volumes, Loustalot's Révolutions de Paris), Guizot's Histoire de la civilisation en France, Delolme's Constitution de l'Angleterre and Shakespeare in English. Kindlinger's Geschichte der deutschen Hörigkeit (history of German serfdom) is noted as a book to buy. Wilda's Gildenwesen im Mittelalter (medieval guilds) appears with a library number, and Reeves's History of the English Law (1787) is copied from a lending-library catalogue, next to Ruggles's History of the Poor and Sinclair's History of the Public Revenue. In 1845, then, Marx wrote down the standard English legal history, but no excerpt from it survives.

1849–51
IV/7–9
London I–XIV

The British Museum notebooks: a deliberate sequence.

  • Notebooks I–VI (1849–51): the crisis of 1847. Tooke, Fullarton and Gilbart, then the currency-school pamphlets and Büsch. Next comes the history of the precious metals and prices: Jacob, Ruding, Garnier, Reitemeier and Böckh. This is where medieval England first enters, through prices and coinage.
  • “Bullion” (spring 1851). Marx indexes his own excerpts on money into 72 sections.
  • Notebooks VII–X: back to theory. Ricardo and Steuart, read side by side and section by section. Then the anti-Ricardians and the Ricardian socialists: Richard Jones, Ramsay, Malthus, Carey, Hodgskin and Ravenstone. Tuckett's history of the labouring population sits in the middle of this.
  • Notebooks XI–XIV (summer 1851): the conditions of production. Wages, factories and trade unions (XI). Rent, the corn laws and soil chemistry, with Liebig and Johnston (XII–XIII). Population (XIII). Then the Roman economy, the ancient states, the conquest of America, colonization and the slave trade (XIV): Dureau de la Malle, Heeren, Prescott, Merivale, Wakefield, Buxton, Howitt.

The historical reading always answers a question in the economics. Medieval prices bear on the value of money; the comparative history of landed property (Jones) bears on rent; conquest and colonies bear on the origin of capital; Roman agrarian law bears on population and rent. The plan behind Notebook XIV is the later chapter on primitive accumulation.

1853–55
IV/12

Journalism sets the agenda. The Eastern question (Urquhart, Hansard, the Levant correspondence, Martens's diplomatic history) and the Spanish revolution of 1854. The Spanish notebooks are the one place in these volumes where Marx excerpts constitutional history at length: the medieval Cortes, the fueros, the Cádiz constitution of 1812 and Du Hamel's constitutional history. Thierry's history of the third estate falls in the same notebooks.

1851–82
outside these volumes

From Hallam to Morgan. Hallam's Middle Ages (1851/52); Machiavelli (1852/53); the English sources of Capital's chapter on primitive accumulation (1863–67: Thorold Rogers, Walton's history of landed tenures, Roberts, Fortescue, More, Harrison, Bacon, Eden); Maurer on the German Mark (1868, 1876). Then the Russian commune (Haxthausen and Russian sources), Kovalevsky on communal landownership (1879/80), Morgan, Maine and Phear (1880–82), and Schlosser's world history (1881/82). After 1868 his interest in the past shifts from the end of feudalism to what came before it: common property in land.

3. Feudalism and English institutions: the evidence

In chronological order. Each entry gives Marx's text (or the record) and a translation.

F1

Roman clients as feudal dependants

Paris notebook, 1844, excerpts from a “Römische Geschichte”IV/3, p. 74
Original
II. Clientes. (Aerarii.) theils shopkeeper u. Handwerker, theils kleine tenants at will der Patricier. stehen im Feudalverhältniß zu den Patricies.
Translation
II. Clients (aerarii): partly shopkeepers and artisans, partly small tenants at will of the patricians. They stand in a feudal relation to the patricians.
Marx's first use of “feudal” in the notebooks describes Rome, in English legal vocabulary (“tenants at will”). He uses the category comparatively from the start.
F2

Books on the English constitution and medieval law, 1844–45

Notebook of 1844–47: Marx's list of his own books; books to buy; library cataloguesIV/3, pp. 7, 8, 13, 24, 27
Original
53) Guizot Hist. de la civil. en France. 5 vol. · 119) Delolme sur la const. de l'Angleterre. · Kindlinger. Geschichte d. deutschen Hörigkeit 12 fr. · 525 Wilda, D. Gildenwesen im Mittelalter. Berlin. 1831. · 2174 Reeves's (John) History of the english law. 1787.
Translation
53) Guizot, history of civilisation in France, 5 vols. · 119) Delolme on the constitution of England. · Kindlinger, history of German serfdom, 12 francs. · 525 Wilda, guilds in the Middle Ages, Berlin 1831. · 2174 John Reeves, History of the English Law, 1787.
Delolme (1771) was the standard Continental account of the English constitution; Marx owned it. Reeves was the standard history of English law before Pollock and Maitland; Marx only copied out its catalogue entry. Neither book is excerpted in the volumes we have. The same list of his own books includes Mackeldey's Lehrbuch des römischen Rechts (no. 64), the Pandect textbook of his Berlin years. His legal frame was the civil law.
F3

Domesday and William I's feudal dues, through the history of money

London notebook III (1850): Ruding, Annals of the Coinage; James Taylor, A View of the Money SystemIV/7, pp. 155–56, 191
Original
In Domesday Book Pecunia sehr selten money bezeichnet, sehr häufig cattle wie „Pastura ad pecuniam villae“. — Die Zahlungen unter W. I hauptsächlich in kind (Naturalzahlung). Dann die verschiedenen Gefälle, Feudalleistungen etc. Wenig Geld also damals nöthig.
Translation
In Domesday Book pecunia very rarely means money and very often means cattle, as in “pasture for the village's cattle”. — Payments under William I were mainly in kind. Then the various dues, feudal services, etc. So little money was needed then.
This is Marx's only Domesday reference, and it comes through a numismatist. The point is economic: feudal society as a natural economy with little need for money.
F4

Saxon and Norman serfdom; the stages of English labour

London notebook IX (1851): J. D. Tuckett, A History of the Past and Present State of the Labouring Population (1846)IV/8, pp. 474, 488
Original
Unter den Normannen: »the labouring classes, and the great body of the occupiers and cultivators of the land, remained, as during the saxon reigns, serfs, villains, or bondsmen attached to a particular manor …« — Die Gesellschaft hat durchgegangen die Stufen von barbarism to villeinage, von villeinage to feudalism und von feudalism to the free labourer.
Translation
Under the Normans, “the labouring classes … remained, as during the Saxon reigns, serfs, villeins, or bondsmen attached to a particular manor …” — Society has passed through the stages from barbarism to villeinage, from villeinage to feudalism, and from feudalism to the free labourer.
Tuckett is the main English medieval source in the notebooks. Marx also takes from him Magna Carta and Henry III's charters on chattel serfs (p. 474), the Statute of Labourers (p. 477), Rymer on the sale of monastic lands (p. 478), Charles II's settlement act (p. 499), the Carta de foresta, the game laws and the qualification act of 15 Richard II (pp. 508–09). The material is legal, but the questions are about labour.
F5

The Statute of Labourers, 1349

London notebook XIII (1851): W. T. Thornton, Over-population and its Remedy (1846)IV/9, p. 240→ Capital 1867, II/5, pp. 213, 578, 592
Original
1349 suchten die landholders, durch ihre Repräsentatives im Parlament, durch das Statute of Labourers die wages of agricultural labourer to limit. Aehnliches Statut im folgenden Jahr.
Translation
In 1349 the landholders, through their representatives in Parliament, tried to limit the wages of agricultural labourers by the Statute of Labourers. A similar statute the following year.
This is the sense in which Parliament interests Marx: as the landholders' instrument. In Capital the Statute opens the history of wage legislation, and Thornton's “golden age” of the fifteenth-century labourer frames the comparison of Fortescue and More (II/5, p. 578; Thornton is named on p. 124).
F6

Hallam, View of the State of Europe during the Middle Ages

Marx's copy, vol. 1 (4th ed., 1826); excerpted 1851/52IV/32, no. 532
Original (catalogue)
Marginalien von Marx (Bleistift) auf fast allen Seiten. Bibliothek Marx. Titel exzerpiert: Marx, 1851/1852 (IISG, Marx-Engels-Nachlaß, B 60).
Translation
Marginalia by Marx (pencil) on almost every page. Marx's library. Title excerpted: Marx, 1851/1852 (IISG, Marx–Engels papers, B 60).
This is the one major work of English constitutional history that Marx certainly read closely. Volume 1 covers France, Italy and Spain and the feudal system; the English constitution is in volumes 2–3, which do not survive in his library. The excerpt notebook would show what he took.
F7

The bourgeois historians of class

Marx to Joseph Weydemeyer, 5 March 1852III/5, p. 75
Original
Die Herrn sollten z. B. die historischen Werke von Thierry, Guizot, John Wade etc. studiren, um sich über die vergangne „Geschichte der Klassen“ aufzuklären.
Translation
These gentlemen should study, for example, the historical works of Thierry, Guizot, John Wade, etc., to inform themselves about the past “history of classes”.
His canon of medieval and constitutional history is French liberal historiography plus John Wade's History of the Middle and Working Classes. It is not the English legal or antiquarian tradition.
F8

Thierry and the third estate

Marx to Engels, 27 July 1854; excerpts in the Spanish notebooksIII/7, p. 130; IV/12, pp. 513ff.
Original
Ein Buch, was mich sehr interessirt hat, ist Thierry's „Histoire de la formation et du progrès du Tiers État“. 1853. Sonderbar, wie dieser Herr, le père des „Klassenkampfes“ in der französischen Geschichtsschreibung, sich in der Vorrede über die „Neuen“ erzürnt, die nun auch einen Antagonism zwischen Bourgeoisie und Proletariat sehn … Hätte Herr Thierry unsre Sachen gelesen, so wüßte er daß der entschiedne Gegensatz der Bourgeoisie gegen den peuple natürlich erst anfängt, sobald sie aufhört als tiers état dem clergé und der noblesse gegenüberzustehn.
Translation
A book that interested me very much is Thierry's “History of the formation and progress of the Third Estate”, 1853. Strange how this gentleman, the father of “class struggle” in French historiography, gets angry in his preface at the “new men” who now see an antagonism between bourgeoisie and proletariat too … Had Mr Thierry read our things, he would know that the decided opposition of the bourgeoisie to the people naturally begins only when it ceases to stand, as the third estate, against the clergy and the nobility.
Marx read Thierry on the communes, not Thierry's Conquête de l'Angleterre, the French version of the Norman-yoke thesis. Engels took up that book in 1882 and rejected its conquest theory (F13).
F9

An ancient constitution Marx did write about: the Spanish Cortes

Spanish notebooks (1854): Marliani, Historia política de la España moderna; “Revolutionary Spain”, New-York Daily Tribune, 1854IV/12, pp. 506–07; I/13, p. 419
Original
Die Justicia sagte: «Nos, que cada uno somos tanto como vos, é todos juntos valemos mas que vos, os hacemos rey de Aragon, con tal que juréis é guardéis nuestros fueros é previlejios; é se no, non» … Dieß die organización política de España bis Ende des Jhh. XV, monarquía templada con instituciones municipales y políticas.
Translation
The Justicia said: “We, each of whom is as good as you, and who together are worth more than you, make you king of Aragon, provided that you swear to and keep our fueros and privileges; and if not, not” … This was the political organisation of Spain until the end of the fifteenth century: a tempered monarchy with municipal and political institutions.
In the Tribune Marx writes of “the third element in the ancient constitution of the Cortes, viz.: the clergy” (I/13, p. 419). This is his only use of the phrase “ancient constitution”, and it is about Spain. His argument is that absolutism destroyed the medieval constitution and left the local institutions standing.
F10

