MxSMarx's Shakespeare
Registers

Meetings of the New Shakspere Society, 1874–1886

Every meeting of the New Shakspere Society recorded in its Transactions: who took the chair, the papers read and who read them, who spoke in the discussion, the business done, and anyone else the record places in the room. 112 meetings, from the opening meeting of 13 March 1874 to the 117th on 11 June 1886.

The sources are the Notices of Meetings printed in the Transactions for 1874, 1875–6 and 1877–9 (meetings 1–56), and the Monthly Abstract of Proceedings bound with the Transactions for 1880–6 (meetings 72–117). No notices for meetings 57–71 (January 1880 to June 1881) were found in the scans; those rows give the papers whose printed headnotes say at which meeting they were read, and the programmes announced in advance in the weekly list of meetings in the Journal of the Society of Arts (edited from 1879 by H. B. Wheatley). Announced papers are marked; not all were read on the day. The Society met until 1894, but no record of the meetings after June 1886 was found. Everything here was read from the Internet Archive OCR of the Toronto copies. Names and dates damaged in the OCR are flagged in the notes, and nothing has been checked against the page images.

Also placed at the meeting lists people the record shows were in the room without their having read a paper or spoken: someone who volunteered, read a list, or is said to be present. The chair, the readers of papers and the speakers were present by definition. Members announced as newly joined are not counted as present. Eleanor Marx appears five times: as a new member (12 May 1876), volunteering to translate Delius (10 Nov 1876), reading her translation (8 Dec 1876), her own paper "How Shakspere became Popular in Germany" (9 April 1880, known from the printed paper, dossier N92), and speaking twice in the discussion of 10 March 1882.

Sort by clicking a heading. Drag rows by ⠿ (or focus the handle and press ↑ or ↓) to reorder; this browser remembers the order. The source link searches the scan for the meeting's heading. See also the Society's publications.

Source
113 Mar 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Metrical Tests as applied to Dramatic Poetry, Part I: Shakspere — F. G. Fleay (read by E. A. Abbott)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, E. A. Abbott, A. J. Ellis, Brinsley Nicholson, Eugene OswaldJ. W. Snelgrove — read the list of new members as Hon. SecretaryOpening meeting at University College, Gower Street, 8 p.m. Furnivall's inaugural address on the Society's aims (printed from the shorthand writers' notes). Proofs of three papers by Fleay laid on the table. The Hon. Secretary read the names of new members: the Society had 247 members on its first evening. Thanks voted to Karl Elze for his paper "Zu Heinrich VIII". The Director read a letter from Baron Albert Grant proposing a statue of Shakspere in Leicester Square.
"Marx, Francis" in the list of new members is Francis Marx, not a relation of Karl Marx.
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
227 Mar 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Metrical Tests, Part II: Fletcher, Beaumont, Massinger — F. G. Fleay (read by E. A. Abbott)
F. J. Furnivall, E. A. Abbott, Brinsley Nicholson, J. W. HalesJ. W. Snelgrove — read the list of new membersMadame Gervinus, widow of G. G. Gervinus, becomes a Vice-President. New members read (among them Lucy Toulmin Smith, Miss E. Phipson, Mrs Furnivall, Alfred Vezin). Proofs distributed of Fleay's appendixes, his Taming of the Shrew paper, and the Appendix with Spedding on Henry VIII and Hickson on The Two Noble Kinsmen. Extra meeting announced for 10 July.
A letter from James Spedding on the rhyme test was read in the discussion.
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
324 Apr 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Authorship of the Taming of the Shrew, with Remarks on Titus Andronicus — F. G. Fleay (read by E. A. Abbott)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, A. J. Ellis, E. A. Abbott, Brinsley Nicholson, H. B. WheatleyProofs of Fleay's papers on Timon and Pericles distributed. Prince Leopold becomes a Vice-President. New members read (among them James Spedding, Dr J. Todhunter, P. A. Taylor, M.P., and Mrs P. A. Taylor).Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
48 May 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Authorship of Timon of Athens — F. G. Fleay (read by E. A. Abbott)
  • On the Play of Pericles — F. G. Fleay (summarised by F. J. Furnivall)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, Brinsley Nicholson, E. A. Abbott, P. A. DanielH. H. Gibbs appointed a Vice-President; new branches at Montreal and at Owens College, Manchester. New members read (among them Miss Marshall and J. G. Fitch). The Director proposed that the next meeting also discuss Clark and Wright's theory of Middleton's hand in the witch-scenes of Macbeth.
Furnivall said Fleay's portions of Pericles matched those Tennyson had picked out as Shakspere's forty years before, and read to him the previous autumn.
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
522 May 1874Tom Taylor (Vice-President)
  • On the Porter in Macbeth — J. W. Hales (read by the author)
Tom Taylor, F. J. Furnivall, Eugene Oswald, Miss Marshall, J. W. HalesThe Countess of Ducie appointed a Vice-President. New members read.
Hales proposed the literary connection between Milton and Shakspere as a future subject.
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
612 Jun 1874A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • On certain Plays of Shakspere of which Portions were written at different Periods of his Life (Richard II; All's Well; Two Gentlemen and Twelfth Night; Troilus and Cressida) — F. G. Fleay (read partly by E. A. Abbott, partly by F. J. Furnivall)
F. J. Furnivall, G. W. Eusden, E. A. Abbott, Eugene Oswald, W. Collet, A. J. EllisNew members read.Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
726 Jun 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On two Plays of Shakspere's altered by other hands: Macbeth and Julius Caesar — F. G. Fleay (read by F. D. Matthew)
  • Mr Halliwell's Hint on the date of Coriolanus — F. J. Furnivall
F. J. Furnivall, Joseph Payne, F. D. Matthew, J. W. HalesBrinsley Nicholson joins the Committee. New members read. Allan Park Paton's "Notes on North's Plutarch" presented.
Halliwell's "Hint" was read by Furnivall, who reported its reception to him by letter next day. Halliwell was not present: his part came by post (Spevack pp. 502, 506; dossier N113).
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
810 Jul 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Political Use of the Stage in Shakspere's Time — Richard Simpson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, J. W. Hales, Brinsley Nicholson, E. A. AbbottFleay's retirement from the Committee reported; Nicholson appointed. New members read (among them Leslie Stephen and W. J. Rolfe). Furnivall reviewed the session and reported the Committee's resolutions: a Revision Committee (Furnivall, Abbott, Hales) to oversee printing; meetings once a month, on the second Friday from October to June; the printing of texts and parallel texts to be the Society's primary object; speakers to supply written abstracts of their remarks. Meetings adjourned to 9 October.Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
99 Oct 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Politics of Shakspere's Historical Plays — Richard Simpson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, F. D. Matthew, E. A. AbbottNew members read (among them H. Buxton Forman and E. H. Pickersgill). The first two publications produced (Allusion-Books Part I, Transactions Part I). Daniel's Romeo and Juliet texts reported in type. Papers promised by Richard Grant White, W. T. Malleson and Prof. Seeley.Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
1013 Nov 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Weak Endings of Shakspere — J. K. Ingram (read by A. J. Ellis)
A. J. Ellis, F. J. Furnivall, Richard SimpsonPrince Leopold to present the parallel-text Romeo and Juliet. Ingleby to give members copies of "The Still Lion". Guizot and Abbott elected Vice-Presidents. New members read. W. J. Craig to edit Cymbeline.Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
1111 Dec 1874F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Hamlet's inserted speech of "a dozen or sixteen lines" — W. T. Malleson (read by the author)
  • Answer to Mr Malleson — J. R. Seeley (read by F. J. Furnivall)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, Peter Bayne, E. H. Pickersgill, Brinsley Nicholson, W. T. Malleson, Lewis JarvisNew members read (among them Peter Bayne, W. Collet and Dr W. Legg). Discussion of the play of Cymbeline, the evening's second subject.
