Maurice on public opinion, the will of the majority and emigration: Norman checked against the sources
[p. 18:] After giving his support to associationism, he still advocated emigration overseas for the poor, as a solution to social ills: it was preferable to tinkering with the structure of society at home. Ludlow and the Christian Socialist activists were very disappointed. … When, in November 1849, the other leaders of Christian Socialism tried to found a Health League, to urge government action for public health reform, Maurice's opposition forced the abandonment of the project. He spoke of the hazards of collective action, and pointed to the example of the Anti-Corn Law League: 'They laid their sacrifices on the altars of the evil spirit called Public Opinion, and they have or have had their reward'. Instead, he sought to inspire private philanthropic work.
[p. 22:] Comparable to his distrust of parties and systems was Maurice's loathing of public opinion. … According to his son and biographer, General Sir John Frederick Maurice, he was the antagonist of 'the great idolatry of the day, the worship of Public Opinion'. Maurice himself wrote: 'it is the worship of opinions which is enslaving both theology and science'. There were, for him, direct political implications. 'The sovereignty of the people, in any sense or form', he wrote in December 1848 — just nine months after the start of the Christian Socialist movement — was to be repudiated 'as at once the silliest and most blasphemous of all contradictions'. … The whole tenor and argument of his 1866 book, The Workman and the Franchise, spells out Maurice's rejection of popular sovereignty in the circumstances not only of the day, but of all conceivable days.
[p. 23:] He railed against 'the miserable theory of numbers', 'the slavish reverence for numbers', and the opinions of 'a mere multitude'. The people were not just an aggregate. Looked at atomistically, as the reformers tended to do, they lacked a sense of their continuity with the past of the nation. They lacked an organic sense. … The work of 'social reformation' in England, he said in 1851, as he opened a new co-operative workshop in Southampton, would come when working men themselves 'became a living, organic part of our English nation'. The 'masses', in contrast, he said, 'form a rude chaos'. The virtue of association and self-help, the whole point of the co-operatives, in fact, was to transform this 'wild floating mass of atoms'; it was to cultivate an atmosphere in which the participants on a mass scale would 'feel that they have a common life and a common object'. Then men will recover their 'manliness', and society will recover that organic identity and those personal freedoms which Maurice, in classic nineteenth-century radical style, supposed were a feature of Saxon England — when institutions had been 'for freedom' and when the family had become 'the root of the state'.
[To Ludlow, 1849, against the Health League, Life II, p. 25:] To all you say about the rapid success of the Anti-Corn Law League, I answer in the words of the Bhagavad-Gita: "Those who worship the Devatas obtain speedy answers to their prayers." Cobden, Bright, Fox, are the very specimens of this kind of worshipper. They laid their sacrifices on the altars of the evil spirit called Public Opinion, and they have or have had their reward. I grant you that the living and true God worked His own ends by their means, but their idolatry has produced curses and I greatly fear will produce more.
[To Ludlow, 6 December 1849, on Sidney Herbert's scheme to send the London needlewomen to Australia, Life II, pp. 28–29:] Colonisation is not transportation; it is a brave, hearty, Saxon, Christian work. To stir up women or men to engage in it is to stir them up to feel that they are women and men in the highest, truest sense of the words. … Let us devise a Socialist home Colonisation as soon as you please … But in the meantime here is this emigration. The sea is not an evil element for English men or women. … Therefore let us help Sidney Herbert and Lord Ashley, say I.
[December 1848, Life I, p. 485:] But the sovereignty of the people, in any sense or form, I not only repudiate as at once the silliest and most blasphemous of all contradictions, but I look upon it as the same contradiction, the same blasphemy in its fullest expansion of which the kings have been guilty.
[The Workman and the Franchise, p. 203:] So help me God, I do not mean to follow the will of a majority, I hope never to follow it, always to set it at nought. And for that expression about "the greatest happiness of the greatest number," I do not understand it. — [p. 207:] Introduce the miserable theory of numbers, and you have nothing but a series of plots and counterplots! — [p. 211:] But by talking of general suffrage or universal suffrage, you will only promote the slavish reverence for numbers. — [p. 217:] A mere multitude must be dangerous. It must be ready to adopt the opinions of any leader who obtains temporary dominion over it. — [p. 22, on the Saxons:] The Saxon restored life to the admirable institutions which Rome had set up in her colony; he made them institutions for freemen; he connected them again with the household; the family became once more the root of the state; the king was a king of men, not a master of slaves.