Capital: Fortescue and More; waiting for Thorold Rogers

Capital 1867; Marx to Engels, 17 Dec. 1866II/5, pp. 577–78; MEGAdigital M0000208
Original
Ein Vergleich zwischen den Schriften der Schatzkanzler Fortescue und Thomas Morus veranschaulicht die Kluft zwischen dem 15. und 16. Jahrhundert. Aus ihrem goldnen Zeitalter, wie Thornton richtig sagt, stürzte die englische Arbeiterklasse ohne alle Zwischenübergänge in das eiserne. — „J. E. Th. Rogers: ‚A History of Agriculture‘. Ich muß das Buch durchaus ansehn u. habe in einem Kapitel deßwegen eine Lücke gelassen.“
Translation
A comparison between the writings of the chancellors Fortescue and Thomas More shows the gulf between the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. From its golden age, as Thornton rightly says, the English working class fell without any transition into the iron age. — “J. E. Thorold Rogers, ‘A History of Agriculture’. I absolutely must look at this book, and have left a gap in one chapter because of it.”
Fortescue's De laudibus legum Angliae is the classic of the common law's own self-praise. Marx uses it for one fact, the prosperity of the fifteenth-century commons (p. 577: “jenen Volksreichthum, den … Fortescue so beredt … schildert”, the popular wealth that Fortescue describes so eloquently). He wanted Thorold Rogers's record-based price series badly enough to leave a gap in the manuscript until he had seen them.
F11

Maurer, Möser and Grimm: the German Mark, 1868

Marx to Engels, 14 and 25 March 1868MEGAdigital M0000572, M0000590; IV/18, p. 556
Original
Auf dem Museum – by the by – u. a. die neusten Schriften v. old Maurer … geochst über deutsche Mark-, Dorf etc Verfassung. Er zeigt ausführlich nach, daß das Privateigenthum an Boden erst später entstand u.s.w. Die blödsinnige westphälische Junkeransicht (Möser etc), daß die Deutschen sich jeder für sich niedergelassen u. erst nachher Dörfer, Gaue etc gebildet, vollständig widerlegt. (14 March)

Ad vocem Maurer: Seine Bücher sind ausserordentlich bedeutend. Nicht nur die Urzeit, sondern die ganze spätere Entwicklung, der freien Reichsstädte, der Immunität besitzenden Gutsbesitzer, der öffentlichen Gewalt, des Kampfes zwischen freiem Bauernthum u. Leibeigenschaft erhält eine ganz neue Gestalt. … Die erste Reaction gegen die frz. Revolution u. das damit verbundne Aufklärerthum war natürlich alles mittelaltrich, romantisch zu sehn, u. selbst Leute wie Grimm sind nicht frei davon. Die 2te Reaction ist … über das Mittelalter hinaus in die Urzeit jeden Volks zu sehn. Da sind sie dann überrascht im Aeltesten das Neuste zu finden, u. sogar Egalitarians to a degree, wovor Proudhon schaudern würde. … so übersetzten Philologen, v. der force eines Grimm, die einfachsten lateinischen Sätze falsch, weil v. Möser etc beherrscht. Z. B. die bekannte Stelle bei Tacitus: „arva per annos mutant et superest ager“ … (25 March)
Translation
At the Museum, by the by, I swotted up among other things old Maurer's latest writings on the German Mark, village and other constitutions. He shows in detail that private property in land arose only later, etc. The idiotic Westphalian Junker view (Möser etc.) that the Germans each settled on their own and only afterwards formed villages, districts and so on is completely refuted. (14 March)

As for Maurer: his books are extraordinarily important. Not only the primeval period but the whole later development (the free imperial cities, the landowners holding immunities, public authority, the struggle between free peasantry and serfdom) takes on a completely new shape. … The first reaction against the French Revolution and the Enlightenment that went with it was naturally to see everything as medieval and romantic, and even people like Grimm are not free of it. The second reaction is to look beyond the Middle Ages into the primeval age of every people. There they are surprised to find the newest in the oldest, even egalitarians to a degree that would make Proudhon shudder. … Philologists of the calibre of Grimm mistranslated the simplest Latin sentences because they were under the sway of Möser etc. For example, the well-known passage in Tacitus, “arva per annos mutant et superest ager” [they change the arable fields every year, and common land is left over] … (25 March)
This is the nearest Marx comes to the “ancient constitution” argument, and it reverses it. Möser's free Westphalian landholders, the German counterpart of the Saxon freeholder, are a misreading of Tacitus. The oldest constitution is common property in land. The critique also bears on your Grimm and philology question: in Marx's view an ideological prior (Möser) produced a philological error (Grimm's Tacitus). Grimm's Rechtsalterthümer is noted in the agriculture notebook of 1868 (IV/18, p. 556).
F12

Blackstone, once, for Engels

Isaac Hall to Engels, Manchester, 14 March 1871MEGAdigital M9241349
Original (English)
I wonder at your reading Blackstone. You should read Williams on the Law of real property.
Note
Joshua Williams, Principles of the Law of Real Property (1845 and later editions), was the practitioners' textbook. This is the only trace of the common-law treatise tradition anywhere in the circle's papers, and it shows Engels reading it, not Marx.
F13

Engels rejects the conquest theory of serfdom; Kovalevsky's English books

Engels to Marx, 22 Dec. 1882; IV/32 nos. 695, 697, 700MEW 35, p. 137
Original
Sicher ist die Leibeigenschaft und Hörigkeit keine spezifisch mittelalterlich-feudale Form, wir haben sie überall oder fast überall, wo Eroberer das Land durch die alten Einwohner für sich bebauen lassen … Diese Tatsache hat sogar mir und manchem andern den Blick getrübt für die Mittelaltersknechtschaft; man wollte sie gar zu gern auf bloße Eroberung gründen, das machte die Sache so nett und glatt ab. Sieh u. a. Thierry.
Translation
Certainly serfdom and bondage are not a specifically medieval-feudal form. We find them everywhere or nearly everywhere that conquerors have the land cultivated for them by the old inhabitants … This fact has clouded even my view, and many others', of medieval servitude: people were only too glad to base it on mere conquest, which made the thing so nice and neat. See Thierry, among others.
Engels dismisses the Norman-yoke explanation outright (Thierry's Conquête de l'Angleterre), and says he and Marx now agree on the history of serfdom. In the same years Kovalevsky sent Marx his archive-based English constitutional history: a collection of documents on police administration in the English counties in the 12th–14th centuries (London, 1876) and The Social Structure of England at the End of the Middle Ages (Moscow, 1880). No excerpts from either are recorded. Marx's heavily annotated Kovalevsky is the book on communal landownership (1879).

4. Common law, antiquaries, the ancient constitution

I ran a full-corpus search for the names and terms that would mark engagement with English legal and antiquarian history. Cantwell's history of the Public Record Office is in the same search folder and accounts for nearly all hits on Palgrave, Kemble, Rymer, Domesday and the record editions, so those hits are excluded below.

TermHits in Marx–Engels textsWhat the hits are
Coke, Littleton, Hale, Selden, Spelman, Sharon Turner, Witenagemot0—
Bracton, Glanvill, Fleta0Only Robert Peel Glanville Blatchford in MEW name indexes.
Palgrave, Kemble, Lingard, Stubbs (historian)0All hits are in Cantwell.
Blackstone1Engels's reading, 1871 (F12). The other twelve hits are Blackstone Edge, the Chartist meeting ground, or Cantwell.
Fortescue2Capital, II/5, pp. 577–78 (F10).
Madox1Madox's Formulare Anglicanum, cited by Jacob (IV/7, p. 256). (Two “Dugdale” hits are a Manchester Schiller-Anstalt contact, not the antiquary.)
Domesday3Ruding, 1850 (F3); two IV/32 entries for a review, “The Domesday Book of Bengal” (1879), in Marx's library.
Magna Carta5Tuckett (IV/8, pp. 474, 509). As a metaphor: “die bescheidne Magna Charta eines gesetzlich beschränkten Arbeitstags” (the modest Magna Carta of a legally limited working day), Capital, II/5, p. 241; “King John's Magna Charta” as a byword in an 1853 article (I/12); a letter on the Schleswig-Holstein charter of 1460 (III/12).
Hallam5All in IV/32: Marx's annotated copy, excerpted 1851/52 (F6).
“ancient constitution”, Norman yoke, Saxon liberty1The Spanish Cortes, 1854 (F9).
Statute of Labourers101844 (“Kritische Randglossen”, I/2), Thornton 1851 (F5), Capital (8).
Möser3Marx to Engels, 1868 (F11); once of Johannes Miquel as Möser's successor at Osnabrück.

Common law

Marx's legal training was in Roman law and Pandects at Berlin, under Savigny and Gans. His notebooks never take up the English common law as a body of doctrine. English law enters only as Gesetzgebung (legislation): statutes on wages, vagrancy, settlement, poor relief, game and enclosure, and the bank acts. He reads it in secondary histories (Tuckett, Eden, Thornton), in Hansard and in the parliamentary blue books. In Capital it becomes the “Blutgesetzgebung” (bloody legislation) against the expropriated. The legal form of a relation interests him as an instrument of one class, not as a tradition with its own reasoning.

Antiquaries

He used what the antiquaries produced but never read them as antiquaries. Domesday comes through Ruding the numismatist, Rymer's Foedera through Tuckett, Madox and Bishop Fleetwood's Chronicon Preciosum through Jacob's history of the precious metals, Camden through Taylor, and later the manorial and college accounts through Thorold Rogers. Whenever he cites antiquarian work, what he wants from it is a number: a price, a wage, a coin weight, an acreage. The Society of Antiquaries, Archaeologia, the Record Commission, the Camden Society and Collier's world never appear in his papers.

The ancient constitution

The Whig and radical argument over Saxon liberties and the Norman yoke, which the Chartists still used, has no place in his notebooks. Delolme sat on his shelf in 1844, and Hallam was annotated in 1851/52. When he does engage an “ancient constitution”, he moves it in two ways.

  • In 1854, to Spain. The medieval Cortes and fueros are a real constitution, destroyed by absolutism.
  • In 1868, to the German Mark. The oldest constitution is common property in land, and the theory of original free homesteads is Möser's Junker myth.

Engels closed the English question in 1882 by rejecting the conquest theory of serfdom. In effect the circle answered the ancient-constitution tradition by replacing it: the old liberty they recognised was communal ownership, not parliamentary right.

The Collier link, and Engels

Against the background of the earlier Shakespeare work, the contrast is sharp. The record-publishing world of the Public Record Office, the Camden Society and Collier's Trevelyan Papers was the institutional home of English constitutional antiquarianism, and Marx stood entirely outside it. Engels came closer. He annotated Eichhorn's Deutsche Staats- und Rechtsgeschichte, listed Savigny's Geschichte des römischen Rechts im Mittelalter and Grimm's Rechtsalterthümer with shelf numbers, read Blackstone, worked through Irish legal history in 1869–70, and used Senckenberg's Corpus iuris feudalis Germanici for “Die Mark” (1882). See Table C.