Cymbeline discussion opened by Furnivall and continued by Nicholson and Jarvis.
Transactions 1874, Notices of Meetings
128 Jan 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Two Quartos of Hamlet, 1603, 1604 — E. A. Abbott (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, Brinsley Nicholson, E. A. AbbottNew members read (among them Alfred Ainger). Thanks voted to Prince Leopold for the parallel-text Romeo and Juliet, to P. A. Daniel for editing it (he had stayed in England to finish it), to Ingleby for 370 copies of The Still Lion, and to Furnivall for 500 copies of his Introduction to Gervinus. Transactions 1874 Part II at press; Nicholson's Henry V reprints to go to the printer. Thanks to the officers for the past year.
Abbott argued that Q1 was a pirate's alteration; Furnivall, Simpson and Nicholson held that it represented an earlier version.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
1312 Feb 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Comedies of Mucedorus and Faire Em — Richard Simpson (read by the author)
  • On a New Metrical Test (the speech-ending test), a letter — J. K. Ingram (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Notes on German Shakspere Literature — Edward Dowden (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Extracts from a lecture on Characteristics of Ben Jonson — E. H. Pickersgill (read by the author)
Richard Simpson, Brinsley Nicholson, F. J. FurnivallNew members read. The audited accounts for 1874 presented (auditors H. B. Wheatley and H. Smart). Next meeting to be a "Scratch Night".
H. C. Hart's promised paper was withdrawn when he became botanist to the Arctic Expedition.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
1412 Mar 1875Tom Taylor (Vice-President)
  • For an early date (not later than 1601) for Julius Caesar — J. W. Hales (read by the author)
  • On "Evening Mass" in Romeo and Juliet — Richard Simpson
  • On "a sea of troubles" in Hamlet — Brinsley Nicholson
Tom Taylor, F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, Brinsley NicholsonNew members read. Halliwell trying to arrange a search of Lady Barnard's house for Shakspere papers. Spedding's Richard III paper to be printed in advance of the next meeting.
The "Scratch Night" of short papers. The Halliwell item is the Director's announcement. Halliwell was not present: his part came by post (Spevack pp. 502, 506; dossier N113).
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
159 Apr 1875A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • On the bond-story in the Merchant of Venice and a version of it in the Cursor Mundi — Lucy Toulmin Smith (read by the author)
  • On the Quarto and Folio of King Lear — Nicolaus Delius (taken as read)
  • On the Corrected Edition of Richard III — James Spedding (read by F. J. Furnivall)
F. D. Matthew, Brinsley Nicholson, E. H. Pickersgill, W. Aldis WrightNicolaus Delius — "who was present at the meeting" (Matthew summarised his Jahrbuch paper)New members reported by the Hon. Secretary.
Lucy Toulmin Smith is the first woman recorded reading her own paper.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
1614 May 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The Date of King John — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
  • On the Old Hamlet — Richard Simpson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, E. H. Pickersgill, Brinsley NicholsonHalliwell presented 600 copies of A. H. Paget's essay on stage history. Furnivall reported on interest in Shakspere at Dublin. New members read.
Thanks "had been expressed" to Halliwell, i.e. by letter. Halliwell was not present: his part came by post (Spevack pp. 502, 506; dossier N113).
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
1711 Jun 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Originals of Shakspere's Plots — H. B. Wheatley (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, J. W. Hales, Lucy Toulmin Smith, E. H. PickersgillF. Chance and Miss L. B. Courtenay reported as new members.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
188 Oct 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Notes on Mr Daniel's Theory of the Relation of the First and Second Quartos of Romeo and Juliet — James Spedding (read by F. D. Matthew)
  • Answer to Mr Spedding — P. A. Daniel (read by F. D. Matthew)
  • On the Elf-locks in Romeo and Juliet — J. Wickham Legg
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, E. A. Abbott, Richard Simpson, A. J. Ellis, E. H. PickersgillOpening of the third session; membership over 500. The Society's publications given to public schools as prizes. Originals and Analogues Part I ready. New members read.
The record says the balance of opinion favoured Daniel.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
1912 Nov 1875A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • The Growth of Hamlet (selections) — Richard Simpson (read by the author)
  • The Early Dates of Pericles and Timon — R. Cartwright (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Richard Simpson, A. J. EllisNew members announced. Prince Leopold offered 50 copies of the parallel-text Romeo and Juliet for free libraries and mechanics' institutes.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2010 Dec 1875F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Play of Edward III — F. J. Furnivall (read by the author)
none namedNew members announced (a long list).
Furnivall could not accept Tennyson's view that the Countess scenes were Shakspere's.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2114 Jan 1876A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • Gruach: Lady Macbeth — Countess of Charlemont (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Rough Notes on Cymbeline — W. J. Craig (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, A. J. Ellis, John TodhunterThomas Beggs and L. E. Shaw reported as new members.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2211 Feb 1876F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Hamlet and Ophelia — John Todhunter (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, F. D. Matthew, John TodhunterNew members (among them the Countess of Charlemont). Accounts for 1875 read (auditors A. J. Abbott and H. Smart): subscriptions £577 19s., expenditure £571 5s. The Earl of Derby to pay for a tract; Furnivall chose Stafford's Compendious Examination (1581).Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2310 Mar 1876A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • The Links between Shakspere's Early Plays and his late Middle-time Comedies — F. J. Furnivall (read by the author)
A. J. Ellis, J. N. Hetherington, F. D. Matthew, Peter Bayne, Brinsley NicholsonNew members announced. Mrs Bidder to give £10 towards a reprint. Grosart may provide more tracts. Peter Bayne to read on Brutus next session. The paper intended for the evening was lost by the death of Colonel Cunningham.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2428 Apr 1876F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Character of Othello and its resemblances to Hamlet (first part) — Frank Marshall (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, R. Cartwright, Joseph KnightNew members (among them Roden Noel). Death of Richard Simpson announced; a resolution of condolence to Mrs Simpson. Delius's promised paper on the epic elements had not arrived. Later papers rearranged.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2512 May 1876F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the approximate date of Othello, from Marston's Parasitaster — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
  • On the Borrowings from Venus and Adonis and from Ben Jonson in Baron's Pocula Castalia (1640) — Brinsley Nicholson
  • On the Character of Banquo — Algernon Foggo (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, R. Cartwright, Harold Littledale, Peter Bayne, Brinsley NicholsonEleanor Marx, H. Burdach and N. D. Chubb reported as new members. A letter from Mrs Simpson read. Simpson's School of Shakspere finished in manuscript. Norden's map of London for Harrison Part I in hand.
