MxSMarx's Shakespeare
§8 · 5 entries

Which Shakespeare? What the texts say about editions

Only carefully copied passages can identify an edition. These are the two mottos (A1, A10) and the note Marx describes (C3). The prose quotations agree with every edition where the editions agree, and diverge from all of them where Marx's memory slips.

TestMarxHazlitt, Routledge 1853Steevens text (Tegg; Fleischer 1833)KnightCollier 1853Full variorum
Lear motto, 1853 (A1)"truth, And … so; if not"match"An""An""An""An"
1H4 motto, 1860 (A10)"it is all filled up"no "all""all""all"no "all"no "all" (1821)
"Hiren" note, 1856 (C3)Siren/Hiren in older writersPeele's Irene only"a cant word for a harlot"no Siren noteno Siren noteSteevens's note
Hamlet I.v, People's Paper speech, 1856 (MECW text)"in the earth""i' the earth"earth"ground"earthearth

Two further tests

H2Where the "Hiren / Siren" note comes from
Johnson 1765, vol. IV; Johnson–Steevens 1773, vol. V, pp. 419–20; Malone 1790, vol. V, p. 332, n. 9

The note Marx describes in May 1856 (C3) first appears in the 1773 Johnson–Steevens edition, which was published as "with the corrections and illustrations of various commentators … by Samuel Johnson and George Steevens". That explains why Marx calls it a …

H4Where Marx's Schlegel–Tieck came from: a hypothesis from the Cologne books
B10–B15 (1842–43); A14 (1860); C14 (1864); H3 (1867); G3

Marx quotes Schlegel–Tieck verbatim in 1842–43, so he had a set, or ready access to one, in the Rhineland. His Cologne library stayed in Cologne from May 1849 until December 1860 (G3). The close German quotations of the London years cluster after that date: …

H5The variorum's notes on Timon's gold, and the "common whore" crux
Malone–Boswell, Plays and Poems (1821), vol. XIII, pp. 294, 299, 344, 363–68, 397, 401; Dawson and Minton (eds), Timon of Athens, Arden 3 (2008), pp. 86 n. 1, 275, 286; MEGA² I/2, p. 319; II/5, pp. 89–90

["No, gods, I am no idle votarist", p. 363:] No insincere or inconstant supplicant. Gold will not serve me instead of roots. JOHNSON. — ["Why this / Will lug your priests and servants from your sides", p. 363:] Aristophanes, in his Plutus, Act V. Sc. II. …

  • Excluded: Knight, by "ground" and "An"; Collier, including the 1843 Tauchnitz reprint of his text; Dyce and Delius, by "hindering" in Dream III.ii, a reading still to be checked in the original People's Paper.
  • Most likely: Marx used more than one book from the Johnson–Steevens–Reed family. Hazlitt's 1853 reprint fits the Lear motto. A Steevens-text edition with "all" fits Herr Vogt. In 1856 he consulted a full variorum with Steevens's notes, perhaps at the British Museum (E1–E9).
  • Still to check: the People's Paper of 14–26 Apr 1856 for "earth" and "hind'ring" (MEGA I/15); Hazlitt vol. 1 for Dream and LLL; the Daniels list (G3, G6, H4); the IV/3 apparatus on no. 115; the Morning Advertiser of early Dec 1855 (C1).