5. Table A: works Marx excerpted, 1844–1855

From the tables of contents of IV/3, IV/7, IV/8, IV/9 and IV/12, with continuations merged and the “Bullion” index collapsed into one row. The page is the MEGA text page where each run of excerpts starts. A ● marks works with feudal, legal or institutional content; the note under the title gives the passage. Use the buttons to filter by subject.

#MEGANotebookAuthor: titlePagesSubject
1IV/3Pariser Hefte 1844/1845
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Pierre de Boisguillebert: Le détail de la France; Dissertation sur la nature des richesses, de l'argent et des tributs; Traité de la nature, culture, commerce et intérêt des grains35Political economy
2IV/3Pariser Hefte 1844/1845
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Jean Law: Considérations sur le numéraire et le commerce66Money, credit & banking
3IV/3Pariser Hefte 1844/1845
Summer 1844 – early 1847
● einer „Römischen Geschichte"
Roman constitution: patricians, curies, plebs; the clients „stehen im Feudalverhältniß zu den Patriciern“ (stand in a feudal relation to the patricians), IV/3, p. 74.
69Ancient, medieval & general history
4IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 1
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Louis Say: Principales causes de la richesse116Political economy
5IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 1, 2
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Jean Charles Léonard Simonde de Sismondi: Études sur l'économie politique. T. 1123, 175Political economy
6IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 1
Summer 1844 – early 1847
CG. de Chamborant: Du paupérisme137Population & poor law
7IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 1
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Alban de Villeneuve-Bargemont: Économie politique chrétienne138Political economy
8IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 2
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Eugène Buret: De la misère des classes laborieuses en Angleterre et en France142Labour, wages & factories
9IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 2
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Nassau William Senior: Principes fondamentaux de l'économie politique157Political economy
10IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 3
Summer 1844 – early 1847
François Louis Auguste Ferrier: Du gouvernement considéré dans ses rapports avec le commerce210Political economy
11IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 3
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Alexandre de Laborde: De l'esprit d'association dans tous les intérêts de la communauté219Political economy
12IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 3
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Ramon de la Sagra: De l'industrie cotonnière et des ouvriers en Catalogne229Labour, wages & factories
13IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 3
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Théodore Fix: De l'esprit progressif et de l'esprit de conservation en économie politique231Political economy
14IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 3
Summer 1844 – early 1847
● Alexandre Moreau de Jonnès: Aperçus statistiques sur la vie civile et l'économie domestique des Romains au commencement du quatrième siècle de notre ère
Roman civil life and domestic economy, 4th century AD.
231Ancient, medieval & general history
15IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 4
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Henri Storch: Cours d'économie politique. T. Ill, V, IV273Political economy
16IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 4
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Nicolas François Dupré de Saint Maur: Essai sur les monnoies281Money, credit & banking
17IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 4
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Isaac de Pinto: Traité de la circulation et du crédit283Money, credit & banking
18IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 4
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Josias Child: Traités sur le commerce et sur les avantages297Political economy
19IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 4
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Benjamin Bell: De la disette317Money, credit & banking
20IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 5
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Auguste de Gasparin: Considérations sur les machines322Labour, wages & factories
21IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 5
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Charles Babbage: Traité sur l'économie des machines et des manufactures325Labour, wages & factories
22IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 5
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Andrew Ure: Philosophie des manufactures342Labour, wages & factories
23IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 5
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Isaac Pereire: Leçons sur l'industrie et les finances352Political economy
24IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 5
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Pellegrino Rossi: Cours d'économie politique354Political economy
25IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 6
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Joseph Pecchio: Histoire de l'économie politique en Italie389Political economy
26IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 6
Summer 1844 – early 1847
John Ramsay MacCulloch: Discours sur l'origine, les progrès, les objets particuliers, et l'importance de l'économie politique407Political economy
27IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 6
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Charles Ganilh: Des systèmes d'économie politique413Political economy
28IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 6
Summer 1844 – early 1847
Adolphe Blanqui: Histoire de l'économie politique en Europe424Political economy
29IV/3Brüsseler Hefte 1845 6
Summer 1844 – early 1847
François Villegardelle: Histoire des idées sociales avant la révolution française426Political economy
30IV/7London notebooks I
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
John Stuart Mill: Principles of political economy39Political economy
31IV/7London notebooks I
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
John Fullarton: On the regulation of currencies42Money, credit & banking
32IV/7London notebooks I
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
David Morier Evans: The commercial crisis 1847-184852Money, credit & banking
33IV/7London notebooks I, II
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Thomas Tooke : A history of prices62, 68, 81, 84Money, credit & banking
34IV/7London notebooks I
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Alexander Anderson : The recent commercial distress66Money, credit & banking
35IV/7London notebooks I
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● Friedrich Wilhelm Freiherr von Reden: Vergleichende Kulturstatistik
Russia had “keine eigentliche Lehnsverfassung und Leibeigenschaft” (no proper feudal constitution or serfdom) until Ivan IV.
77Ancient, medieval & general history
36IV/7London notebooks II
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Robert Torrens : The principles and practical operation of Sir R. Peel's bill108Money, credit & banking
37IV/7London notebooks II
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Lord Ashburton : The financial and commercial crisis110Money, credit & banking
38IV/7London notebooks II
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Archibald Alison: Freetrade and a fettered currency112Money, credit & banking
39IV/7London notebooks II
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
William Blake: Observations on the principles which regulate the course of exchange115Money, credit & banking
40IV/7London notebooks II, III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
James William Gilbart: A practical treatise on banking128, 133Money, credit & banking
41IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Gemini Letters: The true character and certain consequences of our present currency system (p. 146); The currency question146, 147Money, credit & banking
42IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Archibald Alison: England in 1815 and 1845Money, credit & banking
43IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● James Taylor: A view of the money system (p. 155); A letter to his Grace the Duke of Wellington (p. 175); A view of the money system
Payments under William I mostly in kind, “Feudalleistungen” (feudal dues); every tenure held at the king's pleasure (IV/7, pp. 155–56).
155, 176Money, credit & banking
44IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Richard Moore: The case of the currency180Money, credit & banking
45IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Alexander Mundell: The principle and operation of gold and silver in coin181Money, credit & banking
46IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
An examination of the currency question182Money, credit & banking
47IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Edward Solly: The present distress184Money, credit & banking
48IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Nassau William Senior: Three lectures185Political economy
49IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● Rogers Ruding: Annals of the coinage
Domesday Book: pecunia usually means cattle (“Pastura ad pecuniam villae”), IV/7, p. 191.
191Money, credit & banking
50IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Germain Garnier: Histoire de la monnaie192Money, credit & banking
51IV/7London notebooks III, IV, V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● William Jacob: An historical inquiry
Prices under the Leges Saxonum (IV/7, p. 255); Fleetwood's Chronicon Preciosum; Madox's Formulare Anglicanum (p. 256); Spanish repartimientos as “Feudalsklaverei” (feudal slavery).
214, 225, 247, 373Money, credit & banking
52IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● Johann Friedrich Reitemeier: Geschichte des Bergbaues
History of mining in antiquity; forced labour in the mines.
220Ancient, medieval & general history
53IV/7London notebooks III
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. 31. August—12. Oktober 1850227Periodicals & official papers
54IV/7London notebooks IV
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● August Böckh: Die Staatshaushaltung der Athener
Public finance of Athens.
244Ancient, medieval & general history
55IV/7London notebooks IV
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. 30. November 1850273, 309Periodicals & official papers
56IV/7London notebooks IV
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● Johann Georg Büsch: Abhandlung von dem Geldumlauf (p. 277); Theoretisch-praktische Darstellung der Handlung
Money “bei der Lehnsverfassung” (under the feudal constitution) more harmful than useful (IV/7, p. 288).
277, 292Money, credit & banking
57IV/7London notebooks IV
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
William Jacob: A letter to Samuel Whitbread (p. 304); An inquiry into the causes (p. 306); Considerations on the protection304, 308Land, rent & agriculture
58IV/7London notebooks IV
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
David Ricardo: On the principles of political economy316Political economy
59IV/7London notebooks IV, V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Johann Georg Büsch: Sämtliche Schriften über Banken329, 361Money, credit & banking
60IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. Dezember 1850358Periodicals & official papers
61IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
[John Taylor]: Currency fallacies refuted379Money, credit & banking
62IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Scotus: Strictures on the evidence taken before the Committee of Secrecy381Money, credit & banking
63IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
[Charles Enderby]: Money the representative of value385Money, credit & banking
64IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
[Charles Enderby]: The metallic currency387Money, credit & banking
65IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Alfred : A letter to the Hon. the Secret Committee389Money, credit & banking
66IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
[Samuel Bailey]: Money and its vicissitudes391Money, credit & banking
67IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Thomas Joplin: An examination of the report of the Joint Stock Bank Committee407Money, credit & banking
68IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Samuel Jones Loyd : Reflections suggested by a perusal of Mr. J. Horsley Palmer's pamphlet411Money, credit & banking
69IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Thomas Joplin: An examination of Sir Robert Peel's currency bill415Money, credit & banking
70IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
William Clay: Speech of William Clay421Money, credit & banking
71IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
William Hampson Morrison: Observations on the system of metallic currency423Money, credit & banking
72IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Samuel Jones Loyd : Further reflections on the state of the currency426Money, credit & banking
73IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
David Salomons: The monetary difficulties428Money, credit & banking
74IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
George Warde Norman: Remarks upon some prevalent errors429Money, credit & banking
75IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Henry Charles Carey. The credit system432Money, credit & banking
76IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. Mai 1847440Periodicals & official papers
77IV/7London notebooks V
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. Januar 1851461Periodicals & official papers
78IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. Jahrgang 1847467, 479Periodicals & official papers
79IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
David Hume: Essays and treatises on several subjects496Money, credit & banking
80IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
John Locke : The works500Money, credit & banking
81IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Henry Thornton: An enquiry into the nature and effects of the paper credit506Money, credit & banking
82IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Thomas Mortimer: Every man his own broker528Money, credit & banking
83IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Robert Hamilton: An inquiry concerning the rise and progress534Money, credit & banking
84IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Cobbett's Manchester lectures537Political economy
85IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
● John Francis: History of the Bank of England
Trade two centuries after the Norman Conquest.
538, 565, 580Money, credit & banking
86IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Thomas Joplin : Currency reform542Money, credit & banking
87IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The currency question546Money, credit & banking
88IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
John Gray: Lectures on the nature and use of money547Money, credit & banking
89IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Patrick James Stirling: The philosophy of trade557Political economy
90IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Gavin Mason Bell: The philosophy of joint stock banking (p. 571); The currency question571, 575Money, credit & banking
91IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
John Kinnear: The crisis and the currency582Money, credit & banking
92IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Gavin Mason Bell : The country banks and the currency585, 591Money, credit & banking
93IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
David Morier Evans: The city or the physiology of London business588Political economy
94IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Samuel Spurred: The deposit enigma unravelled600Money, credit & banking
95IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
Henry Drummond: Causes which lead to a bank restriction bill601Money, credit & banking
96IV/7London notebooks VI
Sept. 1849 – Feb. 1851
The Economist. Februar 1851603Periodicals & official papers
97IV/8London notebooks
Mar. – June 1851
The Economist. April bis Juni 185186Periodicals & official papers
98IV/8London notebooks
Mar. – June 1851
John Fullarton: On the regulation of currencies118Money, credit & banking
99IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
James William Gilbart: An inquiry into the causes of the pressure121Money, credit & banking
100IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Edward Thornton: Observations of the report127Money, credit & banking
101IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Albert Gallatin: Considerations on the currency130Money, credit & banking
102IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
James William Gilbart: The history of banking in America135, 140Money, credit & banking
103IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
A defence of joint stock banks143Money, credit & banking
104IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Condy Raguet: A treatise on currency and banking144, 159Money, credit & banking
105IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Travers Twiss: View of the progress of political economy156Political economy
106IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
The currency theory reviewed168Money, credit & banking
107IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
James Whatman Bosanquet: Metallic, paper, and credit currency177Money, credit & banking
108IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Report, together with minutes of evidence … [Bullion Committee] 1810182Periodicals & official papers
109IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Charles Bosanquet: Practical observations188Money, credit & banking
110IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
David Ricardo: The high price of bullion191Money, credit & banking
111IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
David Ricardo: Reply to Mr. Bosanquet's Practical observations197Money, credit & banking
112IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Tooke: An inquiry into the currency principle199Money, credit & banking
113IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Robert Torrens: On the operation of the bank charter act212Money, credit & banking
114IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
John Gellibrand Hubbard: The currency and the country216Money, credit & banking
115IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
William Leatham: Letters on the currency ... to Ch. Wood227Money, credit & banking
116IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Reports, minutes of evidence … 1810 (p. 235); note on the Lords' Committee of Secrecy report, 1797235, 246Periodicals & official papers
117IV/8London notebooks VII
Mar. – June 1851
Reports from committees ... 1847-1848272Periodicals & official papers
118IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
Geronimo de Uztariz: The theory and practice of commerce289Political economy
119IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
The Economist. März bis Juni 1845292Periodicals & official papers
120IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
The Economist. August bis Oktober 1846302Periodicals & official papers
121IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
John Morton: On the nature and property of soils305Land, rent & agriculture
122IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
James Steuart: An inquiry into the principles of political economy312, 332, 373, 400, 405, 429Political economy
123IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
David Ricardo: On the principles of political economy326, 350, 381, 402, 409Political economy
124IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
Antonio Serra: Breve trattato396Political economy
125IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
The Economist. April bis Mai 1845426Periodicals & official papers
126IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
Geminiano Montanari: Della moneta446Money, credit & banking
127IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
Geminiano Montanari: Breve trattato448Money, credit & banking
128IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
Robert Torrens: An essay on money and paper currency449Money, credit & banking
129IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
William M. Gouge: A short history of paper money453Money, credit & banking
130IV/8London notebooks VIII
Mar. – June 1851
● William Cooke Taylor: The natural history of society
A stadial “natural history of society”.
460Ancient, medieval & general history
131IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
● William Alexander Mackinnon: History of civilisation
History of civilisation and of public opinion in England.
471Ancient, medieval & general history
132IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
● John Debell Tuckett: A history of the past and present state of the labouring population
The main English medieval source in the notebooks: Saxon and Norman serfs “attached to a particular manor” (IV/8, p. 474); Rymer on the sale of monastic lands (p. 478); the Statute of Labourers (p. 477); Charles II's settlement act (p. 499); Carta de foresta, game laws and the qualification act of 15 Richard II (pp. 508–09); stages “from barbarism to villeinage, von villeinage to feudalism und von feudalism to the free labourer” (p. 488).
473, 597Ancient, medieval & general history
133IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
John Barton: Observations on the circumstances518Political economy
134IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
The Westminster Review. 1826522Periodicals & official papers
135IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
David Buchanan: Observations on the subjects treated of in Dr. Smith inquiry524Political economy
136IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Robert Malthus: The measure of value533Population & poor law
137IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Robert Torrens: An essay on the production of wealth536Political economy
138IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Piercy Ravenstone: Thoughts on the funding system and its effects542Money, credit & banking
139IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Hodgskin: Popular political economy549Political economy
140IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Richard Jones: An introductory lectures on political economy563Political economy
141IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Robert Malthus: Definitions in political economy568Political economy
142IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
● Thomas Chalmers: On political economy
Ch. XII, “On the law of primogeniture” (IV/8, p. 586).
572Political economy
143IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
The Edinburgh Review. 1837590, 613Periodicals & official papers
144IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
● George Poulett Scrope: Principle of political economy
German tribes; “Allodial und feudal tenures” (IV/8, p. 593).
592Political economy
145IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
William Blake: Observations on the effect produced600, 610Money, credit & banking
146IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
John Ramsay MacCulloch: The literature of political economy606Political economy
147IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
● Richard Jones: An essay on the distribution of wealth
Peasant rents: serfs, metayers, ryots, cottiers. The comparative history of landed property.
615Political economy
148IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Outlines of social economy641Political economy
149IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Sharpe Smith: On the economy of nations642Political economy
150IV/8London notebooks IX, X
Mar. – June 1851
George Ramsay: An essay on the distribution of wealth643, 650, 660Political economy
151IV/8London notebooks IX
Mar. – June 1851
Richard Whately: Introductory lectures on politicai economy648Political economy
152IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas de Quincey: The logic of political economy668Political economy
153IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
Henry Charles Carey: Essay on the rate of wages672, 684Labour, wages & factories
154IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
London Magazin. 1824682Periodicals & official papers
155IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
Henry Charles Carey: Principle of political economy688Political economy
156IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
Henry Charles Carey: The past, the present, and the future740Political economy
157IV/8London notebooks X
Mar. – June 1851
Thomas Robert Malthus: Principle of political economy753Political economy
158IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hodgskin: Labour defended against the claims of capital9Labour, wages & factories
159IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Robert Owen: Observations on the effect of the manufacturing system13Labour, wages & factories
160IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
The oppressed labourers14Labour, wages & factories
161IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
William Copland: A letter to the Rev. C. D. Brereton15Political economy
162IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Nassau William Senior: Three lectures on the rate of wages16Labour, wages & factories
163IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
James H. Renny: Hints on wages18Labour, wages & factories
164IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Robert Torrens: On wages and combination20Labour, wages & factories
165IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Nassau William Senior: Letters on the factory act22Labour, wages & factories
166IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Charles David Brereton: A practical inquiry25Political economy
167IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Edward Carleton Tufnell: Character, object, and effects of Trades' Unions29Labour, wages & factories
168IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Henry Stirling: The question propounded40Political economy
169IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
James Howard: The evils of England41Labour, wages & factories
170IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
William Logan: An exposure, from personal observation, of female prostitution42Labour, wages & factories
171IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
John Fielden: The curse of the factory system43Labour, wages & factories
172IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Samuel Laing (jun.): National distress48, 61, 93Labour, wages & factories
173IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
The Edinburgh Review. Vol. 67. 183851Periodicals & official papers
174IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
The Westminster Review. Vol. 37. 184257, 59Periodicals & official papers
175IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hopkins: Great Britain for the last forty years77, 94Political economy
176IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Jelinger Cookson Symons: Outlines of popular economy80Political economy
177IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Jelinger Cookson Symons: Arts und artisans at home and abroad82Labour, wages & factories
178IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Charles Wing: Evils of the factory system96Labour, wages & factories
179IV/9London notebooks XI
July – Sept. 1851
Samuel Laing (sen.): Notes of a traveller100Political economy
180IV/9London notebooks XI, XII
July – Sept. 1851
Peter Gaskell: Artisans and machinery104, 113Labour, wages & factories
181IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
James Anderson: An inquiry into the causes119Political economy
182IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
James Anderson: Essays. Relating to agriculture and rural affairs120Land, rent & agriculture
183IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Christophe-Joseph-Alexandre Mathieu de Dombasle: Annales agricoles de Roville124Land, rent & agriculture
184IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
An inquiry into those principles, respecting the nature of demand132Political economy
185IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Samuel Turner: Considerations upon the agriculture135Land, rent & agriculture
186IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
John Stuckey Reynolds: Practical observations on Mr. Ricardo's Principles of political economy136Political economy
187IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hopkins: Economical enquiries137Political economy
188IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Perronet Thompson: The true theory of rent144Land, rent & agriculture
189IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Perronet Thompson: Corn-law fallacies146Land, rent & agriculture
190IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Edward West: Price of corn and wages of labour147Land, rent & agriculture
191IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hopkins: On rent of land153Land, rent & agriculture
192IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
David Ricardo: An essay on the influence of a low price of corn159Land, rent & agriculture
193IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
David Ricardo: On protection to agriculture161Land, rent & agriculture
194IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Charles Wentworth Dilke: The source and remedy of the national difficulties163Political economy
195IV/9London notebooks XII
July – Sept. 1851
Robert Somers: Letters from the Highlands166Land, rent & agriculture