Eleanor Marx. Reported as a new member: "Mrs [sic, for Miss] E. Marx, Mr H. Burdach, and Mr N. D. Chubb were reported to have become Members since the last Meeting." She joined between 28 April and 12 May 1876.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
269 Jun 1876F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Political Element in Massinger — S. R. Gardiner (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, J. W. Hales, Peter Bayne, Frederick WedmoreNew members reported. Thanks to the Council of University College for the use of the room, before the summer recess.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2713 Oct 1876A. J. Ellis (Vice-President)
  • On the 2nd and 3rd Parts of Henry VI and their Originals — Jane Lee (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Remarks anticipating Miss Lee's views — Richard Grant White (read by F. J. Furnivall)
A. J. Ellis, Peter Bayne, F. J. Furnivall, R. CartwrightOpening of the fourth session. A letter from Richard Grant White, unable to attend. Long list of new members. William Payne retires as Treasurer; H. Courthope Bowen, headmaster of the Grocers' Company's Schools, succeeds him.Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
2810 Nov 1876F. D. Matthew
  • The Character of Hamlet not entitled to the admiration often bestowed upon it — F. J. Furnivall (read by the author)
Joseph Knight, E. H. Pickersgill, Peter Bayne, F. D. Matthew, John Todhunter, F. J. FurnivallEleanor Marx — volunteered at the meeting to translate Delius
Mrs Bayne — written remarks read in the discussion (probable)
New members announced. Thanks for gifts of texts: Richard Johnson (Two Noble Kinsmen, revised), the Earl of Derby (Stafford), Mrs Bidder, Harold Littledale and Stopford Brooke (Spalding's Letter), F. W. Cosens, Miss Phipson and Furnivall (the Tell-Troth volume). Daniel to edit the Henry V parallel texts in place of the ailing Nicholson. Next year's books outlined. Furnivall asked for a volunteer to translate the second part of Delius's paper on narration, and Eleanor Marx undertook it. Prof. Corson to come from the United States in June.
Eleanor Marx. "The Director also asked for a Volunteer to translate, for the Transactions, the 2nd part of Prof. Delius's Paper on the Narrative Element in Shakspere's Plays, and Miss Eleanor Marx kindly undertook to make the translation."
A letter from H. H. Furness agreeing that Hamlet vacillated was read.
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
298 Dec 1876F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Notes on Ben Jonson's Every Man in his Humour — H. B. Wheatley (read by the author)
  • Readings in The Passionate Pilgrim ("by holy"; "Fancy's partial might") — E. G. Doggett and F. J. Furnivall
  • Shakspere's Use of Narrative in his Plays, Part II — Nicolaus Delius (translated and read by Eleanor Marx)
F. J. Furnivall, H. B. Wheatley, F. D. MatthewEleanor Marx — read her translation of Delius in place of an intended paper by Frank MarshallIngleby offered the second edition of his Centurie of Prayse. New members reported (among them Mandell Creighton and the printer Stephen Austin).
Eleanor Marx. "In place of an intended Paper by Mr Marshall, Miss Marx then read a translation which she had made of the 2nd part of a Paper by Prof. Delius … Thanks were voted to Prof. Delius and Miss Marx, and the Director mentioned that Prof. Delius had been much gratified by the able way in which his Paper had been rendered into English."
Transactions 1875–6, Notices of Meetings
3012 Jan 1877F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Some Points of Resemblance and Contrast between Shakspere and the Dramatists of his Country and Epoch — Joseph Knight (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, F. D. Matthew, Lucy Toulmin SmithDeath of Charles Childs, the Society's printer, announced; a letter of condolence to his family resolved. New members (among them Edward Rose, W. G. Stone and Mrs F. Wedmore). Accounts for 1876 presented (auditors Samuel Clark junior and N. D. Chubb).Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
319 Feb 1877F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Hamlet's "some Dozen or Sixteen Lines" — C. M. Ingleby (read by the author)
  • The Division into Acts of Hamlet — Edward Rose (read by the author)
W. T. Malleson, F. J. Furnivall, C. M. Ingleby, Peter Bayne, J. N. Hetherington, Mr Peto, T. A. Spalding, W. A. HarrisonLong list of new members. A letter from Mrs Childs thanking the members. Furnivall reported Guizot's suggestion that the Englished Appian (1578) was the source of the Brutus and Antony speeches.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
329 Mar 1877F. D. Matthew
  • On the Witches in Macbeth — T. A. Spalding (read by the author)
  • Prof. March's arguments for the youthfulness of Hamlet — reported by F. J. Furnivall
  • On Troilus and Cressida — Richard Grant White
  • On the Confusion of Time in the Merry Wives — Richard Grant White
  • The speeches of Brutus and Antony from the Englished Appian (1578) — read by F. J. Furnivall
F. D. Matthew, Peter Bayne, J. N. Hetherington, Mr Peto, T. A. Spalding, F. J. Furnivall, Miss HickeyNew members handed in.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
3313 Apr 1877Karl Elze (Vice-President, of Halle)
  • On the Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar — Peter Bayne (read by the author)
  • Notes on the opening bridal song in The Two Noble Kinsmen — Edward Dowden (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • On the Division of the Acts in Lear, Much Ado, and Twelfth Night — James Spedding (read by F. J. Furnivall)
F. J. Furnivall, Frederick Wedmore, F. D. Matthew, J. N. Hetherington, E. H. PickersgillKarl Elze — in the chairElze's address from the chair on German Shakspere scholarship and the kinship of the two countries. New members (among them Signor Pagliardini). Furnivall thanked Elze at the close.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
3411 May 1877F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Songs of Shakspere — J. W. Ebsworth (read by the author)
  • On the Triple Endings in the Fletcher part of Henry VIII (against Swinburne) — F. J. Furnivall
F. J. Furnivall, J. N. Hetherington, Lewis JarvisT. A. Spalding elected to the Committee. New members reported.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
359 Jun 1877Tom Taylor (Vice-President)
  • On Shakspere's Versification — Hiram Corson of Cornell (read by the author)
Tom Taylor, F. J. Furnivall, Frank MarshallHiram Corson — came from the United States to read his paperNew members announced. J. W. Hales retires from the Committee.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
3612 Oct 1877F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Mistakes in Halpin's Short-Time Analysis of the Merchant of Venice — P. A. Daniel (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Scraps: Iago's "squadron" (Daniel); Touchstone's "feature" (W. Wilkins); quotations of 1640 and 1645 (Brinsley Nicholson); "W. H." of the Sonnets and other notes (Furnivall) — read by F. J. Furnivall
F. J. Furnivall, F. D. Matthew, J. N. Hetherington, R. J. Gilman, Lewis Jarvis, Signor Pagliardini, Edward RoseNew members reported. Gifts: £5 from Mrs Richard Simpson; pamphlets by A. P. Paton and T. H. Hall Caine (on Richard III). Furnivall reviewed the Society's work of the past year and a half. Scraps read; Grosart's tracing of a doubtful "Johne Ford, 1641" signature exhibited.
The date is illegible in the OCR; 12 October 1877 is the second Friday of the month, the Society's rule.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
379 Nov 1877Tom Taylor (Vice-President)
  • On King John (the play and its old original) — Edward Rose (read by the author)
Tom Taylor, F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, J. N. Hetherington, Edward RoseLong list of new members announced.
Rose's paper was afterwards accepted by Macmillan's Magazine.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
3814 Dec 1877James Gairdner
  • The Sources of Henry V — W. G. Stone (read)
James Gairdner, J. N. Hetherington, F. D. Matthew, Edward Rose, F. J. FurnivallMrs K. R. Dowd, Mrs A. C. Sanford and T. O. Harding reported as new members.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
3911 Jan 1878F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The First Quarto of Romeo and Juliet: is there any Evidence of a Second Hand? — T. A. Spalding (read by the author)
  • On the "other business" in The Tempest, I. ii — W. Wilkins (read by F. J. Furnivall)
none namedNew members announced. Accounts for 1877 handed in (auditors H. B. Wheatley and Samuel Clark junior). Thanks to the Council of University College for the room.
