N72 · The Positivists
E. S. Beesly and Marx, 1863–70 (Royden Harrison, 1959, part I): the Positivists who prepared the International, the Commonwealth, University College and the Fortnightly
Royden Harrison, "E. S. Beesly and Karl Marx", I, International Review of Social History 4 (1959), pp. 22–58 (harrison1959.pdf; printed page = PDF + 21)Sources: Beesly's letters to Marx (microfilm from Moscow); the Congreve papers (BL Add. MSS 45227–64; Wadham); the Musée Auguste Comte; the Howell Collection (Bishopsgate Institute); General Council minutes (IISG)
The articlePart I of a two-part study (pp. 22–58); Part II follows at pp. 208–238 (Royden Harrison (1959) II, IRSH 4, pp. 208–238 (harrison1959b.pdf; printed page = PDF + 207)). Harrison argues three …
Points of contact with MarxSt James's Hall, 26 Mar 1863. Beesly organised and addressed the trade unionists' pro-Lincoln meeting with John Bright in the chair; Marx attended (Marx to Engels, 9 Apr 1863; pp. 28–30). …
EducationSeveral points bear on §28: Beesly's "Public Education" (The Commonwealth, 1 Sept 1866) appeared in the International's own paper. His "General Election of 1869: Programme for Trade Unions" …
The Paris workers' reports of 1862Fabien Magnin, the Paris Positivist workman, studied "the reports of the delegates to the London exhibition" (888 pages). These were the Paris workers' delegations to the 1862 Exhibition, …
For the householdBeesly married Emily Crompton, sister of the Positivist Henry Crompton, in 1869. He told Marx "there is no fear that I shall have to become respectable" (21 May 1869; p. 45). Henry Crompton …
To checkPart II (IRSH 4, 1959, Part 2), on the Commune, the refugees and Beesly's later relations with the family. Marx's letters to Beesly (MEW 33). Beesly's letters to Marx in MEGAdigital, compared with Harrison's quotations from the microfilm. Beesly's "Public Education" in the Commonwealth, 1 Sept 1866.
Harrison's thesisTheir friendship rested on a shared "historicism", Comte's and Marx's alike, not on Beesly being an incipient Marxist. Marx's hostility to Comte was to his non-socialist conclusions, not …
Continued inN100 (E. S. Beesly and Marx, 1871–83 (Royden Harrison, 1959, part II): the Commune, the refugees and the later contacts); N101 (Crabb Robinson, University Hall and Beesly's post)