196IV/9London notebooks XII, XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Justus Liebig: Die organische Chemie172, 199Land, rent & agriculture
197IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
John Claudius Loudon: An encyclopaedia of agriculture214Land, rent & agriculture
198IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Joseph Townsend: A dissertation on the poor laws215, 220Population & poor law
199IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Joseph Townsend: A journey through Spain219Population & poor law
200IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Robert Wallace: A dissertation on the number of mankind221Population & poor law
201IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
David Hume: Political discourses224Political economy
202IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Robert Malthus: An essay on the principle of population226Population & poor law
203IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
George Purves: Gray versus Malthus230Population & poor law
204IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
● William Thomas Thornton: Over-population and its remedy
Wages in the 12th–14th centuries and the Statute of Labourers of 1349 (IV/9, p. 240); Thornton's “golden age” returns in Capital (II/5, p. 578).
235Population & poor law
205IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Robert Vaughan: The age of great cities248Population & poor law
206IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Doubleday: The true law of population250Population & poor law
207IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
William Pulteney Alison: Observations on the management of the poor in Scotland253Population & poor law
208IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
Archibald Alison: The principles of population256, 318Population & poor law
209IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
James Finlay Weir Johnston: Lectures on agricultural chemistry and geology276Land, rent & agriculture
210IV/9London notebooks XIII, XIV
July – Sept. 1851
The Economist. Juni 1851321, 394Periodicals & official papers
211IV/9London notebooks XIII
July – Sept. 1851
The Economist. Juli 1851323Periodicals & official papers
212IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
● Adolphe-Jules-César-Auguste Dureau de La Malle: Économie politique des Romains
Ager publicus and the Roman agrarian laws.
325Ancient, medieval & general history
213IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
● Arnold Hermann Ludwig Heeren: Ideen über die Politik, den Verkehr und den Handel der vornehmsten Völker der alten Welt
Constitutions and commerce of the ancient states.
365, 454Ancient, medieval & general history
214IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
James Finlay Weir Johnston: Catechism of agricultural chemistry and geology372Land, rent & agriculture
215IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
William Johnston: England as it is, political, social, and industrial387Political economy
216IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
The Times. August 1851402Periodicals & official papers
217IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
William Hickling Prescott: History of the conquest of Mexico403, 416Colonies, slavery & conquest
218IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Herman Merivale: Lectures on colonization and colonies435, 461Colonies, slavery & conquest
219IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Felix Wakefield: Colonial surveying482Colonies, slavery & conquest
220IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Edward Gibbon Wakefield: A view of the art of colonization486Colonies, slavery & conquest
221IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hodgkin: An inquiry into the merits of the American Colonization Society492Colonies, slavery & conquest
222IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Hodgkin: On the British African Colonization Society493Colonies, slavery & conquest
223IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Fowell Buxton: The African slave trade494Colonies, slavery & conquest
224IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Thomas Fowell Buxton: The remedy; being a sequel to the African slave trade499Colonies, slavery & conquest
225IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
● Arnold Hermann Ludwig Heeren: Handbuch der Geschichte
Constitutions and commerce of the ancient states.
502Ancient, medieval & general history
226IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
William Howitt: Colonization and Christianity516Colonies, slavery & conquest
227IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Juan Sempere y Guarinos: Considérations sur les causes de la grandeur527Colonies, slavery & conquest
228IV/9London notebooks XIV
July – Sept. 1851
Henry Brougham: An inquiry into the colonial policy of the European powers542Colonies, slavery & conquest
229IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Russians in Moldavia and Wallachia. 2 ed7Diplomacy, Russia & the East
230IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Heinrich von Brandt: Rußland's Politik und Heer in den lezten Jahren15Diplomacy, Russia & the East
231IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Greek and Eastern Churches17Diplomacy, Russia & the East
232IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Valerian Krasinski: Lectures on the religious history of the Slavonic nations30, 37Diplomacy, Russia & the East
233IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Augustin Theiner: Die Staatskirche Rußlands im Jahre 183931Diplomacy, Russia & the East
234IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Charles de Martens, Ferdinand de Cussy: Recueil manuel et pratique de traités, Conventions et autres actes diplomatiques. T. 135Diplomacy, Russia & the East
235IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Hansard's parliamentary debates, third series (vols. for 1831–48)42, 134Diplomacy, Russia & the East
236IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
David Urquhart: Progress of Russia in the West, North, and South. 2 ed44, 60Diplomacy, Russia & the East
237IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1, 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Georg Friedrich von Martens: Grundriß einer diplomatischen Geschichte der europäischen Staatshändel und Friedensschlüsse seit dem Ende des 15ten Jahrhunderts bis zum Frieden zu Amiens65, 260, 312Diplomacy, Russia & the East
238IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
George Henry Francis: Opinions and policy of Palmerston88, 100Diplomacy, Russia & the East
239IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
John McNeill: Progress and present position of Russia in the East97Diplomacy, Russia & the East
240IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 1, 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Correspondence relative to the affairs of the Levant. Pt. 1-3105, 195, 305Diplomacy, Russia & the East
241IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Notes from British newspapers, Oct. 1853179Money, credit & banking
242IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Portfolio. Vol. II301Diplomacy, Russia & the East
243IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Franz Schuselka: Die Orientalische, das ist Russische Frage304Diplomacy, Russia & the East
244IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Reasons for demanding investigation into the charges against Lord Palmerston321Diplomacy, Russia & the East
245IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
David Urquhart: La crise325Diplomacy, Russia & the East
246IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
David Urquhart: An appeal against faction326Diplomacy, Russia & the East
247IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Portfolio329Diplomacy, Russia & the East
248IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
César Famin: Histoire de la rivalité et du protectorat des églises chrétiennes en Orient340Diplomacy, Russia & the East
249IV/12Diplomatic history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Jules de Bréval: Mazzini jugé par lui même et par les siens362Diplomacy, Russia & the East
250IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Henry Headley Parish: The diplomatic history of the monarchy of Greece from the year 1830375Diplomacy, Russia & the East
251IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Una plumada sobre la índole y tendencia de la revolución en España397Spain
252IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The crisis of Spain. 2. ed402Spain
253IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Terence McMahon Hughes: Revelations of Spain in 1845411Spain
254IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1, 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Sebastián de Minano: Révolution d'Espagne. Examen critique493, 809Spain
255IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1, 2, 4, 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
● Manuel de Marliani: Historia política de la España moderna
Medieval Cortes; the Aragonese coronation formula and the fueros (IV/12, pp. 506–07).
494, 664, 831, 939Spain
256IV/12Spanish history notebooks 1
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
● Augustin Thierry: Essai sur l'histoire de la formation et des progrès du Tiers État. 2 éd
The medieval communes and the third estate (excerpted 1854; IISG B 70). See Marx to Engels, 27 July 1854.
513Ancient, medieval & general history
257IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
● The political constitution of the Spanish monarchy
The Cádiz constitution of 1812.
581Spain
258IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Robert Southey: History of the Peninsular war594, 622Spain
259IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Joseph Bonaparte: Mémoires et correspondance politique et militaire du roi Joseph616Spain
260IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Constitution décrétée par l'assemblée constituante. 1791620Spain
261IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
John Bigland: Histoire d'Espagne depuis la plus ancienne époque jusqu'à la fin de l'année 1809626Spain
262IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
William Walton: The revolutions of Spain630Spain
263IV/12Spanish history notebooks 2, 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
José María de Toreno: Historia del levantamiento, guerra, y revolución de España645, 683, 707Spain
264IV/12Spanish history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Dominique de Pradt: Mémoires historiques sur la révolution d'Espagne666, 671, 703Spain
265IV/12Spanish history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Heinrich von Brandt: The two Minas and the Spanish guerillas670, 674Spain
266IV/12Spanish history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Diodorus Siculus: Bibliotheca Histórica702Ancient, medieval & general history
267IV/12Spanish history notebooks 3
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Dominique de Pradt: De la révolution actuelle de l'Espagne et de ses suites705Spain
268IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Gaspar Melchor de Jovellanos: Informe de la Sociedad económica de Madrid727Spain
269IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Henry Winter Davis: The war of Ormuzd and Ahriman in the nineteenth century732Spain
270IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Evaristo San Miguel: Memoria sucinta sobre lo acaecido en la columna móvil de las tropas nacionales al mando del comandante general de la primera division Don Rafael del Riego738Spain
271IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Joseph Blanco White: Letters from Spain740Spain
272IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Christopher Clarke: An examination of the internal state of Spain745Spain
273IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
John Bramsen: Remarks on the North of Spain762Spain
274IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The last days of Spain763Spain
275IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Pedro de Urquinaona: La España bajo el poder arbitrario de la Congregación Apostólica774Spain
276IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Santiago Perez: Who is the liberator of Spain?790Spain
277IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Holy Alliance versus Spain793Spain
278IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
François-René de Chateaubriand: Congrès de Vérone. Guerre d'Espagne. T. 1796Spain
279IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4, 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
● Victor Du Hamel: Historia constitucional de la Monarquía española
Constitutional history of the Spanish monarchy.
823, 855Spain
280IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Carta á los editores del Español-Constitucional827Spain
281IV/12Spanish history notebooks 4, 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Michael Joseph Quin: A visit to Spain851, 901Spain
282IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Dominique de Pradt: Garanties à demander à l'Espagne875Spain
283IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Evaristo San Miguel: De la guerra civil de España876Spain
284IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Richard Ford: An historical enquiry into the unchangeable character of a war in Spain880, 889Spain
285IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
Vicente Pou: L'Espagne en la crise présente885, 890Spain
286IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Edinburgh Review. Februar 1823 bis Januar 1824940Periodicals & official papers
287IV/12Spanish history notebooks 5
Sept. 1853 – Jan. 1855
The Economist, 6 Jan. 1855946Periodicals & official papers
288IV/8London notebooks
Mar. – June 1851
● “Bullion. Das vollendete Geldsystem” (Bullion: the money system completed): Marx's own compilation, in 72 sections, from his earlier excerpts on money (Adam Smith; Jean-Baptiste Say; Pellegrino Luigi Edoardo Rossi; John Francis Bray; Robert Owen; G. Browning; Jean-Charles-Léonard Simonde de Sismondi; Joseph-Francis-Xavier Droz; François-Louis-Auguste Ferrier; Alexandre-Louis-Joseph de Laborde; Henri Storch; David Ricardo; James Mill; Nassau William Senior; William Atkinson; John Wade; John Stuart Mill; Thomas Cooper; James William Gilbart; Thomas Rowe Edmonds; William Cobbett; Gustav von Gülich; Marie Augier; Joseph Pecchio; John Ramsay MacCulloch; Charles Ganilh; Louis Say; James Maitland Lauderdale; William Petty; [Edward Misselden:] Free trade; Pierre Boisguillebert; Thomas Paine; London Encyclopaedia; St. Simoniens; William Blake; John Fullarton; Thomas Tooke; Johann Georg Büsch; Alfred; Samuel Bailey; Thomas Joplin; Samuel Jones Loyd; William Clay; William Hampson Morrison; David Salomons; George Warde Norman; Henry Charles Carey; The Economist 1847; The Economist 1844; David Hume; John Locke 72 Heft mit Exzerpten und Notizen; Henry Thornton; Thomas Mortimer; Robert Hamilton; John Gray; Patrick James Stirling)
Section XXIV (Augier): medieval public credit; revenues “seigneuriales”, taxes in kind.
3–85Money, credit & banking