The record names no speakers; it says only that Wilkins's view "was not endorsed by the Meeting".
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
408 Feb 1878William Chappell
  • Shakspere's Knowledge and Use of Old Ballads — J. W. Ebsworth (read by the author; several ballads sung)
William Chappell, F. J. FurnivallWilliam Chappell announced as a new member. A letter from Prof. Pulling on the speech-ending test applied to Romeo and Juliet and Cymbeline.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
418 Mar 1878Frank A. Marshall
  • On As You Like It — H. Courthope Bowen (read by the author)
Frank A. Marshall, F. J. Furnivall, J. N. Hetherington, F. D. Matthew, Eugene Oswald, Edward Rose, W. A. Harrison, H. Courthope BowenTransactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4213 Apr 1878H. Courthope Bowen (Treasurer)
  • On Love's Labour's Lost — Walter H. Pater
  • Some Remarks concerning the Introductory Scene of 2 Henry IV — Prof. Hagena, with a letter by P. A. Daniel
  • On Hamlet as the greatest of Shakspere's Plays — M. Wynell Mayow
H. Courthope Bowen, F. J. Furnivall, J. N. Hetherington, James Spedding, Miss Peto, M. Wynell MayowNew members announced. Thanks to Karl Warnke and Ludwig Proescholdt for their edition of Mucedorus. Furnivall announced the series of photolithographic Quarto facsimiles by W. Griggs under his superintendence, sanctioned by the Committee.
The OCR of the discussion is badly garbled; the names are read with some doubt. Whether Pater read his own paper is not stated in the passage read.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4310 May 1878F. D. Matthew
  • On Elizabethan Demonology — T. A. Spalding (read by the author)
F. D. Matthew, F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, M. Wynell Mayow, Edward Rose, E. H. Pickersgill, W. A. Harrison, T. A. SpaldingNew members announced. A paper on The Winter's Tale promised for October.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4414 Jun 1878F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Caliban — Frederick Wedmore (read in his absence by Peter Bayne)
  • Shakspere's "New Map" in Twelfth Night — C. H. Coote of the British Museum Map Department
  • On the Element of Chance in the Merchant of Venice — William Malleson (read by F. J. Furnivall)
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, T. A. Spalding, J. N. Hetherington, Edward Rose, M. Wynell MayowEdward FitzGerald and the Universal Library, Leipzig, announced as new members. The Committee made Ingleby a Vice-President, and Peter Bayne and Edward Rose members of the Committee.
"Mr E. Fitzgerald" among the new members may be the translator of Omar Khayyám; the record gives no more. One further speaker on Wedmore's paper is illegible in the OCR.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4511 Oct 1878F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Notes on "fret" in Julius Caesar, II. i. 103–4 — John Ruskin (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • On the Anachronisms in The Winter's Tale — J. W. Mills (read by F. D. Matthew)
  • Extracts from the Lord Chamberlain's records on the King's players — Walford D. Selby (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • The site of "The Theatre" — G. H. Overend (read by F. J. Furnivall)
none namedOpening of the sixth session; Furnivall congratulated the members on the hold the chronological study of Shakspere had gained. A long list of new members for the past three months.
No discussion recorded.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
468 Nov 1878F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Times and Durations of the Actions of Shakspere's Plays, Part I: the Comedies — P. A. Daniel (read by F. J. Furnivall)
Edward Rose, Brinsley Nicholson, Joseph Knight, J. N. Hetherington, F. J. FurnivallH. C. Bowen gives up the Treasurership; T. A. Spalding appointed in his place. Prof. Storojenko of Moscow appointed a Vice-President. New members handed in.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4713 Dec 1878F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The Times or Durations of the Action of Shakspere's Plays, Part II: the Tragedies — P. A. Daniel (read by F. J. Furnivall)
Brinsley Nicholson, Peter Bayne, Edward Rose, Joseph Knight, E. H. Pickersgill, F. J. FurnivallThe Earl of Pembroke and Lady Southampton elected Vice-Presidents. A letter from Frank Marshall on Hamlet read.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4810 Jan 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Casket Story in the Merchant of Venice — James Pierce (read by Sir Philip Magnay)
  • Animal versus Human Nature in King Lear — J. Kirkman
F. J. Furnivall, William Malleson, H. P. Stokes, F. D. Matthew, Peter Bayne, Sir Philip Magnay, Emma Phipson, Miss Hickey, Lewis Jarvis, J. KirkmanAccounts for 1878 handed in (auditors Samuel Clark and H. Smart). Giulio Carcano of Milan, translator of Shakspere, elected a Vice-President.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
4914 Feb 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Growth of Shakspere, as witnessed by the Characters of his Fools — J. N. Hetherington (read by the author)
  • On the Relation between the First Quarto (1600) and First Folio of Henry V — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, A. J. Ellis, E. H. PickersgillNew members: J. S. Thorpe, Miss Redpath, James Hay, Henry Sedgwick, Miss Sandell.
Hetherington's paper was printed in the Cornhill Magazine, autumn 1879.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5014 Mar 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Which is the next greatest of Shakspere's Plays after Hamlet? — M. Wynell Mayow (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, T. A. Spalding, Peter Bayne, Edward Rose, Thomas Tyler, Miss HickeyFurnivall read Robert Browning's letter agreeing to become President; resolved with great pleasure, and thanks voted to Furnivall. New members reported.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5125 Apr 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Falstaff and his Satellites from the Windsor Observatory — J. W. Ebsworth
  • The Natural History Similes in Henry VI — Emma Phipson (read by the author)
none namedNew members announced (among them Timothy Holmes and Mrs Holmes).
"Discussions took place on both Papers"; no names given. The day of the month is damaged in the OCR ("April L>5"); 25 April 1879 was a Friday.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
529 May 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Sudden Emotion: its effect on different characters, as shown in Shakspere — Edward Rose
  • A suggested emendation in Macbeth, V. v. 9 — Wyke Bayliss (rejected by the meeting)
  • Shakspere's Reconciliation with the World, as exhibited in the Plays of the Fourth Period — Thomas Tyler (read by the author)
W. A. Harrison, T. A. SpaldingNew members announced.
J. O. Halliwell-Phillipps among the new members announced; he had not been a member before.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5313 Jun 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Genesis of The Tempest — B. F. de Costa (read by Edward Rose)
  • The Times or Durations of the Action, Part III: the Histories — P. A. Daniel
  • Notes: hebenon as henbane (H. N. Ellacombe); "the soul of adoration" in Henry V (Sidney Herington); scraps on rush-rings and other matters (Mr Hart, Furnivall and others)
F. J. Furnivall, Edward Rose, W. A. Harrison, Thomas Tyler, Peter BayneThomas Tyler announced as a member. Thanks for Signor Carcano's translation of Shakspere. Thanks to University College for the room.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5417 Oct 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Memoranda on the Midsummer Night's Dream (that the play was not written before 1596) — J. O. Halliwell-Phillipps (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • The Dispute between George Maller, glazier and trainer of players to Henry VIII, and Thomas Arthur, his pupil — G. H. Overend (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • On Shakspere's Immortals: the Spirit Creations of Shakspere — Harry Beighton (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, Joseph Knight, Thomas Tyler, W. A. Harrison, J. N. Hetherington, F. D. Matthew, Edward Rose, H. B. WheatleyThanks to Ingleby for the Centurie of Prayse; further allusions to be issued on fly-leaves. Stone's Henry V and Craig's Cymbeline nearly finished; the Digby Mysteries almost all in type. New members announced. Thanks to Halliwell-Phillipps for 25 copies of his Memoranda.
