N83 · Marx and the Society of Arts
Running list: Marx's reading and the Society of Arts — its library and Journal, its speakers, and the lecturers of Cole's schools
MEGA² II/5 pp. 297, 306, 314, 320, 395; II/6 (bibliography, pp. 1633–69); IV/26 pp. 3–44, 139 ff.; IV/32 nos. 757, 1340, 1433–36Journal of the Society of Arts, vols. 1–30 (1852–82), full texts on archive.org (journalofsociety01soci_0 … 30soci_0) and the JSTOR early-content issues 1852–69; Capital I (1867, 1872), III ch. 37
The libraryThe Society kept a Library and Reading-room at its house in John Street, Adelphi. In the first issue of 1870, six months after Marx's election (N25), the Journal announced that the Library …
MethodThe Journal's accession notices for 1852–82 were extracted (147 blocks) and matched against the bibliography of Capital I (MEGA² II/6), the IV/32 library catalogue and the notebooks; papers …
| Work | Connection with the Society or Cole's schools | Marx's use | References |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. The Society's Journal: papers and reports Marx cites | |||
| J. C. Morton, "On the Forces used in Agriculture" | Paper read at the Society, 7 Dec 1859; printed in the Journal, vol. 8, no. 368 (9 Dec 1859) | Capital I (1867), machinery chapter; again Capital III, ch. 37, n. 32. The II/6 bibliography gives Marx's route as the Economist of 21 Jan 1860. The 1887 English translation misdates the paper "January 1861". | II/5 p. 306; Journal 8, no. 368 |
| J. Forbes Watson, in the discussion of John Crawfurd, "On the Cotton Supply" | Ordinary meeting of 17 Apr 1861; Journal, vol. 9 (19 Apr 1861), p. 399 ff. Watson, the India Office's Reporter on Products, had read his own paper on Indian fibre plants there on 9 May 1860 and won the Society's silver medal. | Capital I (1867) on machine printing: "Paper read by Dr. Watson … before the Society of Arts, 19. April 1861" (the date of the Journal, not of the meeting). The 1887 translation has "17th April, 1860". | II/5 p. 320; Journal 8, p. 618; 9, p. 399 |
| Leone Levi, "On Deer Forests and Highland Agriculture in relation to the Supply of Food" | Paper read at the Society, 21 Mar 1866; Journal, vol. 14 (23 Mar 1866). Levi had spoken there before, on agricultural statistics (1854) and on trade marks. | Note added to the second edition (1872) of Capital I, in the chapter on primitive accumulation: Marx dates the lecture "April 1866" and quotes it on the clearances. | II/6 bibliography; Capital I, 1887 transl., ch. 27 |
| "The Progress of the Nation": report of Alexander Redgrave's lecture at the Bradford Mechanics' Institute, late 1871 | Printed in the Journal, vol. 20, no. 998 (5 Jan 1872), pp. 133–36. Redgrave was "Her Majesty's principal inspector of factories". | Note added to the second edition (1872) of Capital I, machinery chapter: the woollen factories "formerly … filled with women and children, now machinery seems to do all the work". This is the one Capital source taken from the Journal while Marx was a member. | II/6 bibliography; Capital I, 1887 transl., ch. 15, n. 148 |
| Documents of the Society's commission of inquiry into industrial pathology (1854) | Listed in the catalogue of the "Twickenham Economic Museum" of Thomas Twining, a vice-president of the Society | Capital I (1867), on the division of labour and occupational disease | II/5 p. 297; Journal 16, p. 276 (Twining) |
| The Journal itself | The Society's weekly, sent to members | It lists Marx among the candidates proposed (vol. 17, no. 863, 4 June 1869) and elected (no. 867, 2 July 1869, p. 646). Pfänder returned a borrowed number in March 1870, probably no. 898 (N25). | Journal 17, pp. 645–46 |
| B. Books and serials in the Society's library that Marx owned, used or excerpted | |||
| John Yeats, The Growth and Vicissitudes of Commerce (1872); A Manual of Recent and Existing Commerce (1872); The Natural History of the Raw Materials of Commerce (2nd edn 1872); The Technical History of Commerce (1872; Marx's copy 1875). The series is titled "Technical, industrial, and trade education". | All four presented to the Society's library by the author (Journal 22, p. 573, 1 May 1874), with three wall charts "to illustrate lectures" (p. 610). Yeats, master of a middle school at Peckham and "an old member of the Society", sat on its technical-education committee in 1868 (16, p. 276). He read papers on public instruction in the Netherlands (16, p. 284), on "Guilds and their Functions" (29 Jan 1873; 21, p. 177 ff., on the craft guilds and the rise of trade unions) and on middle-class education in Holland (28 Feb 1877; 25, p. 299). At his suggestion (22, p. 720) the Society added "Commercial History and Geography" to its examinations, and he examined in it from 1875 (23, pp. 733, 736). The books were in effect the set texts. | Marx owned all four volumes (IV/32 nos. 1433–36). Three carry his marginalia in pencil and red, blue and green crayon; the Manual has marginalia in another hand. He excerpted the Natural History at length: IV/32 dates the excerpt 1876, while IV/26 prints it among the notebooks of March–September 1878. This is the clearest case of a book on the Society's shelves that Marx worked through, though in his own copy. | IV/32 nos. 1433–36; IV/26 pp. 3–44; Journal 16, 21, 22, 23, 25 |