6. Table B: book lists in the notebook of 1844–47

Marx's notebook of 1844–47 (IV/3, pp. 5–30) records books he owned, wanted, priced or found in library catalogues. These are titles he consulted or meant to consult, not excerpts.

This table is machine-read from the OCR of the printed notebook text. Entries run together on one line have been split by their numbers, and German or French abbreviations are kept as Marx wrote them. The section labels follow Marx's page order and his own headings. The MEGA apparatus (IV/3, pp. 483ff.) identifies the libraries, but it is not in our scan, so I have not named them. Check any entry you rely on against the printed page.

Show the 303 list entries
MS p.ListNo.Entry as written
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)28Adam Smith Richesse d. Nat.5 t. 10
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)29Skarbek: Théories des richesses sociales. 2 t.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)30Pecqueur théor. nouvell. d'écon. sociale.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)31Eugène Buret: Misère des classes laborieuses.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)32Michel Chevalier: Coursd'économie polit. 2 t.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)33Ganilh hist, des systèmes d'économ.pol. 15
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)34Économistes financiers du 18' siècle.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)35Dupuis origine des cultes. 3 vol.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)36États généraux vol.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)37Destutt de Tracy écon. polit.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)38Élémens d'écon. pol. par M. de B. 39) l'agriculture des anciens p. AdamDickson.2 vol.
[9]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)40Bignon Desproscriptions.2 vol.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)41Pompéry Exposition de science sociale de Fourier.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)42Histoire de la révol. franc, pardeux amis de la liberté. 11 vol.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)43Loustalot. Révolutions de Paris.7 t.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)44Republikanische Flugschriften. Nach 1830.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)45Vict. Antoine: Prospectus de perfectibilité.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)46Jean Journet la bonne nouvelle. (Fourier.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)47Richard Lahautière. loi sociale.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)48Dezamy. Lammenais réfuté p. lui-même.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)49Catéchisme du peuple. 1841.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)50Absence du droit électoral etc
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)51Plato operaomnia.2 t.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)52Archives de Police Fouchet4 t.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)53Guizot Hist, de la civil, en France.5 vol.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)54Gervinus Litteraturgeschichte. t.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)55Biese Phil. d. Aristoteles.
[10]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)56Sextus Empiricus
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)59Renouvier: Manuel de phil. moderne.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)60Schiller Werke.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)61Göthe. Werke.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)62Herder. Ideenzur Philos, d. Geschichte.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)63Gibbon Sinken d. römischenReichs.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)64Mackeldey Lehrbuch d. römischenRechts.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)65Eichhorn Deutsches Privatrecht.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)66Trendelenburg Logik.2 t.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)67Duc de St. Simon Mémoires.3 vol.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)68Llorente hist, de l'inquisition etc. 4 vol.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)69Homer: op.omnia.5 vol.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)70Pindar.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)71Tacitus 2 vol.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)72Vellejus Paterculus.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)73Erdmann Logik.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)74Buttmann griechische Grammatik.2 vol.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)75Eberstein Peripatetiker. Scholastiker.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)76Strauß Dogmatik.2 t.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)77Daub Vorlesung überMoral.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)78Point du jour 2 ν. (Barrère.
[11]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)79feuille villageoise 6 vol. (Cerutti.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)80de Luchet hist. litt, de Voltaire. vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)81Mably œuvres complètes. 12 vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)82Preussisches Landrecht. vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)83Pages hist, de la Révol.2 vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)84Corpus juris
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)85Beaulieu Essais etc sur la révol. de France.6 vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)86Mirabeau de la monarchieprussienne.7 vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)87Barbier ïambes. 5
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)88Pétition d'un citoyen opprimé. 1789.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)89l'homme et la société.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)90les hommesnouveaux.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)91Discours du Général Foy 2 vol.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)92Froment la police dévoilée. 10
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)93Olinde Rodrigues Poésies sociales.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)94Märker Princip d. Bösen.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)95Monsieur Talleyrand.
[12]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)96Sarran légitimité
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)97Ganilh Pouvoir et opposition. 15
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)98Robinet de la nature.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)99Terentius.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)100Mémoire de l'abbé Terray.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)101Hist, de Paraguay et d. Dr. Francia.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)102Hist, du dix Août 2 vol. 20
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)103Isambert Manuel du publiciste 2 vol.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)104Rémusat Essai de philosophie.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)105Discours à la chambre des pairs.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)106Claus überRechtsphil. etc.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)107essais sur la constit. pratique en Angleterre. 1
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)08Lettres de Mad.Roland.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)109Papierstrouvés chez Robespierre.3 vol.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)110Œuvres de Lepelletier.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)111Gedichte eines Lebendigen.
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)112Franz. Phil. d. Mathematik. 30
[13]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)113Bauer Synoptiker.3 vol.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)114Weitling Garantien d. Freiheit.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)115Shakespeare, englisch.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)116Britisches Theater.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)117Britische Lyriker. 35
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)118Schulz Bewegung d. Production.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)119Delolme sur la const, de l'Angleterre.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)120de l'opposition en 1831.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)121Edgar Bauer, liberale Bestrebungen 2Th.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)122Der Richter als Geschworn. etc. 40
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)123St. Lambert 2 t.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)124Owen, thenewmoralworld.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)125Owen six lectures etc.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)126Louis Napoleon: Extinction du paupérisme.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)127Channing ZurErheb, d. niedern Volksklassen.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)128Timon: Légomanie.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)129Histoire du Clergé 3 vol.
[14]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)130Code Napoléon. 2 vol.
[15]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)131Herder: Cid.
[15]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)132Constitution de l'Amérique.
[15]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)133Collection des Constitutions2 vol.
[15]Marx's list of his own books (from Aug. 1844)134Mad.Roland:Mémoires 135) 136) 137) 138) 139) 140)| Zukaufenodersonstzuverschaffen:
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx1Buonarotti. (Herwegh.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx2 +Sismond Sismondi. Nationalökonomische Schrift.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx3 +Owen franz. Uebers. (Gay
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx4 +Rossi Nationalök.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx5 +Physiokraten
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx6 +Malthus
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx7 +St. Simon science de l'homme.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx8 +List (Engels.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx9Villeneuve-Bargemont hist, de l'éc. politiq.
[16]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx10 +Bentham. a) défense [de] l'usure etc. Par. 1828. +b) esquisse d'unouvrageen faveur des pauvres,traduitetpubliépar Duquesnoy.Par. 1802. + c) Théorie des peines et des récompenses.2 vol.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx11 +Babbage Ch. Traité sur l'économie des machines et des ma- nufactures, tr. d e l'anglais parEd. Biot. Par. 1833.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx12 +Bell (Benjamin) De la disette, trad, de Prévost de Genève. 1804.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx13Canard (N.F.) Principes d'économie politique. Par. 1801. in-8. (Oekonomie algebraisch.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx14Cabrion-Nisas. (A. de.) Principes d'économiepolitique.Paris. 1825. (précis historique de Banque de France.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx12 +Chaptal. (comte.) De l'Industrie française. 1819. 2 vol.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx13Chastellux. (comte de.) De la félicité publique ou considérât, etc. Par is. 1822. 2 vol. in 8.
[17]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx14 +Coffinières. (A.S.G.) De la Bourse et des spéculations sur les effets publics. Paris. 1824.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx15Clarke docteur.Coup d'œil sur la force et l'opulence de la Gran- de-Bretagne, etc. traduitp.Marchena.Paris. 1802. Lond. 1801.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx16 +ComteCharles 1) traité de législation etc. Paris. 1827. 4 v. 2) traité de la propriété.Paris. 1834. 2 v.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx17 +Considérant. Destinée sociale. (Herwegh.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx18Duchâtel (T.) De la charité dans ses rapports avec l'état moral etc. Paris. 1829.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx19 +Dunoyer (B.C.) Nouveautraitéd'économie sociale etc. Paris. 1830. 2 vol. in 8.
[18]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx20 +Fergusson. (Adam). Essai sur l'histoire de la société civile, trad, de l'Anglais par Bergier. Paris. 1783. 2 vol. in-12 ou 1796. in-8. + Droz Économiepolitique ou principes de la science des richesses. Paris. 1829.I
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx21 +Gasparin. (de) Considérations sur les machines. Paris. 1835. in 8. 20
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx22 +Hamilton. (Robert.)Recherches sur l'origine etc. de la dette nationale de la Grande-Bretagne;traduit etc p. Henri Lasalle. Paris. 1817.
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx24Herrmann. Staatswirthschaftliche Untersuchungen, in 8. München. 1832.
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx25Laboulinière (P.) De la disette et de la surabondance en France etc. Paris. 1821. 2 vol. in 8.
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx26Lötz. Handbuch d. Staatswirthschaftslehre. 3 B. in-8. Erlangen. 1823.
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx27 +Mac Culloch. Principes d'économie politique, trad,parPrévost de Genève.1 Vol. Londres. 1830.
[19]Works to obtain (Paris); “+” = ticked by Marx28 +Macnab (Henri-Grey).Examenimpartial d. nouvelles vues de M. R. Owen. etc. Paris 1821.
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)29Mossé L'art de gagner sa vie ou Encyclopédie industrielle etc. 1826. Paris. I
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)30Rau. Lehrbuch d. politischen Oekonomie.3 B. Heidelberg. 1837.
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)31 +J.B. Say. Courscompletd'économiepratique etc. Guillaumin. 1840 2 Vol. in 8.
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)32 +Steuart (J.) Recherches sur les princ. de l'économie polit, etc. trad, de l'anglais p. Senovert. Paris.Didot-aîné 1789. vol. in 8.
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)33 +Storch. (Henri).Coursd'économiepolitique etc. avec des notes etc. d. Say. Paris. 1823. vol. 40
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)34 +Werke v. Turgot.
[20]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)35 +Vre (Andrew)Philosophie des manufactures etc. Par. et Bruxelles 1836. 2 vol. [in-]12.
[21]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)36Villeneuve Bargemont etc. Économie polit. Chrétienne.Paris. 1834. 3 vol.
[21]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)37 +Villermé. Tableau de l'état physique et moral des ouvriers etc. Re-5 nouard. 1840. 2 vol. Bei Guillaumin Galerie de la Bourse, 5, Panoramas. Physiocrates fr. \ Turgot. 12 fr. Malthus fr. {Ricardo œuvres complu fr. (.Say
[22]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)1Cabrion Nisas. Principes d'économie polit. 3 fr.
[22]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)2 +Godwin Recherches sur population etc. 2 vol. 12 fr.
[23]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)4Deine Aufhebung des vorgestellten Gegenstandes, des Gegenstandes als Gegenstandes des Bewußtseins identificirt mitder wirklichen gegen- ständlichen Aufhebung,der v. demDenkenunterschiednen sinnlichen Action, Praxis, u. r
[25]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)1Die Entstehungsgeschichte des modernen Staats oder die franzö- sische Revolution. DieSelbstueberhebung des politischen Wesens. Verwechslung mitdem antiken Staat. Verhältnis derRevolutionairezurbürgerlichen Gesell- schaft
[25]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)3Der Staat u. die bürgerliche Gesellschaft.
[25]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)5Die Theilung der Gewalten. Gesetzgebende u. exekutive Gewalt.
[25]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)6Die gesetzgebende Gewalt u. die GesetzgebendenKörper. Politische Clubs.
[25]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)7Die exekutive Gewalt.Centralisation u. Hierarchie.Centralisation u. politische Civilisation. Federativwesen u. Industrialismus. Die Staatsverwaltung u. Gemeindeverwaltung. \ 8') Die richterliche Gewalt u. das Recht. 8")
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)1Gülich fr.
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)2List. 8
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)3{Rau. 83.
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)14) Babbage.
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)14Coffinières.
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)47) Droz
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)58) MacCulloch
[28]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)37Villermé \
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)10Physiocrates 5
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)11Turgot.
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)1012) Malthus. (10 fr.
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)13Dunoyer.
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)914) Macnab. _ 7
[29]Bookshop prices and purchases (Paris)15Fergusson. (8 fr.) _ 8
[37]Reading list (Paris/Brussels)1Économie polit, chrét.
[37]Reading list (Paris/Brussels)2Hist, de l'écon. pol. Mac Culloch Princip. d'éc. pol. Considérant destinée sociale. Dunoyer de la liberté du travail etc. III vol. Ferner Auguste Comte Phil. pos. (Say Louis} | Storch Cours d'éc. pol. (Torrens} \ (Thomps
