William Benzie
Modern biographer of F. J. Furnivall (Dr. F. J. Furnivall: Victorian Scholar Adventurer, 1983), the dossier's main source for Furnivall's societies, his circle and his quarrels. Benzie cites Kapp's two-volume Eleanor Marx (1972, 1976) and repeats its misattribution of Engels's "pilgrim" sentence to Marx (Kapp tally no. 1).
51 mentions in 39 notes.
Mentions
The dossier's title page1
- (outside the entries)
…Exposition of 1867, the General Council's minutes, the histories and reports of the Working Men's College, Benzie 's life of Furnivall, and the 1821 variorum. Full list in
§9 Marx, Furnivall and Delius, 1876–823
- (outside the entries)
…and her literary circle. The first group comes from the letters in MEW 33–36; the second from William Benzie 's life of Furnivall and from Kapp; the family letters themselves are
- N4 Furnivall in the street, "like a pilgrim"
joke only works if Marx could picture Furnivall. William Benzie , Dr. F. J. Furnivall: Victorian Scholar Adventurer (1983), p. 261 n., citing Kapp, Eleanor Marx, vol. 1, p.…
…like a pilgrim on the way to the Holy Land to seek St. Anthony's beard" (Kapp, Verso 2018, p. 129 n.), and Benzie copied
§10 Eleanor's work for the societies: translator, transcriber, reader and critic, 1876–8519
- N47 "She used to drag me to Furnivall's Shakespeare Society meetings"
- N47 › Page numbers
Benzie cites the 1972 edition (vol. 1, pp. 172, 187); the pages here are those of the one-volume Verso edition. The…
- N48 Eleanor as a reader for the Dictionary, and the Macro plays
[ Benzie p. 141:] In 1882, when Furnivall was editing the Digby Plays for the New Shakspere Society, he obtained…
- N48 › Now attested from Eleanor's side
…over Furnivall's protest; the agreements were executed by the Vice-Chancellor and sent out on 1 March 1879 ( Benzie pp. 102–06; Gilliver pp. 106–07). Her 1878 work for the Philological Society was therefore done for…
- N48 › On the river, July 1882
…that being one of my stock pieces" (pp. 183–84). Kapp gives no more. What such an outing meant is clear from Benzie : rowing was Furnivall's ruling passion, and from the Working Men's College years his river excursions mixed…
…his 21-year-old secretary Teena Rochfort-Smith into the house in Primrose Hill where his wife still lived ( Benzie pp. 29–30). Eleanor's letter, not quoted further by Kapp, would show who else was in the boat. Benzie's…
and 1 more in this note
- N14 › Eleanor
…p. 147, from Marian Comyn, "My Recollections of Karl Marx", The Nineteenth Century and After, January 1922). Benzie (1983, p. 141) confirms that in 1882 Furnivall "obtained permission for a copy of the manuscript of the Macro…
- N91 › What the list adds
names Eleanor among the EETS transcribers without saying what she copied (N14), and Benzie and Kapp know only the Macro plays (N48). The volumes themselves name four further jobs between 1880 and…
- N113 › Wheatley
…later editor of Pepys. His ties to Furnivall's circle run through every institution in this dossier. (1) Benzie names him among the Philological Society men of the 1860s with Morris, Ellis and Sweet (p. 79), and as Hon.…
- N49 The Browning and Shelley Societies: the Abbé Vogler, Aveling refused, "Shelley and …
[ Benzie p. 228:] Eleanor Marx gave "A Short Account of the Abbe Vogler". — [p. 241:] Such diverse characters as Shaw,…
- N49 › Aveling and the Shelley Society: the accounts differ
(vol. 2, p. 250, from Henry Salt) has Rossetti's threat to resign forcing Aveling's admission. Benzie (p. 247) and Peterson (p. 192) say he was refused and that Rossetti resigned from the committee; Peterson…
…either account. The Society's own record supports Kapp: Aveling is in its list of members for 1887 (N111). Benzie 's and Peterson's "resigned" may compress a threat into the
- N111 Eleanor in the Browning and Shelley Societies' own volumes; Thomas J. Wise; and the …
…Society, Part I (1888); Shelley Society, Report for 1887; Academy, 1 May 1886 and 24 December 1887; William Benzie , Dr. F. J. Furnivall (1983), pp. 14, 37, 39, 67–68, 71–72, 112, 123, 209, 254, 266. Full texts on…
- N111 › What this adds
Benzie and Kapp report the Vogler paper and the Shelley lecture at second hand (N49). The volumes give the paper…
- N111 › Furnivall's societies, from Benzie
…begun with the National Sunday League; p. 209), the Browning Society (1881), the Wyclif Society (1881 in Benzie 's contents) and the Shelley Society (1886). A Lydgate and Occleve Society was attempted and abandoned (p.…
…Shakespeare League and its Commemoration committee (pp. 37, 39) and the English Association (1907; p. 68). Benzie also records his youthful membership of the Whittington Club (1848; p. 14), which later housed the trades'…
§11 Eleanor on the stage and the platform: acting, lectures, editions and the press, 1881–984
- N104 The Browning Society recitation, the Cenci company, Mathilde Blind, Irving and the …
William Benzie , Dr. F. J. Furnivall: Victorian Scholar Adventurer (Norman, Okla., 1983), p. 24–p. 31, p. 125, p. 141, p.…
- N104 › The Browning Society
…Recitations, and Browning songs" (p. 233), which fits Eleanor's recitation of 30 June 1882 (inference; Benzie gives no date). Eleanor read the Society a paper on the Abbé Vogler (p. 228; N49). In 1886 W. G. Kingsland…
- N104 › The Cenci company
…dates the Shelley Society to 1884 (Meier/Evans p. 133) and calls the paper "Shelley's Socialism" (p. 204); Benzie has the Society resolved on 6 Dec 1885 and founded in 1886 (p.
