MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N72 › Note

Points of contact with Marx

A note onN72 E. S. Beesly and Marx, 1863–70 (Royden Harrison, 1959, part I): the Positivists who prepared the International, the Commonwealth, University College and the Fortnightly
  • St James's Hall, 26 Mar 1863. Beesly organised and addressed the trade unionists' pro-Lincoln meeting with John Bright in the chair; Marx attended (Marx to Engels, 9 Apr 1863; pp. 28–30).
  • The newspaper, 1865–66. Marx and Beesly both backed the Miner and Workman's Advocate, renamed the Commonwealth. Radical manufacturers of the Reform Union, led by S. C. Kell of Bradford, gained control and attacked "Positivists and Marxists" in its columns. Marx proposed selling out to Kell (Marx to Engels, 9 June 1866; p. 34). Harrison used the company's articles and shareholder list in the Public Record Office: see N64.
  • Introduction through Lafargue. Marx and Beesly came to know each other through Lafargue, "a Positivist in his youth" (Marx to Engels, 16 May 1868; p. 33).
  • Exeter Hall, 1867. Beesly's speech on the Sheffield outrages ("Governor Eyre was a greater murderer than Broadhead") nearly cost him his chair. Sir F. H. Goldsmid moved at University College that he was "unfit to be entrusted with the instruction of young men in History", and the motion was defeated 12–3 on 27 July 1867. Marx wrote in support, and Beesly replied on 24 July 1867 (pp. 37–39).
  • Marx reads Comte, and Beesly receives Capital. Marx read Comte "as a side-line" in 1866: "miserable compared to Hegel" (Marx to Engels, 7 July 1866). Beesly thanked Marx for Capital I but could not read German (24 Sept 1867). John Morley turned down Engels's review for the Fortnightly as "too dry" (Marx to Engels, 15 Oct 1868; pp. 40–41).
  • Exeter Hall, 23 June 1869. Trade Union Bill meeting, Samuel Morley in the chair. At Beesly's reference to the June days, "Karl Marx grinned a ghastly grin and Sam Morley smiled a sickly smile" (p. 46).
  • 1870. Marx wrote to Beesly on 12 Sept 1870 that the International's address "coincides … almost literally" with Beesly's A Word for France. Beesly then wrote "The International Working Men's Association" for the Fortnightly (Nov 1870) with Marx's materials and proofs (pp. 47–53).
  • Disagreement over the Positivists. Marx tried to keep the Paris Proletarian Positivists out of the International (15 Mar 1870). Engels attacked "the Comtists" in the Council on 31 Jan 1871 for splitting the workers over armed intervention (pp. 53–56).