[44]Reading list (Brussels, 1845)1827Observations on papermoney,bankingandovertrading. D'Avenant. Essay upon Ways and Means. Discourses on the Trade of England. Acompendious or briefe examination of certayneordinarycomplaints, by W. S. 1581. (enthält eine A
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4933 +R. Wallace essai sur la différence du nombre des hommes etc. Lond. 1754.
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4941Traité de la circulation etc. (de Pinto publié parDumas)Amst. 1771.
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4948 +Maupin de la seule richesse du peuple.Par. 1785.
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4952 +Herrenschwand discours fondamental etc. London 1786
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4962Simonde: de la richesse commercialeGenève 1803. 2 v.
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4966Al. De La Borde de l'esprit d'associationdanstous les intérêts de ! la communauté etc. Par. 1818.) '
[58]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4968Capmas théorie de l'intérêt de l'argent. Par. 1782
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4980FriedländerEntwurf einer Geschichte d. Armen, etc. Leip- zig 1804.) \
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4995Grégoire hist, du commercehomicide de la traite des noirs.Par. 1822.
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5003Essai sur les monnoies ou réflexions sur le rapportentrel'argent et les denrées. Paris. 1746. (Dupré de St. MaurMaître des comptesà Paris Verfasser
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5044J.B.A. Malisset, la boussole des spéculateurs, ou traité complet etc ducommerce.Par. 1803.) +
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5056Éléments du commerce par de Forbonnais.Leyde et Par. 1754. 2 v.
[59]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5057Traité sur le commerceparJos. Child avec un petit traité cont. ! l'usure p. Th.Culpeper.Amst. 1754> j
[60]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5076Condillac le commerce et le gouvernement.Amst. et Par. 1776.
[60]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5096A.M. Chappus. histoire abrégée des révolutions du commerce. P. 1803.
[60]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5098F.L.A. Ferner: du gouvernement considéré dans ses rapports ! avec le commerce.Par. 1805.) '
[60]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5104P. Laboulinière de l'influence d'unegrandeRévolutionsur le commerce etc La Haie 1808
[60]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4720Locke du gouvernement civil. Lon. et Par. 1783
[61]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4828Ethocratie ou gouvernementfondé sur la morale.(Holbach) Amst. 1776. 3866 Œuvres diverses de Locke Amst. 1732. 2 v. 3868 Œuvrescomplètes de M. Helvétius. Londres. 1785. v.
[61]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3870Th.Hobbesopera philos. 3874 de la Mettrie. œuvres phil. Berlin. 1764. 2 v. 3914 d'Argens,philosophie du bon sens. La Haye. 1740.
[61]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3936Bernardi Telesii de rerumnatura. 1586.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3931H. Cardani de sapientia | lib. 5. Aureliopoli. 1624.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3940Visct. Bolingbroke the philosophicalworks.Lond.1754-77.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3822Petri Pomponatii operaomnia. Ven. 1525.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3823Antoniana Margarita etc. Anno 1554.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3824Francisci Baconioperaomnia. Francf. 1665. id.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3825Works of FrancisBacon.Lond. 1778. 5
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)3832RenatiDescartesoperaomnia.Amst.1670-83.
[62]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4008Prodromusphilosophiaeinstaurandae; i.e. dissertationis de na- turarerumcompendium | ex script. Th.Campanellae.Franc. 1617.
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4012Rad.Cudworthi systema intellectuale etc. 1773 2 v.
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4019N. Malebranche.Recherche de la vérité. 10
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4050Jord.Brunus. de umbrisidearum. 1582.
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4060F. ThomaeCampanellae de sensu rerum et magia. 1. IV. 1620.
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4073Em. Swedenborg du commerce établi entrel'âme et le corps.Lon- dres et la Haie. 1785.
[63]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4077Fabre. essai sur 1. facultés de l'âme. Paris 1787 etc.
[64]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4082Vives (Joan.Lod.) de anima et vita. 1. III 1555.
[64]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4108Hier. Cardani de immortalitateanimorum.Lug. 1545.
[64]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4111J.C.Delamétherie, de la nature des êtres existans etc. Par. 1805 4112 id. considérations sur les êtres organisés. 1808. Supplément. 1 Partie. (du 1 Janvier au 31 Dec. 1841
[64]Library catalogue numbers (1845)1777Revue mensuelle d'économie politique, publiée p. Th. Fix. P. 1833. 5v.>| 4\ Catalog, (v. 1Jan. bis 31 Dec. 1842.) 4400.-5531 Dunoyer, l'industrie et la morale considérées dans leurs rap- ports avec la liberté. Par. 1825.
[65]Library catalogue numbers (1845)1820I 2 v. (4585.-5562. Storch, cours d'écon. pol.Par. 1823. vol. 5730.-5516.Journal des économistes, etc 1841-42.2 v.> | 1 Supplément.
[66]Library catalogue numbers (1845)507 +Trioen traité général des empruntscontractéspartoutes les puiss. de l'Europe. Brüx. 1839. 1vol.) (509 id. essai sur les abus de l'agiotage Brüx. 1834
[66]Library catalogue numbers (1845)525Wilda, D. Gildenwesen im Mittelalter. Berlin. 1831. | 1 Part. 1521. Martineau. de la société américaine, tr. p. Laroche.Brüx.
[66]Library catalogue numbers (1845)1838Partie. 6617.-7486 Cadet de Vaux moyens de prévenir le retour des disettes. Par. 1812 7243.-6572. Les Prussiens dénoncésàl'Europe.Par. 1789
[68]Library catalogue numbers (1845)17907Recherches et considérations sur les finances de France de 1597 à 1721 par (de Forbonnois.) Bâle. 1758 2ν| 17946 le marq. Gamier hist, de la monnaie. P. 1819. 2 v.
[69]Library catalogue numbers (1845)17996Tableau de Paris p. Mercier.Amst. 1789. 12 v.
[69]Library catalogue numbers (1845)18746Joan.Miltonii Angli propopulo anglic. defensio cont.Claudii Anonymi, alias Salmasii defensionem regiam. Lond. 1651. de Chamborant: Du Paupérisme etc Par. 1842 chez Guillaumin.| Queries relating to thetradeandprosperity o
[70]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4937Messance, recherches sur la population des généralités d'Auver- gne, de Lyon, de Rouen, etc. de 1674 à 1764. Paris. 1766.
[70]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4949Raynal discours sur la prospérité des sociétés politiques.Genève. 1789. 4953 de l'économie politique moderne etc. Londres. 1786. (Herren- schwand
[70]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4954Le réformateur (par Cliquot-Blervache.) Amst. 1766 2 ν.
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4970Deon de Beaumont, essai hist, sur les finances de la France sous Louis XIV et le Régent.Amst. 1753.
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4974Ch.Dupin,discours et leçons sur l'industrie etc. Par. 1825.
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4990Briatte, offrande àl'humanité ou traité sur les causes de la misère en général et de la mendicité en particulier. Amst. et Par. 1780.
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5005De Bettange. traité des monoyes.Avignon. 1760.
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5093V. Roux, de l'influence du gouvernement sur la prospérité du commerce.Par. 1800 2 t. -
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5147D.F.Donnant.Théorie élémentaire de la statistique. Par. 1805. 10
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4991Moyens de détruire la mendicité. -
[73]Library catalogue numbers (1845)4987Buch v. 1621. (Le premierplan du mont de piété françois.
[72]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5918Delabergerie histoire de l'agriculture française. Paris. 1815.
[72]Library catalogue numbers (1845)5971De la disette de B. Bell. trad,par P. Prévost.Genève 1804. | 1
[72]Library catalogue numbers (1845)6946Alison's (A.) Principles of Population.2 v. 1840.
[75]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6318Bank of England.Statement of thepower of the. 1832.
[75]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6268Chalmers (Dr.)ThesupremeImportance of a right moral to a right economical state of thecommunity. 1833. 2
[75]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6280Chalmers (Dr.) On political economy. 1832. 6222 (Collier's (J.P.) History of english DramaticPoetry. 1831.) 6404 (Gaskell (P.) On themanufacturingpopulation of England.
[75]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6440Gilbart's (J.W.) Historyand Principles of Banking. 1834.) I
[74]Library catalogue numbers (1845)6586Prichard: Researchesintothe physical history of mankind. 2 V. I I
[74]Library catalogue numbers (1845)6620Greg's (R.H.)FactoryQuestionandthe Ten hours Bill. 1837. 6/49 Hamilton's: Progress of Society. 1830.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)7414Head's (Sir Geo.)Tour in themanufacturing districts in England. 1836.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)7194Hopkins (John)Notions on political Economy. 1833. 5134 (Mackintosh's (Sir James)History of theRevolution in England in 1688. | 1834
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6597Mc.Culloch's Statistical Account of the british empire.2 vols. 1837 6233 (Mc.Culloch's Principles of Political Economy. 1831.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)1987Anderson's On the origine of commerce.4 v. 1801.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2128Banking System of England.Observation on the. 1821.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298Clarkson (Wm.) on pauperismpamphl. 1816.
[76]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2128Credit, Individual,Observations on the circulation of - 1811
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)6527Moreton's. Brief Analysis of the naturallawsthat regulate the numbersandconditionofmankind. 1836.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3646Gilbart's Practical Treatise on banking. 1827.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3758Godwin (Will.) Answer to Malthus. 1820.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)4289Godwin (W.) History of the Commonwealth.4 v. 1824.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)4561Graham (Sir J.) CornandCurrency. 1826.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)33298 Higgins'Remarks on M.CullochsDoctrine respecting thecorn Laws. 1826. -
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3634Hopkins (Th.) Economical Inquiries respecting Rent, Wages etc. 1822.
[77]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)5298Jakob's (Giles) Report on AgricultureandtheCorntrade.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298James's Essay on the currency. 1820.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)320Jarrold's (Th. M.D.)Answer to Malthus.1806-17.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)43298 Jemmett's: Observations on Ricardo's System of Politic. Eco- nomy. 1826.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)52045 King's (Chas.) British Merchant3 v. 1721.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3350Lauderdale's Defence of his Enquiry. 1804.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3781Malthus Political Economy. 1820
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)63634 Measure of value stated and illustrated. 1823.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)73600 — Definitions in Political Economy.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3604Mandeville by W. Godwin.3 v. 1818.
[78]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3356MerchantsandManufacturers, Interest of the, stated etc 1774.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)12202Mill's (J.) Commerce defended. 1808.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298R. Owen Effect of the manufacturing system. 1817.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298On the means of limiting thepopulation 1820.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)382Priestley Disquisitions on matterand spirit. 1777.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298Protection to Agriculture. 1821.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2174Reeves's (John)History of the english law. 1787.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2181Report,Parliamentary, on the education of the lower orders of themetropolis. 1816.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)83298 RicardoandAdam Smith. 1821.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2188Ruggles's (Th.) History of the poor2 v. 1794.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3634Senior's Lecture on political Economy. 1827.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)4789Essay on the mercantile theory of wealth. 1828.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2015Sinclair's (Sir John)History of the public revenue. 4 1786.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3298Sinclair: on theapproaching crisis. 1818.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)4859Social Life, Comparative view of, in EnglandandFrance, from theRestoration of CharlesI to the french Revolution. 1828.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2018Sommerville's (Th.) History of Parties, from the Restoration to theDeath of William III, 4 1792.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2645Temple's (Sir Wil.) Works: 2ter vol.
[79]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)93298 Thompson J. Perronet Exposition of Fallacies of rent. 1826.
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2209Thornton's (Hen.) Essay on thePaperCredit of Great Bri- tain. 1800.
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3826Torrens's (Maj.) Essai on the external Corntrade. 1820. 5
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2232Trade,Foreign,Causes of the decline of ... 1750.
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2237Trades, General description of 1747.
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)289Trimmer's economy of charity. 1787. 2215 [Uztariz's] (J. d.) Theoryand Practice of commerce. 1751.
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3408WasteLands, On theAdvantages of inclosing 1772. 10
[81]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)403Weyland (John). On population. 1816.
[82]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)12228A. Young Political Arithmetic. 1774.
[82]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2942Senior's Two lectures on populationandcorrespondencewith Malthus. 1829. 4552 (Tooke: Essay on the high andlow prices from 1793 to 1822 8°. 1824.) 4565 idem on the state of the currency. 1826.
[82]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2049Torrens: Letter to LordLiverpool on Agriculture. 1820. Dallas: recollections of LordByron. Everett: New Ideas on Population. George Ensore Esq. "The Poor and their Relief." Ming Skidmore AmerikanischeRadicale gegen Eigen
[84]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)1An Inquiry into the present State of population in England and Wales etc. by W. Wales. Lond. 1781.
[84]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)2An Examination of Dr. Price's Essay on the population of England and Wales ... By theRev.John Howlett. Maidstone. 1781. J.C. Prichard M.D. Researches into the physical history of mankind. 4 v. Lond. 1841-44. | Recherches
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)559Anderson. (Jas.) Essays on Agriculture3 v. 1771-96.3 vol.
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3404Anderson. (Jas.) Calm investigation of the causes of the scarcity. 1801. 5
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)455Anderson. (J.) Observations on nationalindustry. 1777.
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)3636Attwood's (Thos.) Letter to LordLiverpool on theBankReports. 1819.
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)104262 Chalmers: Christianand civic economy. {88 Collier's (Jere) Immorality of the English Stage. 1698.) 11
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)799Animal Creation, Philosophical Survey of the ... 1768.
[86]“Catalog der Leihbibliothek” (lending-library catalogue)121821 Townsend Rev. (Travels through Spain) 2 vol.
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)3615Atkinson's Principles of political economy. 1840.) (3616 id. State of the science of political economy. 1838) 13
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)3689Logic of political economy, by de Quincey.
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)3691Mc.Culloch on Taxation. 1845.
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)768Bailey's -Moneyand its vicissitudes in value. 1837
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)1305Cobbett's (William) Paperagainst gold. 1306 idemCurse of papermoneyandbanking.> 15
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)138Longfield's (M.) Lectures on political economy. 1834.
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)1384Th.MoresUtopia. 1838
[92]“Atheneum” (Athenaeum library)14197 Scrope's (G.P.) Principles of political economy. 1833. | Weyland John. Esq.The principles of the English poor laws. 1815. The principles ofPopulationandProduction.Lond. 1816. Bergius JohnHenri Lewis. CompleteCatalogu

