[To Le Neve Foster:] I have to thank you for your letter offering me to be proposed as a member of the Society of Arts and beg to say in reply that I shall feel obliged if you will be kind enough to do so at an early opportunity. — [To Davenport:] I have the …
The Society of Arts and South Kensington, 1851–82
Marx's membership of the Society of Arts (1869) is documented in the MEGAdigital letters. The Society itself, the South Kensington Museum and the Department of Science and Art were the work of Henry Cole, so the household's links to them are read here against Elizabeth Bonython and Anthony Burton, The Great Exhibitor: The Life and Work of Henry Cole (London: V&A Publications, 2003), cited as Bonython and Burton; its page numbers are the printed page feet. The book does not mention Marx's membership, Simmonds or Freiligrath, and refers to Marx only through "Marxist solutions" (p. 7). Its 467 indexed names were checked against the whole Marx corpus. Most of the 225 surnames in common are false positives (Petrie, Hooker, Spackman, Cubitt and Chorley are different men or places). The ones that hold up are below.
| Person | Who | What the sources show | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Henry Cole | Chairman of the Society of Arts council from late 1850; head of the Department of Science and Art; director of the South Kensington Museum | Ran the Society as the engine of the 1851 Exhibition; Albert Medal 1871. No evidence that Marx met him. The 1869 conversazione Marx attended was in Cole's museum. See N26. | Bonython and Burton pp. 103, 267; M0001072 |
| Peter Le Neve Foster | Secretary of the Society of Arts, 1853–79 | Invited Marx to be proposed as a member (May 1869). With Cole on the Society's medieval art committee of 1850, beside the antiquaries C. Roach Smith, W. J. Thoms and J. R. Planché, and A. W. Franks as secretary. | M0001046; Bonython and Burton p. 102 |
| P. L. Simmonds | Danish-born writer on commercial products and waste (1814–97) | Named as Marx's proposer, or a signatory of his proposal, by Allan and Whittick, as quoted by Desrochers (2025); not in the Marx letters. See N25. | Desrochers, Recycling 10 (2025), art. 49 |
| Samuel Thomas Davenport | Society of Arts officer | Received Marx's yearly subscription of two guineas, 12 Nov 1869. | M0001216 |
| C. W. Dilke (the younger) | Cole's closest ally; son of the Athenaeum's proprietor | Chairman of the Society's council 1857–58. The family paper is the Athenaeum Freiligrath wrote for from 1855 (N20). Marx later scorns two younger Dilkes (MEW 35). | Bonython and Burton pp. 68, 185 |
| Gottfried Semper | Dresden architect, exile after 1849 | On Kinkel's refugee committee, August 1851; taught Cole's metalwork class from September 1852. See N28. | III/4 p. 195; Bonython and Burton pp. 152, 155, 172–73 |
| Robert Willis | Professor of applied mechanics | Marx attended his experimental course for workers at the Jermyn Street geological institute in January 1863. See N27. | III/12 p. 324 |
| August Wilhelm Hofmann | Director of the Royal College of Chemistry, taken over by Cole's department | Marx attended his lectures in 1865; they lie behind a note in Capital I. See N27. | M0000280; II/5 p. 246; Bonython and Burton p. 256 |
| Lyon Playfair | Chemist; Cole's partner in running the department; Liebig's pupil at Giessen | A contributor to the Museum of Practical Geology's Lectures on Gold (1852); Marx's own copy, used in the Grundrisse and Zur Kritik (N83). Reading Cole's diaries for 13–20 August 1851, Bell concludes that Playfair was "more than anyone" the founder of the South Kensington museum and school; with Cole and Redgrave he ran the Department of Science and Art from 1853, and devised payment by results (N35). | IV/32 no. 757, pp. 405–06; Bonython and Burton pp. 129, 159; Bell p. 247 n.; Howes pp. 163–64, 187 |