Wheatley spoke, with Furnivall and Tyler, on Beighton's paper. Halliwell-Phillipps's dating was "not accepted by any of the Members present". Furnivall to Halliwell the same night: "in the Meeting of 30, there was not one person who agreed with you" (Spevack p. 506), the only head-count found for an ordinary meeting. Halliwell was not present: his part came by post (Spevack pp. 502, 506; dossier N113).
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5514 Nov 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Hebenon in Hamlet — Brinsley Nicholson
  • Notes on hebenon — Frank Marshall
  • Shylock defended; Portia questioned — "a Lady" (Mrs Boole, who read it herself)
  • Essex is not the Turtle-dove of the Phoenix and Turtle — F. J. Furnivall
  • Prof. Ingram's Speech-ending Test applied to 20 Plays — F. Pulling
  • Puck's "swifter than the moon's sphere" and Shakspere's Astronomy — F. J. Furnivall
J. Kirkman, Brinsley Nicholson, F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, Frank Marshall, J. N. Hetherington, Edward Rose, Timothy HolmesMrs Boole — read her own paperC. G. Clement, T. M. Lockwood, William Watson and J. A. Jacob reported as new members.
The record gives only "Mrs Boole"; who she was is not established here.
Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5612 Dec 1879F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On the Evidence that Shakspere was, in Troilus and Cressida, rewriting an old Play — J. W. Mills (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Are the Philosophizings of Achilles and of Aufidius Mistakes in Characterization? — F. J. Furnivall
  • A Note on hebenon — Thomas Tyler
F. J. Furnivall, J. N. Hetherington, Joseph Knight, Edward Rose, Brinsley Nicholson, Thomas Tyler, W. A. HarrisonC. B. Cowper-Coles reported as a new member. J. N. Hetherington elected to the Committee from January, in place of Dr G. H. Kingsley.Transactions 1877–9, Notices of Meetings
5723 Jan 1880—
  • The Inconsistency of the Time in Shakspere's Plays — Edward Rose
none named
Known only from the headnote to the printed paper (Transactions 1880–6, Part I). The meeting number is damaged in the OCR ("VI th"); 57th follows from the sequence.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
5912 Mar 1880—
  • Shakspere and Sea-Glasses — Brinsley Nicholson
  • Kemp and the Play of Hamlet; Yorick and Tarlton — Brinsley Nicholson
none named
Known only from the headnotes to the printed papers. The second headnote's OCR reads "55th"; the date shows it is the 59th.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
609 Apr 1880—
  • How Shakspere became Popular in Germany — Eleanor Marx
  • Some Fifty Fresh Allusions to Shakspere in 1592–1693 (announced; author not named)
none namedEleanor Marx — her paper was read at this meeting (the printed text says only "read at a meeting"; that she read it herself is likely but not stated)
Eleanor Marx. Her own paper, printed in the Gentleman's Magazine, June 1880, pp. 707–723, with the footnote "Paper read at a meeting of the New Shakspere Society on April 9, 1880." See dossier N92.
Known from the footnote to the printed paper and from the advance programme in the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 28, 1880, p. 409 or near it, weekly list of meetings): "New Shakespeare, University College, W.C., 8 p.m. 1. Miss Eleanor Marx, 'How Shakespeare became popular in Germany.' 2. 'Some Fifty Fresh Allusions to Shakespeare in 1592–1693.'" The Journal was then edited by H. B. Wheatley, its Assistant Secretary. No record of the meeting itself was found. The meeting number follows from the sequence (59th on 12 March, 61st on 14 May 1880).
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6114 May 1880—
  • The Number of Witches in Macbeth, IV. i — Brinsley Nicholson
  • Shakspere's Treatment of Fate and Freewill in his Characters — F. D. Matthew (announced)
none named
Nicholson's paper is known from the headnote to the printed paper; Matthew's from the advance programme in the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 28, about p. 553). Whether Matthew's paper was read is not recorded.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6211 Jun 1880—
  • The Seasons of Shakspere's Plays — H. N. Ellacombe
  • The Utter Failure of Mr Swinburne's Metrical Argument against Fletcher's Share in Henry VIII — F. J. Furnivall (announced)
  • Suicide in Shakspere — J. Kirkman (announced; read 13 Jan 1882)
none named
Ellacombe's paper is known from the headnote to the printed paper; the programme from the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 28, about p. 639).
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6315 Oct 1880—
  • The First and Second Quartos and the First Folio of Hamlet: their Relation to each other — Gustav Tanger
none named
Known only from the headnote to the printed paper.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6412 Nov 1880—
  • On Four Passages in Henry V — Brinsley Nicholson
none named
Known only from the headnote to the printed paper.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6521 Jan 1881—
  • Mr Spedding's Proposed Arrangement of Acts in King Lear — Peter Bayne
none named
Known only from the headnote to the printed paper.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
688 Apr 1881—
  • Shakspere's Old Men — Constance O'Brien (announced)
  • Was Shakespeare a Democrat? — Emma Phipson (announced)
none named
Known only from the advance programme in the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 29, about p. 439). The meeting number is inferred (65th on 21 Jan 1881, then monthly) and may be wrong; whether the papers were read is not recorded.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
6913 May 1881—
  • The Suicides in Shakspeare's Plays — J. Kirkman (announced; read 13 Jan 1882)
  • The Cruxes in Shakspeare's Early Comedies — F. J. Furnivall (announced)
none named
Known only from the advance programme in the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 29). The meeting number is inferred and may be wrong.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
7010 Jun 1881—
  • The Alterations in the Acting Editions of Shakspere's Plays — Mr Poole (announced)
none named
Known only from the advance programme in the Journal of the Society of Arts (vol. 29). The meeting number is inferred and may be wrong.
Transactions 1880–6, headnotes to papers
7214 Oct 1881F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • "I have much to say on behalf of that Falstaff" — J. W. Mills of the Clifton Shakspere Society (read from the chair)
F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, T. A. Spalding, James DarmesteterNew members: Teena Rochfort-Smith ("Miss Teena Smith"), Prof. Tanger, the King's Inns Library, Dublin. The Society's Report read from the chair. Resolutions on the death of President Garfield, "long a member of this society": sympathy to his family; Mrs Garfield elected the first honorary member; a set of the publications for Hiram College; Prince Leopold to convey the resolutions.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
7311 Nov 1881F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Notes on All's Well that Ends Well — J. G. A. Dow of the Monday Shakspere Club, Glasgow (read from the chair)
  • The Tale of the Forest of Arden — Richard Grant White (read from the chair)
none namedWilliam Poel announced as a new member. Kirkman's paper on suicide postponed to January.
Every speaker repudiated Grant White's view of Touchstone as a loveless cynic; no names are given.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
749 Dec 1881F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Romeo and Juliet — Emily H. Hickey (read by the author)
  • Notes on three passages in Hamlet ("mortal coil" and others) — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, W. A. Harrison, Brinsley Nicholson, Emma Phipson, Peter Bayne
Lucy Toulmin Smith supplied a passage from the Towneley Mysteries for Nicholson's notes; it is not clear that she was present.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
7513 Jan 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Suicide in Shakspere — J. Kirkman (read by the author)
  • On Constance in King John — Mrs J. H. Tucker of Clifton
  • Shakspere's Character (the last of a series of lectures) — C. H. Herford
F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, Brinsley NicholsonTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
7610 Feb 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • What are the dozen or sixteen lines which Hamlet proposed to insert in the sub-play? — M. W. Mayow (read by the author)
  • Shakspere and Euphuism: Euphues an adaptation from Guevara — F. Landmann (read by the author)
Brinsley Nicholson, F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne
Furnivall said Landmann's paper "marked an epoch in the criticism of English literature".