- N104 › Peterson on the members
…which Browning came to see because of her Beatrice Cenci for the Shelley Society (p. 185). James Lecky, whom Benzie counts with Eleanor among the "very active members", read "Browning's Realism" on 25 Mar 1887; the paper was…
§12 Eleanor's circle, her editing of Marx and her papers7
- N62 Furnivall's working circle in the family letters: Mrs Furnivall, Teena Rochfort-Smith, …
William Benzie , Dr. F. J. Furnivall: Victorian Scholar Adventurer (Norman, Okla., 1983), p. 24–p. 31, p. 125, p. 141, p.…
- N62 › Mrs Furnivall
…worked as Furnivall's amanuensis on the dictionary and married him at the Hampstead register office in 1862 ( Benzie p. 24–p. 25). The separation was being prepared through 1882: Lucy Toulmin Smith told Murray of it on 20 Dec…
- N62 › Murray before and after
…Later he complained that "a Miss Marx" claimed 110 hours for 144 words, all from existing dictionaries; Benzie suspects that Furnivall had Murray paying for time spent mainly on New Shakspere Society work (p. 141, citing…
- N68 Eleanor's literary London, 1877–98: Maskelyne and Wallace, Meredith, Gosse, Walter Crane, …
…end 1877 or early 1878; Engels → Karl Henckell, end 1892; Kapp pp. 142, 307, 380, 448, 450, 808, 842 n.; Benzie pp. 201, 214–15, 223; Harris p. 769;
- N68 › Meredith
…1877 told him how his lecture on comedy had gone, and declined the Browning Society's committee in 1882 ( Benzie pp. 214–15, 223). His Tragic Comedians (1880) fictionalises Lassalle's fatal affair with Helene von Dönniges…
- N68 › Gosse
…in Furnivall's quarrel with Swinburne and later wrote harshly of Furnivall in his life of Swinburne ( Benzie pp. 201,
- N61 › The Furnivall side
…Question (agreement April 1886) and the Capital contract (pp. 321, 352). Furnivall's own papers, used by Benzie , are the next place to
§16 The British Museum and other libraries1
- E19 › Furnivall
…he was severely censured for inking over faded letters in a manuscript lent for Mrs Furnivall's use (p. 436). Benzie adds his lost ticket of 1873 (p. 260 n.) and his row with Bullen in 1879 (p.
§19 Law, philology and the record scholars1
- F15 › Lachmann in England
…in his journal "that jackanapes" whose editions should not be allowed, while respecting Skeat (p. 85, via Benzie pp. 130–31). See N60 for the Society Furnivall
§20 Who connects whom: the circles in tables1
- (outside the entries)
33 pp. 620–21; Benzie p.
§25 The art trades, the Communards and the International, 1864–741
- N69 W. J. Linton's workshop: Herzen's letters (1855), Crane's apprenticeship and Smith, …
is not named in the MEGA III letters to 1865, MEW 33–39, Kapp, Benzie or the daughters'
§27 The Working Men's College and the Christian Socialists, 1852–909
- (outside the entries)
…Hughes, J. M. Ludlow, John Westlake, Lowes Dickinson, Llewelyn Davies, R. B. Litchfield and F. J. Furnivall ( Benzie p. 43). Its own records are read here: J. Llewelyn Davies (ed.), The Working Men's College 1854–1904 (1904),…
…and subscription lists of 1858, 1866, 1868, 1869, 1874, c. 1880, 1889 and c. 1890 (archive.org; §31). William Benzie , Dr. F. J. Furnivall: Victorian Scholar Adventurer (1983), is cited as Benzie. None of these mentions Marx.…
and 1 more in this note
- N40 Frederic Harrison and "Mr Shaen": College men on both sides of Marx's arbitration, 1874
records and Benzie , against
and 1 more in this note
- N40 › Harrison
…on the refugees (N33). Harrison also describes the Positivists' "pilgrimages" to Stratford-on-Avon (quoted by Benzie p.
- N41 Ruskin's drawing class against Cole's system, and its handover to South Kensington
- N41 › Furnivall's part
…workman should be regulated", into the hands of "some 600", and canvassed trade-union branches for students ( Benzie p.
§28 Marx and the International on education, 1864–952
- N65 The Sunday Evenings for the People, 1866: the Marx family hears Huxley and Lyell at St …
…Vorbote no. 2, Feb 1866; General Council minutes, 16 Feb and 17 Aug 1869; Engels → Marx, about April 1863; Benzie p. 62; Harris pp.
- N65 › Huxley elsewhere
…Council's first war address in 1870 (I/21 p. 812). On the Furnivall side, Huxley wrote to Furnivall in 1856 ( Benzie p. 62), and Harris lists Huxley and Furnivall among the early holders of readers' tickets (p. 768;
§29 Corrections to earlier notes2
- (outside the entries)
…"um den Bart des heiligen Antonius zu holen" (to fetch St Anthony's beard). Kapp (p. 129 n.) and, after her, Benzie (p. 261 n.) give it to Karl Marx; it is
letter is Engels's. Benzie (p. 261 n.) repeats the misattribution from