| William Morris | Designer, socialist | His firm won two gold medals at Cole's 1862 Exhibition and decorated the Green Dining Room of the South Kensington Museum (1867); in 1882 he told the Royal Commission on Technical Instruction he had used the museum "as much as any man living". From 1881 an occasional, and often absent, judge of the Society's art-workmanship prizes. See N53. | Thompson, Part II ch. I; Howes pp. 205–06 |
| Justus von Liebig | Chemist | The Society's Albert Medal for 1869, the year Marx joined; Liebig's soil-exhaustion argument runs through Capital I. | Bonython and Burton p. 267 |
| Richard and Samuel Redgrave | Cole's Art Superintendent and his brother | Samuel was proposed as an 1851 secretary. Whether the factory inspector Alexander Redgrave, quoted in Capital (II/5 p. 211; X43), belonged to the same family is unverified. Bell (1963) names only Samuel (p. 238) and Richard's Dictionary (p. 209 n.); nothing on Alexander. | Bonython and Burton p. 124 |
| Lord Overstone; Babbage; the Political Economy Club | Economists in Cole's world | Overstone (S. J. Loyd), Marx's "currency principle" banker, sat on the 1851 Commission and guaranteed £10,000; Babbage, whose Economy of Machinery runs through Capital, attacked the Commission; Cole spoke at a Political Economy Club dinner. | Bonython and Burton pp. 58, 122, 131, 135–36 |
| Benjamin Lucraft | Hoxton cabinetmaker, former Chartist; General Council of the International 1864–71 | Spoke for the "working man" at the South Kensington Museum, May 1865; on the Council's 1867 excursion committee; Society of Arts reporter on chairs at Paris, 1867 (X81); left the Council over The Civil War in France. See N30. | Kriegel pp. 1, 179–81; Rifkin p. 102 n. 28; M0000133, M0000972, M1922726 |
| Hermann Jung | Swiss watchmaker in London; General Council, corresponding secretary for Switzerland | Society of Arts reporter on watches at Paris, 1867 (X81); Marx's go-between for placing Communard refugees in 1871–72. See N30, N33. | Rifkin p. 102 n. 28; MEW 33 pp. 267, 410 |
| Edmund Potter | Calico printer; chairman of the Manchester School of Art | His letter to The Times of 24 March 1863 is dissected in Capital I; his evidence of 1864 explains why calico workers stayed away from the art school. See N31. | II/5 pp. 235, 465–67; Macdonald pp. 151–52 |
| George Howell | Bricklayer; founding member of the General Council; secretary of the Reform League | Attacked patronised "Working-Class Exhibitions" in the Council, May 1865; Society of Arts reporter on bricklaying at Paris, 1867. See X81, X78. | GC minutes, 1865; Reports of Artisans (1867) pp. 189–99 |
| Robert Coningsby | Workman and journalist | Denounced by the General Council in 1865 as "the avowed enemy of the working classes"; Society of Arts special reporter on French workers, 1867; "ein Lump" to Marx, 1868. See X78. | GC minutes, May 1865; Reports of Artisans (1867) pp. 428 ff.; M0000882; M5722519 |
| Richard Whiteing | Journalist, later novelist | Society of Arts special reporter on French workers, 1867; wrote to Marx for the New York World, June 1871. See X78. | Reports of Artisans (1867) pp. 452 ff.; M0083500 |
| Carl Pfänder | Miniature painter; General Council member | Returned a borrowed number of the Journal of the Society of Arts to Marx, March 1870. See N25, N38. | M6893416; MEW 33 index |
| Elkington & Co. | Birmingham electroplaters, patentees from 1840 | Communard bronze-workers were told to apply to them in 1871. The firm's electrotypes were part of South Kensington's reproduction programme (from outside knowledge; not checked). See N33. | M1512510; Kriegel p. 97 |
| Edward Aveling | Science lecturer; later Eleanor's partner | Taught evening, then morning, classes in botany and zoology at the Polytechnic College in Regent Street from 1874, giving it as his address until May 1881. Its Educational Department was then run "in association with the Society of Arts, the Science and Art Department in South Kensington and the City of London College" (Kapp, citing the Polytechnic's librarian). | Kapp (Verso, 2018) p. 204 and n. |
