MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N41 · The College and Marx's circle

Ruskin's drawing class against Cole's system, and its handover to South Kensington

Davies pp. 38, 39, 49, 277; WMC reports 1868, 1889; Benzie p. 48; Macdonald pp. 267, 325; Butterworth pp. 279–80; Cooper p. 202; Bonython and Burton p. 114; Bell pp. 121, 243, 259, 262–63; Davies pp. 50–52College histories and the histories of Cole's schools
Original (English)

[J. P. Emslie, Davies p. 39:] In the year 1856 I became a student in the drawing class of the Working Men's College. This class was at that time conducted by Messrs. Ruskin, D. G. Rossetti, and Lowes Dickinson. … Mr. Ruskin's method of teaching somewhat surprised me, used as I had been to the Government School of Design, where one has to go through a long course of drawing from the flat before being permitted to draw from the round. Mr. Ruskin, on the contrary, did not give his students printed works to copy, but set them at once to draw from objects. — [Lowes Dickinson, Davies p. 38:] when he [Cave Thomas] relinquished it, there was difficulty in providing a permanent unpaid teacher for the school, and an arrangement was made with the South Kensington Schools, under which a competent teacher is appointed, with quite satisfactory results. — [Report, 1889:] In connection with Science and Art Department, South Kensington. — [Davies p. 277:] students have been encouraged to sit for outside examinations — in science and art for those of South Kensington; in languages and commercial subjects for those of the Society of Arts and the London Chamber of Commerce.

Two systemsCole's Department taught by graded copying from flat examples; Ruskin taught drawing from things. Ruskin's later attacks are on Cole by name: "There you may see the complete issue of Sir … The handoverOnce no unpaid teacher could be found, Cole's schools supplied one, and by 1889 the art class ran under the Science and Art Department, with South Kensington's examinations and grants; the … The pupilsGeorge Allen "became an engraver, and, afterwards, publisher of Mr. Ruskin's books" (Davies p. 49). "E. Cooke, Lithographer" is among the certificated students in the report of February … Furnivall's partAt the opening meeting in 1854 Furnivall put a reprint of Ruskin's "On the Nature of Gothic", "a statement of the conclusions … respecting the conditions under which the life of the workman … Ford Madox BrownIn January 1855 Brown applied to Cole for a teaching post, was told a certificate was imperative and was sent on to Burchett; his diary calls him "the humbug Henry Cole C.B." (Bell p. 259 … Ruskin's referencesBell gives Ruskin on Cole and Redgrave in the preface to Works XVI, pp. xxvi–xxxi, and in the Laws of Fésole (Works XV p. 344) (pp. 262–63). He dates Ruskin's protest five years after the … Copyist and draftsmanThe Berlin artillery school had the same argument in 1816, when Meno Burg replaced copying exemplars with descriptive geometry to train a Zeichner (draftsman) rather than an Abzeichner …