| Reports of the Inspectors of Factories, half-yearly | Presented to the library by Alexander Redgrave, one report after another from 1869 to 1875: half-years to Oct 1869, Apr 1870, Apr 1871, Apr 1872, Apr and Oct 1873, Apr 1875 | The main English source of Capital I's chapters on the working day and on machinery. The Society's set put a second run within a member's reach. | Journal 18–24, accession notices |
| Transactions of the National Association for the Promotion of Social Science | Presented by the Association for the meetings of 1869, 1870, 1873 and 1875 | Capital I cites the Association's Edinburgh congress of 1863 and its Social Science Review (Richardson on overwork). Engels owned Hutton's two papers from its 1867 Belfast meeting. | II/5 pp. 198, 322; IV/32 no. 588; Journal 18, 19, 22, 24 |
| Massachusetts Bureau of Statistics of Labor, first report (1869–70), and later Massachusetts labour reports | Presented 1870 and (by the American Statistical Association) 1872 | No use by Marx established. In 1878, however, he excerpted the first report of the Ohio bureau (IV/26 pp. 95–122), the same kind of document. | Journal 18 (24 June 1870); 21 (29 Nov 1872) |
| C. Books by lecturers of Cole's Department of Science and Art | |||
| Lectures on Gold. For the instruction of emigrants about to proceed to Australia (Bogue, 1852): Jukes, Edward Forbes, Lyon Playfair, Warington Smyth, John Percy, Robert Hunt | Delivered at the Museum of Practical Geology, Jermyn Street, which passed to Cole's department in 1853 (N27) | Marx's copy ("Bibliothek Marx"), with many dog-eared pages; used in the Grundrisse, the Urtext and Zur Kritik | IV/32 no. 757; II/1.1 pp. 109–11; II/2 pp. 29, 40, 216 |
| T. H. Huxley, Lessons in Elementary Physiology (1866) | Huxley was professor of natural history at the Government School of Mines in Jermyn Street from 1854; Marx names his lectures there in 1863 (N27) | Capital I (1867), on factory air: "Every man should have at least 800 cubic feet." (Huxley) | II/5 p. 395; II/6 bibliography |
| John Tyndall, Heat a Mode of Motion, 4th edn (1870) | Tyndall taught physics at the Government School of Mines (1859–68) as well as at the Royal Institution, where these lectures were given (post from general reference) | Probably Marx's copy, with red-crayon marginalia, probably his, on many pages | IV/32 no. 1340 |
| J. Beete Jukes, The Student's Manual of Geology, 3rd edn, ed. Archibald Geikie (1872) | Jukes lectured on gold at the Museum of Practical Geology (1852) and from 1854 taught geology at the Museum of Irish Industry, later the Royal College of Science for Ireland, the department's Dublin college. Geikie was of the Geological Survey, also under the department. | Excerpted by Marx in 1878, the largest block of IV/26; a review of IV/31 also lists Jukes among its sources | IV/26 pp. 139 ff. |
| A. W. Hofmann, Introduction to Modern Chemistry (1865), the printed form of his Royal College of Chemistry lectures | Marx attended these lectures in 1865 (N27) | Unconfirmed. Reviews of IV/31 connect Marx's chemistry notes of 1877–83 with Hofmann, but none checked here names this book. | II/5 p. 246 (the 1865 note) |
| Robert Willis | Gave the course for workers at Jermyn Street that Marx attended in 1863 (N27) | No book by Willis found in Capital's bibliography or in IV/32 | III/12 p. 324 |
| D. Authors Marx cites who spoke at the Society | |||
| H. D. Macleod, "The Modern Science of Economics" | Paper read 22 Jan 1879, during Marx's membership; Journal, vol. 27 (24 Jan 1879), p. 135 ff. | Marx cites Macleod's Theory and Practice of Banking in Capital I, without sympathy; no sign that he read the paper | II/6 bibliography; Journal 27, p. 135 |
| W. T. Thornton, paper on irrigation in India | Read in 1878, during Marx's membership; Journal, vol. 26, p. 272 ff. | Capital I cites Thornton's Over-population and its Remedy (1846) three times | II/5 pp. 113, 124, 578 |
| David Urquhart, "On the Art of Constructing Turkish Baths, and their Economy as a Means of Cleanliness" | Paper read 26 Feb 1862, the Duke of Wellington in the chair; Journal, vol. 10 (28 Feb 1862), p. 220 ff. | Marx owned and marked several of Urquhart's books; Capital I quotes Familiar Words on the division of labour | IV/32 nos. 1344–51; II/5 pp. 297, 410, 600 |
| Edmund Potter, lecture on calico printing | "A lecture delivered before this Society by Mr. E. Potter, M.P.", cited in the Journal in 1862; its own date has not been found | Capital I dissects Potter's letter to the Times of 24 Mar 1863 (N31) | Journal 10 (1862) |
| E. The Exhibitions | |||
| The Industry of Nations, pt II: A Survey of the Existing State of Arts, Machines, and Manufactures (SPCK, 1855) | The sequel to pt I (1852), a survey of the materials of industry as shown at the Society's Great Exhibition of 1851 (from general reference) | Capital I on the slide rest and machine tools | II/5 p. 314 |
| "The International Exhibition", Standard, 19 Sept 1862 | Cole's 1862 Exhibition (X70) | Cited in Capital I | II/6 bibliography |
| F. Engels's books of the same kind | |||
| J. Clerk Maxwell, Theory of Heat, 4th edn (1875), in Longmans' "Text-books of science adapted for the use of artisans and students in public and science schools" | A series written for the science schools and examinations of the Department of Science and Art | Engels's copy, with his marginalia; used in the Dialectics of Nature | IV/32 no. 881 |
| Edward Aveling, An Introduction to the Study of Botany (1891) | "Specially adapted for … candidates for the Science and Art Department examination in botany" | Engels's library | IV/32 no. 48 |