MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N111 · The Browning and Shelley Societies; the Text Society's programme

Eleanor in the Browning and Shelley Societies' own volumes; Thomas J. Wise; and the search of Furnivall's other societies

Not in MEGAThe Browning Society's Papers, Part III (London: N. Trübner & Co., 1882), pp. 339–343; The Shelley Society's Papers, Part II (London: Reeves and Turner, 1888), pp. 180 ff.; Note-book of the Shelley Society, Part I (1888); Shelley Society, Report for 1887; Academy, 1 May 1886 and 24 December 1887; William Benzie, Dr. F. J. Furnivall (1983), pp. 14, 37, 39, 67–68, 71–72, 112, 123, 209, 254, 266. Full texts on archive.org, searched 16 November 2026; quotations are from the OCR text and have not been compared with the page images.
VolumeWhat it recordsWordingScan
A. Browning Society
The Browning Society's Papers, Part III (1882), no. XVII, pp. 339–343Her paper "An Account of Abbé Vogler. (From Fétis & Nisard.) By Miss Eleanor Marx": a life of Browning's musician, with his schools, his Orchestrion and his pupils Weber and Meyerbeer. Written for print, not for a meeting: the Academy of 15 July 1882 says she "is drawing up a short account … for the second part of the Browning Society's Papers". Peterson's list of every meeting and paper read (1969, Appendix A) does not include it. It is printed between the two papers read on 27 Oct 1882 (Dorothea Beale, pp. 323–38; Edwin Johnson, pp. 345–80), so it went out with that meeting's papers but was not read: the Academy's report of the meeting (4 Nov 1882, p. 334; Francis Storr in the chair) names only the papers by Johnson and Miss Beale and does not mention her ."Surely a sufficient answer to those who would see in him a mere 'charlatan.'"archive.org (catalogued as Furnivall's Bibliography of Robert Browning)
Hiram Corson, An Introduction to the Study of Robert Browning's Poetry (1886)Takes his account of Vogler from her paper and lists it among the Society's papers."For a further account, see Miss Eleanor Marx's paper on the Abbé Vogler, from which the above facts have been derived."archive.org
James Fotheringham, Studies in the Poetry of Robert Browning (1887)Uses her paper for the facts of Vogler's life."I take those facts from an analysis made by Miss Marx."archive.org
Edward Berdoe (ed.), Browning Studies: Being Select Papers by Members of the Browning Society (1895)Named in the introduction among those drawn to Browning, and in Mrs Turnbull's paper on "Abt Vogler". Her own paper is not reprinted, though the publisher's announcement had listed her as a contributor."The Abbé Vogler, thanks to Miss Marx, is no stranger to us".archive.org
B. Shelley Society
Note-book of the Shelley Society, Part I (1888), meeting of 14 April 1886; Academy, 1 May 1886Aveling spoke in the discussion of Buxton Forman's paper on Queen Mab, with Garnett, Shaw and Furnivall. Eleanor is not named."Dr. Edward Aveling (also a visitor) thanked Mr. Forman".Note-book · Academy
Note-book, pp. 189–95, meeting of 13 April 1887 (W. M. Rossetti in the chair)A. G. Ross's paper on The Revolt of Islam attacked street socialism. Rossetti, Furnivall, Salt, Shaw and Aveling answered him. Eleanor is not named.Ross "had not expected to meet an audience of such pronounced socialistic sympathies, much less to see such well-known socialists as Dr. Aveling and Mr. Shaw among them."archive.org
The Shelley Society's Papers, Part II (1888), from p. 180"Shelley and Socialism. By Edward Aveling and Eleanor Marx Aveling. Part I. A Lecture delivered to the Shelley Society", December 1887 (the day is damaged in the OCR; the Academy of 10 December lists it for the following week). Aveling read it."That which one of us is about to read to you, has been talked over, planned, thought out, in truth written by both of us; and although I am the reader, it must be understood that I am reading the work of my wife as well as, nay more than, of myself."archive.org
The same, p. 184 (by the OCR)The paper gives Marx's saying on Byron and Shelley as his daughter's report."As Marx, who understood the poets as well as he understood the philosophers and economists, was wont to say: 'The real difference between Byron and Shelley is this: those who understand them and love them rejoice that Byron died …'"archive.org
Shelley Society, Report for 1887, list of membersAveling is listed (65 Chancery Lane). Eleanor is not."Aveling, Edward, … 65, Chancery Lane, W.C."archive.org
What this addsBenzie and Kapp report the Vogler paper and the Shelley lecture at second hand (N49). The volumes give the paper itself, show three later Browning critics relying on it, and print Aveling's … Not present in the recordNo printed report of a Shelley Society meeting names Eleanor as present or speaking, and she is not in the 1887 list of members. The evidence for her in that Society is the lecture alone, … Thomas J. WiseWise edited the Shelley Society's reprints from 1886 and became its honorary secretary just after the Avelings' lecture: "Mr. J. Stanley Little has resigned the secretaryship of the Shelley … The other societies: nothing foundThe texts of 245 scans of Chaucer Society publications, 56 of the Ballad Society and 93 of the Wyclif Society on archive.org were searched for "Miss Marx", "Miss E. Marx", "Eleanor Marx", … The Philological Society's Transactions, 1877–87: not namedThe volumes for 1877–9, 1880–81, 1882–4 and 1885–7 were searched in full (archive.org scans, several copies of each, among them 1877–9, 1880–81, 1882–4 and 1885–7). She is not named. The … Furnivall's societies, from BenzieFounded by him: the Early English Text Society (1864; Extra Series 1867), the Chaucer Society and the Ballad Society (1868), the New Shakspere Society (1873), the Sunday Shakspere Society …
Not yet doneThe Browning Society's Papers after Part III (1885–91) were not found as scans; the Monthly Abstract in the first volume is too badly read by the OCR to search. Peterson locates the programme of the entertainment of 30 June 1882 in that Abstract (Papers I, pp. 35*–37*), with the Academy report of 8 July (N91); the evening was "so hastily put together" that Emily Hickey wrote a public apology (Academy, 15 July 1882, p. 50) . The Sunday Shakspere Society's papers and the missing Chaucer Society numbers have not been read volume by volume. The press reports of the December 1887 lecture have not been looked for outside the Academy.