N100 › Note
Part II: the Commune, 1871
A note onN100 E. S. Beesly and Marx, 1871–83 (Royden Harrison, 1959, part II): the Commune, the refugees and the later contacts- Beesly's articles. Beesly defended the Commune in the Bee-Hive. When Marx told him the paper was "sold to Sam Morley and Co." he wrote eight articles for the Eastern Post instead (July–Aug 1871). Marx told Beesly that "as a Party man" he was "thoroughly hostile" to Comte, and called him the only Comtist who handled historical turning-points "as an historian in the best sense of the word" (Marx to Beesly, 12 June 1871; pp. 213–14, 230).
- Robinet. The "honourable French writer" quoted near the end of The Civil War in France is Comte's physician Dr Robinet. Marx took the words from a pamphlet of Robinet's letters, published anonymously with an introduction by Beesly, and ran separate passages together (pp. 216–17).
- Beesly on the address. Beesly praised The Civil War in France but called its "foreign" style and its refusal to state ulterior aims "indistinct and unsatisfactory" (17 June 1871; p. 217).
- The household. On 19 Oct 1871 Marx sent a photograph "for Mrs. Beesly" and wrote that "Jenny will give herself the pleasure to call on Mrs. Beesly on Wednesday next" (p. 213). Marx, sometimes with his wife, Engels or a friend from the continent, dined with the Beeslys at University College Hall, Gordon Square, at times with John Morley or Captain Maxse present (pp. 225–26).