| Frederic Harrison | Positivist lawyer (1831–1923). MEW's index calls him "Mitglied der IAA" (member of the International). Royden Harrison (1959) shows the English Positivists advising the International from outside: Beesly declined the General Council, and they formed no section of their own. His membership is therefore unconfirmed. | Helped with the Communard refugees in 1871–72; identified by MEW as the "Herr Harrison" who arbitrated in the dispute over the engraving firm in 1874. See N32, N33. From Royden Harrison (1959; N72):
| MEW 33 pp. 410, 620–21; Royden Harrison (1959) I, pp. 23, 26, 28, 30–31, 40, 45; II, pp. 209, 222–23, 232 |
Entries N30–N35 also draw on four histories of Cole's schools, cited by author: Stuart Macdonald, The History and Philosophy of Art Education (London: University of London Press, 1970); Harry Butterworth, The Science and Art Department 1853–1900, PhD thesis, University of Sheffield, 1968, vol. 2 (page heads); Lara Kriegel, Grand Designs: Labor, Empire, and the Museum in Victorian Culture (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2007); and Adrian Rifkin, "Success Disavowed: The Schools of Design in Mid-Nineteenth-Century Britain (An Allegory)", Journal of Design History 1, no. 2 (1988), pp. 89–102. Ann Cooper, For the Public Good: Henry Cole, His Circle and the Development of the South Kensington Estate, PhD thesis, Open University, 1992, supplies the Society of Arts proposals. None of them mentions Marx's membership of the Society, Lafargue's workshop or Le Moussu.
The section also draws on Quentin Bell, The Schools of Design (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1963; HathiTrust text, printed page numbers), cited as Bell; Anton Howes, Arts and Minds: How the Royal Society of Arts Changed a Nation (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2020), cited as Howes; and E. P. Thompson, William Morris: Romantic to Revolutionary (Oakland, CA: PM Press, 2011), cited by part and chapter. Bell and Thompson do not mention Marx's membership of the Society; Howes mentions only Jenny's verdict (N25). Every "Dyce" in Bell is William Dyce the painter, not Alexander Dyce the Shakespeare editor.
Marx and the Society of Arts
This entry was part of N25 until November 2026; it is cited there under its old heading.
The Society kept a Library and Reading-room at its house in John Street, Adelphi. In the first issue of 1870, six months after Marx's election (N25), the Journal announced that the Library Committee would send every member "a transferable ticket of admission. …
[I/12 p. 206, Gammage at Blackstone Edge, June 1853, as Marx reports him:] They would all recollect that sometime ago, Mr. Slaney had introduced into the House a motion for the appointment of a standing commission, whose business it should be to inquire into …
Cole's Society and his schools
[Bonython and Burton, p. 103:] Towards the end of 1850, Cole became chairman of the council of the Society of Arts … — [p. 179, 1857:] In setting up security arrangements, Cole consulted Panizzi of the British Museum about warding there, on 12 February. — …
[1863:] Um darüber ins Klare zu kommen, habe ich meine Hefte (Auszüge) über Technologie ganz nachgelesen, höre ditto einen praktischen (nur experimentalen) Cursus des Prof. Willis (in Jerminstreet, dem Institut f. Geologie, wo auch Huxley seine Vorlesungen …
Es wurde ein neues provisorisches gewählt, bestehend aus den Herrn Kinkel, Graf Reichenbach, Bucher und dem Sachsen Semper.
Berlin compared
[Engels, 1839, on Leo's attack on the Hegelians:] … denn mag Gans etc. auch im Einzelnen sich von diesen geschieden haben, sie gehörten doch so innig zusammen, daß Leo am wenigsten capabel war, die Differenzpunkte als wichtig zu beweisen. — [Bauer, 1841:] …
[4 July 1864:] In dieser Zeit, wo ich ganz arbeitsunfähig, gelesen: Carpenter, Physiology, Lord ditto, Kölliker Gewebelehre, Spurzheim, Anatomie des Hirns u. Nervensystems, Schwann u. Schleiden über die Zellenscheisse. — [31 Aug 1864:] Es ist mir durch die …