MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N54 · Marx and the Society of Arts

Ernest Jones walks out of the Society of Arts, 1854: the Preston conference and Slaney's limited liability

MEGA² I/12, p. 206, ll. 7–16; I/13, p. 581, ll. 1–8Marx, "Russian Policy against Turkey—Chartism", NYDT, July 1853; "The English Middle Class", NYDT, 1 Aug 1854; Howes pp. 178–81
Original (English)

[I/12 p. 206, Gammage at Blackstone Edge, June 1853, as Marx reports him:] They would all recollect that sometime ago, Mr. Slaney had introduced into the House a motion for the appointment of a standing commission, whose business it should be to inquire into that condition and suggest measures of relief—but such was the determination of the House to evade the question, that on the introduction of the motion, only twenty-six members were present, and the House was counted out. — [I/13 p. 581:] The eyes of the working classes are now fully opened: they begin to cry: "Our St. Petersburg is at Preston!" Indeed, the last eight months have seen a strange spectacle in that town—a standing army of 14,000 men and women subsidized by the trades unions and workshops of all parts of the United Kingdom, to fight out a grand social battle for mastery with the capitalists …

The conferenceDuring the Preston lock-out of 1853–54 the Society of Arts, whose Union of mechanics' institutes included many trade unionists, called a conference of employers and workers' … Marx's sideMarx followed Preston in the Tribune ("British Finances—The Troubles at Preston", I/13; "The English Middle Class", I/13 p. 581). He knew of Slaney from the Chartist platform: the passage …
BearingFifteen years before Marx joined the Society (N25), its leading men tried to settle by conference and company law the class struggle Marx was reporting, and the Chartist who printed Marx walked out. Slaney died after falling through a gap in the floor at the opening of Cole's 1862 Exhibition (Howes p. 181).
Correction"No mention of the Society's conference was found in I/12–13" is wrong. Marx reported it in the Tribune article written 7 Feb 1854 (NYDT no. 4008, 21 Feb 1854), under the heading "The 'Society of Arts' and tricks" (MECW 12, p. 612; quoted in N25). He gives Jones's protest and Owen's speech, and compares the conference to Louis Blanc's Luxembourg Commission of 1848. MECW's sources are the speeches of Jones and Owen "at the meeting of the Society of Arts, January 30, 1854", in the People's Paper no. 92 (4 Feb 1854). MECW's note 413 says the meeting "would not let him speak" and that his comrades walked out; Howes has him cut off by the chair. The article is in MEGA² I/13; the page is still to be found.