MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N49 · The Browning and Shelley Societies; the Text Society's programme

The Browning and Shelley Societies: the Abbé Vogler, Aveling refused, "Shelley and Socialism"

Benzie pp. 221 n., 228, 231, 241, 246–47, citing Kapp, Eleanor Marx, vol. 2, p. 250, and BL Ashley MS 1449Secondary sources
Original (English)

[Benzie p. 228:] Eleanor Marx gave "A Short Account of the Abbe Vogler". — [p. 241:] Such diverse characters as Shaw, Augustine Birrell, James Lecky, and Karl Marx's daughter Eleanor were very active members. — [p. 247:] Aveling … was refused membership of the Shelley Society in 1886 mainly because, although married, he was living with Eleanor Marx. William Rossetti, who saw the irony of such a ruling, resigned from the society's committee. He explained to Furnivall later that "on the same grounds the Shelley Soc[iet]y w[oul]d have turned out Shelley himself." — [pp. 246–47:] in a paper entitled "Shelley and Socialism" that they read to the Shelley Society on December 14, 1887, they declared that Shelley was their Socialist brother. They supported that claim by quoting Karl Marx's statement that Shelley "was essentially a revolutionist and he would always have been one of the advanced guard of socialism."

AnalysisEleanor was a member of Furnivall's Browning Society (1881) and read it a paper on the Abbé Vogler, the subject of Browning's "Abt Vogler"; she was among its "very active members". In the Shelley Society (1886) the committee at first refused Aveling, and Rossetti's threat to resign forced his admission (Kapp vol. 2, p. 250, quoting Henry Salt). The Avelings' lecture is the English original of "Shelley als Sozialist", for which Engels translated the verse (N22). Kapp has the Avelings members of the Shelley Society "from 1885 when it was first founded by Furnivall for whom she had done endless hackwork in the past", though her own note on Furnivall dates the Society to 1886 (pp. 450, 129 n.); in July 1882 Eleanor recited at a "Browning Evening", and Mrs Sutherland Orr offered to take her to recite to Browning himself (pp. 183–84). The remark on Shelley comes only from the Avelings' report of Marx's conversation; it is not in MEW.
Aveling and the Shelley Society: the accounts differKapp (vol. 2, p. 250, from Henry Salt) has Rossetti's threat to resign forcing Aveling's admission. Benzie (p. 247) and Peterson (p. 192) say he was refused and that Rossetti resigned from …
The Cenci and the Browning recitationThe Shelley Society's Cenci (7 May 1886, Hermann Vezin and Alma Murray), the Outram libel, Mathilde Blind on the committee, and the Browning Society's founding members: N62.