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
7710 Mar 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • As You Like It and Lodge's Rosalynde compared — W. G. Stone (read by W. A. Harrison)
  • Notes on some recent characterizations by Mr Ruskin of Shakspere's heroines — Peter Bayne (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, Peter Bayne, Emma Phipson, Eleanor Marx, Mrs Wedmore
Eleanor Marx. Spoke twice. On Stone's paper: "This subject, of Oliver's and Celia's betrothal, was discussed by Miss Phipson, Miss Marx, and Mrs Wedmore." On Bayne's notes on Ruskin's ranking of the heroines: "Mr Furnivall, Miss Phipson, and Miss Marx joined in objecting to the classification of Viola and Juliet together; and Miss Marx insisted that Cordelia must have been beautiful, or else her sisters would not have hated her so."
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
7814 Apr 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Shakspere's Characters contrasted with those of George Eliot — Peter Bayne (read by the author)
  • "Cursed Hebona" — W. A. Harrison (read by the author)
  • On Macbeth — J. C. Gibson of the Glasgow Monday Shakspere Club (read from the chair)
F. J. Furnivall, Joseph Knight, Emma Phipson, J. J. Jusserand, Grace Latham, Peter Bayne, Brinsley Nicholson
Bayne's paper appeared in Blackwood's Magazine, April 1883. The 79th meeting (12 May 1882) has no abstract in the scan; a paper read at it is printed in Transactions 1880–6.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
809 Jun 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • Was Hamlet Mad? — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, W. A. Harrison, Emma Phipson, Brinsley NicholsonTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
8113 Oct 1882F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • On Julius Caesar — Emily H. Hickey (read by the author)
Joseph Knight, James Darmesteter, W. A. Harrison, Thomas Tyler, Brinsley Nicholson, Emily H. HickeyOpening of the tenth session, open to the public. Furnivall on the Society's objects and the chronological method ("their battle fairly won"); the Old-Spelling Shakspere announced.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
8210 Nov 1882W. A. Harrison
  • The Relation of the First Quarto of Hamlet to the Second, and Some of the Textual Difficulties of the Play — Teena Rochfort-Smith (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Note on "chiefe in that" — W. Taylor Thom of Hollins Institute, Virginia
none named
"A discussion, by a full meeting" of Rochfort-Smith's points; no speakers named.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
838 Dec 1882Peter Bayne
  • Textual Difficulties in the Early Comedies (with the readings for the Old-Spelling Shakspere) — F. J. Furnivall (read by the author)
  • Notes on three puzzle-words in Hamlet — W. Taylor Thom
W. A. HarrisonTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
8412 Jan 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The Textual Difficulties in Richard II — W. A. Harrison (read by the author)
none namedTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
859 Feb 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The Witches of Shakspere — Grace Latham (read by the author)
Peter Bayne, F. J. Furnivall, W. A. Harrison, Brinsley NicholsonAccounts for 1882 read by the Hon. Secretary (auditors F. D. Matthew and E. Bell). Nicholson's illness obliges him to give up his paper on the Sonnets; Boyle's on Massinger and The Two Noble Kinsmen substituted.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
869 Mar 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
  • The Two Noble Kinsmen and Massinger's probable share in it — Robert Boyle of the St Petersburg Shakspere Circle
F. J. Furnivall, Brinsley Nicholson, W. A. Harrison
Furnivall announced that he had given up his former view that Shakspere was part-author of the play.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
879 Apr 1883Peter Bayne
  • Textual Difficulties in All's Well and Twelfth Night — W. G. Stone (read by F. J. Furnivall)
  • Notes on a passage in Troilus and the "death-angel" — W. G. Black
  • On Cymbeline and The Winter's Tale — Isabel Marshall (read by F. J. Furnivall)
Brinsley Nicholson
The abstract prints "Friday, April 9, 1883", but 9 April 1883 was a Monday, so the day or the date is wrong.
Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
8811 May 1883—
    none namedThe Society's first Musical Evening, in the Botany Theatre, University College: Shakspere's madrigals, glees and songs sung in chronological order (programme printed in the Appendix).
    No discussion; a concert.
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    898 Jun 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • Textual Difficulties in The Winter's Tale — Brinsley Nicholson (read by the author)
    • Note on "Nobler than attending for a check", Cymbeline III. iii — Thomas Tyler (read by the author)
    none namedThanks to the Council of University College for the rooms.
    "Each difficulty was discussed by the meeting as it was brought forward"; no names given.
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    9012 Oct 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • The Supremacy of Shakspere — Peter Bayne (read by the author)
    F. J. Furnivall, W. J. Craig, Grace Latham, Thomas Tyler, Mr Shaw, Mr FlügelOpening of the eleventh session. Furnivall reviewed the Society's progress, with papers now coming from Russia, Canada and the United States, and the difficulties delaying the Old-Spelling Shakspere. The Committee's resolution of sympathy with Mr and Mrs Patrick Smith on "the cruel death of their gifted daughter, Miss Teena Rochfort Smith", editor of the Four-Text Hamlet.
    "Mr Shaw" is very probably G. B. Shaw, whose paper was read at the 95th meeting; the abstract gives the surname only.
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    919 Nov 1883W. A. Harrison
    • On the Quarto (1597) and Folio of Richard III (his introduction to Griggs's facsimile of Q1) — P. A. Daniel (read by F. J. Furnivall)
    none namedTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    9214 Dec 1883F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • Preface to the Riverside Shakspere — Richard Grant White (read by W. A. Harrison)
    • Shakspere in Poland, Russia and Servia (a short paper) — B. Ziolecki (read by the author)
    • On the study of Shakspere in Australia — G. W. Rusden of Melbourne (spoke by request of the chair)
    W. G. Stone, G. W. RusdenTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    9311 Jan 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • On Love's Labour's Lost — S. L. Lee, Hon. Treasurer (read by the author)
    none namedS. L. Lee — read his paper as Hon. TreasurerAccounts for 1883 laid before the meeting by the Hon. Secretary (auditors F. D. Matthew and E. Bell).Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    948 Feb 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • "O poor Ophelia!" — Grace Latham (read by the author)
    F. J. Furnivall, W. A. Harrison, Thomas Tyler, Frederick Wedmore, F. DallyP. Z. Round and F. Dally announced as new members. Dr Dally described relics of Shakspere in his possession (a carved oak table and other wood-carving) that he wished to exhibit.
    "Other members also spoke."
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    9529 Feb 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
    • On Troilus and Cressida — G. B. Shaw (read by Grace Latham)
    • Shakspere in Poland and the Slavonic Countries — B. Ziolecki (read by the author)
    W. A. Harrison, Thomas TylerGrace Latham — read Shaw's paper
    Shaw read Troilus as Shakspere's protest against Homer and Chapman, and found Cressida "Shakspere's first real woman". "Other members spoke on the question of the date."
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    9614 Mar 1884Peter Bayne
    • The Sources of The Tempest and The Winter's Tale in the history of Poland and Lithuania — Prof. Caro, translated by Robert Boyle (read by P. Z. Round)
    F. J. Furnivall, Peter Bayne, B. Ziolecki, Grace Latham, Mr ShawFurnivall announced that Tommaso Salvini had accepted a Vice-Presidency, and that P. Z. Round had been elected to the Committee.