7. Table C: excerpts and reading outside the volumes searched

From IV/32's records of surviving excerpt notebooks (“Titel exzerpiert”, title excerpted, with IISG notebook numbers), from Capital, and from the letters. Limited to history, law, land and society.

Marx

DateWorkWhere recordedNote
1843Montesquieu, Œuvres (Kreuznach notebooks); again 1859–63, 1867/68MEGA IV/2, pp. 106–115; IV/32 no. 910The Kreuznach notebooks (IV/2) hold Marx's 1843 reading in French, English, German and Venetian history. I haven't searched them here.
1851/52Henry Hallam, View of the State of Europe during the Middle Ages, vol. 1 (4th ed., 1826)IISG B 60; IV/32 no. 532Marx's own copy: “Marginalien von Marx (Bleistift) auf fast allen Seiten” (pencil marginalia by Marx on almost every page). The main constitutional history of medieval England and Europe, with chapters on feudalism and on the English constitution.
1852/53Machiavelli, Tutte le opereIISG B 52, B 63; IV/32 no. 814
1854Augustin Thierry, Essai sur l'histoire de la formation et des progrès du Tiers État (2nd ed., 1853)IV/12, pp. 513ff.; IISG B 70; IV/32 no. 1306Marx to Engels, 27 July 1854 (III/7, p. 130): Thierry is “le père des ‚Klassenkampfes‘ in der französischen Geschichtsschreibung” (the father of “class struggle” in French historiography).
1856Joachim Lelewel, Histoire de PologneIISG B 83; IV/32 no. 765
1856, 1863Charles Forster Cotterill, Public granariesIISG B 81, B 105; IV/32 no. 257
1857–61Gustav Moritz Redslob, ThuleIISG B 83, B 91A, B 93; IV/32 no. 1097
1859–63; 1878–81Simon-Nicolas-Henri Linguet, Théorie des loix civilesIISG B 91A; IV/32 no. 778A legal-historical theory of property and servitude. Marx already excerpted Linguet in 1845 (IV/3).
c. 1863–67Alfred Armstrong Walton, History of the Landed Tenures of Great Britain and Ireland, from the Norman Conquest to the Present Time (1865)IV/32 no. 1399; cited in the 1863–67 manuscripts (II/4.2, p. 673) and Capital IIIMarx's copy, with his pencil marginalia on pp. 59–119. Walton was an architect and a member of the International.
1866/67James E. Thorold Rogers, A History of Agriculture and Prices in England, vols. 1–2 (1866)Marx to Engels, 17 Dec. 1866 (MEGAdigital M0000208); cited in Capital (II/5, pp. 543, 548, 581)“Ich muß das Buch durchaus ansehn u. habe in einem Kapitel deßwegen eine Lücke gelassen” (I absolutely must look at the book and have left a gap in one chapter because of it). Thorold Rogers built his series from manorial and college accounts.
by 1867George Roberts, The Social History of the People of the Southern Counties of England in Past Centuries (1856)IV/32 no. 1122; Capital I (II/5, p. 579)Municipal bye-laws and local records. Marx's copy has his marginalia.
1867Sir John Fortescue, De laudibus legum Angliae; Thomas More, Utopia; William Harrison, Description of England; Bacon, History of Henry VII; Sir F. M. Eden, State of the PoorCapital I (II/5, pp. 577–79, 592, 596)Fortescue is the only common-law classic that Marx uses, and he uses it as evidence of 15th-century popular wealth.
1868Georg Ludwig von Maurer, Einleitung zur Geschichte der Mark-, Hof-, Dorf- und Stadt-Verfassung; Geschichte der Fronhöfe; Geschichte der Dorfverfassung; again 1876IISG B 111, B 112, B 133; IV/32 no. 880; Marx to Engels, 14 and 25 Mar. 1868Read at the British Museum. See §4 below.
1868Jacob Grimm, Deutsche Rechtsalterthümer (2nd ed., 1854); Carl FraasHefte zur Agrikultur, Heft 2 (IV/18, p. 556); IISG B 112; IV/32 no. 435
1876; 1881August von Haxthausen, Die ländliche Verfassung RußlandsIISG B 138, B 167; IV/32 no. 544The Russian commune.
1879/80Maksim Kovalevsky, Obshchinnoe zemlevladenie (Communal landownership, 1879)IISG B 156; IV/32 no. 697Annotated on almost every page; dedicated to Marx. Edited by Harstick (1977).
—Kovalevsky, Obshchestvennyi stroi Anglii v kontse srednikh vekov (The social structure of England at the end of the Middle Ages, 1880); Collection of unpublished acts and documents on police administration in the English counties in the 12th–14th centuries (London, 1876); history of tax jurisdiction in France (1876)IV/32 nos. 695, 700, 699Presentation copies to Marx. These are archive-based English constitutional history by the Russian historian closest to him. No excerpts are recorded.
1879/80Ludwig Lange, Römische Alterthümer; Karl Bücher, Die Aufstände der unfreien Arbeiter; Robert Sewell, Analytical History of IndiaIISG B 156; IV/32 nos. 723, 175, 1232
1880–82Lewis H. Morgan, Ancient Society; John Budd Phear, The Aryan Village; Henry Sumner Maine, Lectures on the Early History of Institutions; John LubbockIISG B 162 (Morgan, More); IV/32 nos. 915–916The “ethnological notebooks” (ed. Krader 1972). The Maine and Phear titles are from Krader's edition, not checked against our volumes. Marx's library also had Maine's Village-Communities in the East and West (IV/32 no. 824), annotated by its previous owner, Utin.
1881/82F. C. Schlosser, Weltgeschichte für das deutsche Volk; Carlo Botta, Histoire des peuples d'ItalieIISG B 157–160; IV/32 nos. 1194, 152The chronological excerpts, running from the first century BC to the Peace of Westphalia.

Engels

DateWorkWhere recordedNote
by 1853/55List of library books with shelf numbers: Savigny, Geschichte des römischen Rechts im Mittelalter (6 vols.); Grimm, Rechtsalterthümer; Hüllmann, Städteverfassung des Mittelalters; Sartorius, Ursprung der deutschen Hanse; Zimmermann, BauernkriegIV/12, pp. 946–949In Engels's hand. The numbers are probably a library's catalogue numbers; the apparatus is not in our scan.
1869/70Irish history (Prendergast, Davies, the Brehon laws)MEW 32–33; MEGAdigital
1871Blackstone, CommentariesIsaac Hall to Engels, 14 Mar. 1871 (MEGAdigital M9241349)“I wonder at your reading Blackstone. You should read Williams on the Law of real property.” This is the only sign in the whole corpus of anyone in the circle reading the common-law treatise tradition, and it is Engels, not Marx.
—K. F. Eichhorn, Deutsche Staats- und Rechtsgeschichte, 4 vols.IV/32 no. 357Engels's copy, with his pencil marginalia throughout vol. 1.
1882Senckenberg, Corpus iuris feudalis Germanici; MaurerIISG J 22; IV/32 nos. 1226, 880For “Die Mark” and the Frankish-period studies.
22 Dec. 1882Thierry, Histoire de la conquête de l'Angleterre par les NormandsEngels to Marx, MEW 35, p. 137See §4: Engels rejects the conquest theory of serfdom.

8. Method and gaps

  • How Table A was made. I extracted the contents pages, split them at each “Exzerpte aus” (excerpts from), merged continuation runs (“Fortsetzung”, “Schluß”, “Nachtrag”) and corrected about a dozen OCR-damaged titles by hand. The subject classes are mine. The institutional flags come from a sweep of the full notebook texts for feudal, manorial, tenurial, constitutional and antiquarian vocabulary; I read every hit and kept only real ones.
  • Notebooks not searched. These volumes hold most of the rest of the answer:
    • IV/2, the Kreuznach and Paris notebooks of 1843–44. Published descriptions list historical excerpts that include English history and constitution, among them Lord John Russell on the English government and constitution, Lingard and Möser's Patriotische Phantasien. I have not checked this against the volume. If it holds, the 1843 Marx read the English constitution and Möser directly, before turning to political economy.
    • IV/4–5, the Manchester notebooks of 1845, when he copied the library catalogue entries in Table B.
    • The volumes for London notebooks XV–XXIV (1851–53), the period of the Hallam excerpt.
    • IV/18, the agriculture notebooks of 1865–68 (Maurer, Fraas, Grimm).
    • The excerpts of 1879–82 (Kovalevsky; Morgan, Maine, Phear; Schlosser).
  • The single most useful volume to obtain for your question is the one containing IISG B 60, the Hallam excerpts. Hallam's chapters on the feudal system and the English constitution are the only place where Marx can be seen reading Whig constitutional history at length.