    "The opinions of Miss Latham, Mr Shaw, and other speakers in the full meeting" favoured the survival of Polish traditions.
    Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
    979 May 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      none namedThe Society's annual musical entertainment, Botany Theatre, University College, members and friends admitted by ticket. Before the music, Furnivall moved a resolution of sympathy with the Queen on the death of the Duke of Albany (Prince Leopold), Vice-President. Music directed by J. Greenhill.
      No paper; a concert.
      Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      9830 May 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      • Shakspere's Sonnets, I: the Chronology of the Sonnets — Thomas Tyler (read by the author)
      W. A. Harrison, G. B. Shaw
      The abstract of this meeting is bound inside that of the 97th. Shaw maintained that the British Museum engraving after the Mytens portrait showed William Herbert as "a remarkably handsome man". Gerald Massey's view of the "mortal moon" (Sonnet 107) was discussed in the paper; whether Massey was present is not stated.
      Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      9913 Jun 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      • A short paper on a search at the Record Office (from a suggestion made from the chair at the last meeting) — W. A. Harrison (read by the author)
      • Shakspere's Sonnets, II — Thomas Tyler (read by the author)
      W. A. Harrison, Thomas TylerThe Hon. Secretary reported acknowledgments from the Queen and the Duchess of Albany of the Society's resolutions of 9 May.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10021 Oct 1884F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      • Shakspere's Garden of Girls, I: Hot-house Flowers (Juliet, Imogen, Ophelia) — Miss M. Leigh-Noel (read by the author)
      • Early references to Shakspere in Germany by Burckhard Mencke — Ewald Flügel (read by the author)
      none namedOpening of the twelfth session; Furnivall reviewed the year's Shakspere work. New members: B. Ziolecki, the Faculté des Lettres de Paris, W. B. Slater, the Melbourne Shakspere Society, the Montgomery Female College Shakspere Society (Virginia). Resolution of condolence on the death of Giulio Carcano, Vice-President.
      Leigh-Noel's estimates were "criticised and fully discussed"; no names given. The abstract prints "Friday, October 21", but 21 October 1884 was a Tuesday, so the day or the date is wrong.
      Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10114 Nov 1884W. A. Harrison
      • Shakspere's Garden of Girls, II: Hardy Blossoms — Miss M. Leigh-Noel (read by the author)
      • Textual difficulties in As You Like It (notes for the Old-Spelling Shakspere) — W. G. Stone
      none namedThe Hon. Secretary read a letter from Signora Carcano thanking the Society.
      "The various points raised were discussed by the meeting"; no names given.
      Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10212 Dec 1884W. A. Harrison
      • Shakspere's Garden of Girls, III: Wild Flowers (Miranda, Perdita, &c.) — Miss M. Leigh-Noel (read in her absence by S. L. Lee)
      • Textual difficulties in Measure for Measure — W. G. Stone
      W. A. Harrison, F. J. Furnivall, Grace Latham, William PoelS. L. Lee — read Leigh-Noel's paperTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10316 Jan 1885Richard Garnett
      • Henry VIII: an Investigation into the Origin and Authorship of the Play — Robert Boyle of St Petersburg (read by F. J. Furnivall)
      Richard Garnett, F. J. Furnivall, W. A. Harrison, F. D. Matthew, Grace Latham, W. Wilkins, Thomas Tyler, Stanley Cooper, William Poel, W. G. StoneTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10413 Feb 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      • The Dramatic Meaning of the Construction of Shakspere's Verse, with especial reference to the Run-on Line and the Extra Syllable — Grace Latham (read by the author)
      F. J. Furnivall, William Poel, W. A. HarrisonJ. Kinton Bond and Henry Cochin announced as new members.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10513 Mar 1885C. Knight Watson (Secretary of the Society of Antiquaries)
      • An Elizabethan Learned Society — S. L. Lee, Hon. Treasurer (read by the author)
      C. Knight Watson, F. J. Furnivall, F. A. MarshallNew members: J. J. Britton and the Bradford Public Free Libraries. Accounts for 1884 laid before the meeting (auditors F. D. Matthew and E. G. Bell).Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      10610 Apr 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
      • Documents relating to the Players at the Red Bull and the Cockpit — James Greenstreet (taken as read; proofs on the table)
      • On the anonymous play of Richard II in Egerton MS. 1994 — F. A. Marshall (read by the author)
      F. J. Furnivall, F. A. MarshallAn old portrait said to be of Shakspere, belonging to Mr Mills of Bond Street, exhibited; the meeting rejected its authenticity.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
      1078 May 1885—
        none namedThe Society's third annual musical evening: madrigals, glees and songs directed by J. Greenhill (programme in the Appendix).
        No paper; a concert.
        Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        10812 Jun 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • "Such Harmony is in Immortall Soules" (Merchant of Venice, V. i. 63) — Frank Carr (read by the author)
        F. J. FurnivallTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        10923 Oct 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • The Play of Hamlet from a Theosophic Point of View — G. B. Finch (read by the author)
        F. J. Furnivall, J. Kirkman, Mr Shaw, S. L. Lee, Thomas Tyler, G. B. FinchOpening of the thirteenth session. New members: J. J. Britton, the Bradford Public Free Libraries, the Romanisch-Englisches Seminar at Marburg, Sir Philip Perring and R. G. Moulton. Moulton elected to the Committee.
        "Mr Shaw doubted whether it was 'degrading' Hamlet to treat it as Mr Finch had done", but would not have it that Shakspere wrote it as an allegory.
        Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11013 Nov 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • The Play of Richard III — Stopford A. Brooke (read by the author)
        F. J. Furnivall, F. A. Marshall, Thomas Tyler, Emma Phipson, H. A. Frink, Stopford A. BrookeH. A. Frink of Amherst College — spoke of his pleasure "in being present at a meeting of the Society"Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11111 Dec 1885F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • The Prose in Shakspere's Plays, the Rules for its Use, and the Assistance it gives in understanding the Plays — Henry Sharpe (read by the author)
        • Notes on Shakspere's prose — R. G. Moulton (read by F. J. Furnivall; Moulton "unable to be present")
        F. J. Furnivall, Grace Latham, W. A. Harrison, William PoelTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11215 Jan 1886F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • Character-Development in Shakspere, as illustrated by Macbeth and Henry V — R. G. Moulton (read by the author)
        F. J. Furnivall, William Poel, Thomas Tyler, S. L. Lee, R. G. MoultonNew members: Miss O. Richardson, J. A. McHardy, Floyd B. Wilson, M. Mull. William Poel and Prof. Napier elected to the Committee. A letter from Wentworth Huyshe on the Cobham tomb at Lingfield.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11312 Feb 1886F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • William Herbert and Mary Fitton in connection with Shakspere's Sonnets, Part I — W. A. Harrison (read by the author)
        • On Pericles (abstract of his introduction to the Quarto Facsimile) — P. Z. Round (read by the author)
        F. J. FurnivallTransactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11412 Mar 1886F. J. Furnivall (Director)
        • William Herbert and Mary Fitton, Part II — W. A. Harrison (read by the author)
        • Shakspere and the Welcombe Enclosures — J. S. Stuart Glennie (read by the author)
        F. J. Furnivall, Thomas Tyler, W. M. Rossetti
        Furnivall held that the Society's work had brought the personal theory of the Sonnets to the point where "people of fair and independent minds must accept" it.
        Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        1159 Apr 1886A. H. Bullen
        • Beaumont, Fletcher and Massinger — Robert Boyle (read by F. J. Furnivall)
        A. H. Bullen, F. J. Furnivall, P. Z. Round, Mr Shaw, Thomas TylerNew members: the Sheffield Public Libraries, J. Petherick, the University Library, Prague. The Hon. Secretary read a letter from D. Bikelas with his Greek translations of Othello and King Lear, performed at Athens and elsewhere.Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
        11614 May 1886—
          none namedThe fourth annual musical entertainment, Botany Theatre: songs, catches and ballads mentioned by Shakspere, directed by J. Greenhill.
          No paper; a concert.
          Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings
          11711 Jun 1886W. A. Harrison
          • Hamlet's Age — Sir Edward Sullivan (read by F. J. Furnivall)
          • Shakspere and his Wife (against Halliwell-Phillipps) — F. A. Marshall (read by P. Z. Round)
          W. A. Harrison, Thomas Tyler, F. J. Furnivall, Mrs Peto
          The last meeting in the scanned Transactions. The Society met until 1894; no records of the later meetings were found in the scans searched.
          Transactions 1880–6, Monthly Abstract of Proceedings

          People named at the meetings

          Everyone the records place at a meeting, as chair, reader, author reading their own paper, speaker, or otherwise present, with the number of meetings. Names are as normalised in the data file; "Mr Shaw" is kept apart from "G. B. Shaw" where the abstract gives only the surname.

          F. J. Furnivall971discussion 75, chair 69, read a paper 28, own paper 41 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 102 103 104 105 106 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 117
          Brinsley Nicholson331discussion 32, own paper 61 2 3 4 8 9 11 12 13 14 15 16 18 23 25 44 46 47 49 54 55 56 74 75 76 77 78 80 81 85 86 87 89
          W. A. Harrison3131discussion 22, own paper 5, chair 5, read a paper 231 41 43 52 53 54 56 74 77 78 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 91 92 94 95 98 99 101 102 103 104 111 113 114 117
          Peter Bayne2911discussion 25, own paper 4, chair 311 23 24 25 26 27 28 31 32 33 37 43 47 48 50 53 55 72 74 75 76 77 78 80 83 85 87 90 96
          F. D. Matthew197discussion 17, read a paper 4, chair 37 9 15 18 22 23 28 29 30 32 33 36 38 41 43 45 48 54 103
          Thomas Tyler1950discussion 16, own paper 450 52 53 54 56 81 89 90 94 95 98 99 103 109 110 112 114 115 117
          J. N. Hetherington1623discussion 15, own paper 123 31 32 33 34 36 37 38 41 42 44 46 49 54 55 56
          Edward Rose1431discussion 13, own paper 2, read a paper 131 36 37 38 41 43 44 46 47 50 53 54 55 56
          Richard Simpson141discussion 12, own paper 51 3 4 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 16 17 18 19
          A. J. Ellis111discussion 10, chair 6, read a paper 11 3 6 10 15 18 19 21 23 27 49
          E. H. Pickersgill1111discussion 10, own paper 111 13 15 16 17 18 28 33 43 47 49
          Grace Latham1078discussion 6, own paper 3, read a paper 1, present 178 85 90 94 95 96 102 103 104 111
          E. A. Abbott91discussion 9, read a paper 4, own paper 11 2 3 4 6 8 9 12 18
          Joseph Knight924discussion 8, own paper 124 28 30 46 47 54 56 78 81
          T. A. Spalding831discussion 7, own paper 331 32 39 43 44 50 52 72
          Emma Phipson748discussion 6, own paper 148 51 74 77 78 80 110
          Frank A. Marshall724discussion 6, own paper 2, chair 124 35 41 55 105 106 110
          J. W. Hales72discussion 6, own paper 22 5 7 8 14 17 26
          Emily H. Hickey532discussion 4, own paper 232 48 50 74 81
          S. L. Lee593own paper 2, present 2, discussion 293 102 105 109 112
          William Poel5102discussion 5102 103 104 111 112
          Eleanor Marx428present 3, read a paper 1, discussion 128 29 60 77
          Eugene Oswald41discussion 41 5 6 41
          H. B. Wheatley43discussion 3, own paper 23 17 29 54
          J. Kirkman448discussion 3, own paper 148 55 75 109
          Lewis Jarvis411discussion 411 34 36 48
          M. Wynell Mayow442discussion 3, own paper 142 43 44 50
          Mr Shaw490discussion 490 96 109 115
          P. Z. Round496read a paper 2, own paper 1, discussion 196 113 115 117
          R. Cartwright419discussion 3, own paper 119 24 25 27
          Tom Taylor45chair 4, discussion 45 14 35 37
          B. Ziolecki392own paper 2, discussion 192 95 96
          Frederick Wedmore326discussion 326 33 94
          John Todhunter321discussion 3, own paper 121 22 28
          Lucy Toulmin Smith315discussion 2, own paper 115 17 30
          H. Courthope Bowen241discussion 2, own paper 1, chair 141 42
          J. W. Ebsworth234own paper 234 40
          J. W. Snelgrove21present 21 2
          James Darmesteter272discussion 272 81
          M. Leigh-Noel2100own paper 2100 101
          Mr Peto231discussion 231 32
          W. G. Stone292discussion 292 103
          W. J. Craig221own paper 1, discussion 121 90
          W. T. Malleson211discussion 2, own paper 111 31
          A. H. Bullen1115chair 1, discussion 1115
          Algernon Foggo125own paper 125
          C. Knight Watson1105chair 1, discussion 1105
          C. M. Ingleby131own paper 1, discussion 131
          Ewald Flügel1100own paper 1100
          F. Dally194discussion 194
          F. Landmann176own paper 176
          Frank Carr1108own paper 1108
          G. B. Finch1109own paper 1, discussion 1109
          G. B. Shaw198discussion 198
          G. W. Eusden16discussion 16
          G. W. Rusden192discussion 192
          H. A. Frink1110discussion 1110
          H. A. Frink of Amherst College1110present 1110
          H. P. Stokes148discussion 148
          Harold Littledale125discussion 125
          Harry Beighton154own paper 154
          Henry Sharpe1111own paper 1111
          Hiram Corson135own paper 1, present 135
          J. J. Jusserand178discussion 178
          J. S. Stuart Glennie1114own paper 1114
          James Gairdner138chair 1, discussion 138
          James Spedding142discussion 142
          Joseph Payne17discussion 17
          Karl Elze133chair 1, present 133
          M. W. Mayow176own paper 176
          Miss Marshall15discussion 15
          Miss Peto142discussion 142
          Mr Flügel190discussion 190
          Mrs Bayne128present 128
          Mrs Boole155present 155
          Mrs Peto1117discussion 1117
          Mrs Wedmore177discussion 177
          Nicolaus Delius115present 115
          P. A. Daniel14discussion 14
          R. G. Moulton1112own paper 1, discussion 1112
          R. J. Gilman136discussion 136
          Richard Garnett1103chair 1, discussion 1103
          S. R. Gardiner126own paper 126
          Signor Pagliardini136discussion 136
          Sir Philip Magnay148read a paper 1, discussion 148
          Stanley Cooper1103discussion 1103
          Stopford A. Brooke1110own paper 1, discussion 1110
          Timothy Holmes155discussion 155
          W. Aldis Wright115discussion 115
          W. Collet16discussion 16
          W. M. Rossetti1114discussion 1114
          W. Wilkins1103discussion 1103
          William Chappell140chair 1, discussion 140
          William Malleson148discussion 148