N98 › Note
What Shakespeare meant to them
A note onN98 What Shakespeare meant to the working men's committee, 1864The committee did not teach Shakespeare. It celebrated him and tried to build him a monument, and the press reports give no sign of reading circles or classes run by it. Lectures were available nearby: the Whittington Club heard one on "the History, Genius, and Influence of Shakespeare" on 18 Feb. 1864 (Standard, 22 Feb.), and the penny-readings and Working Men's College movements were current. But these were not the committee's work. What it said about Shakespeare comes to four claims.
Reading it. The movement put Shakespeare to two uses. He was a national, classless poet who had been born a working man, and working men honoured him in order to show that they were respectable, literate and loyal. That is the case for the vote that the same men (Howell, Cremer, Odger) carried into the Reform League a year later. Hence the 1867 sneer that the reformers should account for the Shakespeare pennies before asking for "manhood suffrage and vote by ballot". Nothing found here quotes Shakespeare against the employers or the state. The radical claim is the one about ownership: that the greatest English writer belonged to the working class, which could therefore stand for the nation.
- He was one of them. At the meeting of 14 Sept. 1864 Bainbridge "claimed Shakespeare as a working man, one who had sprung from the industrial classes, but nevertheless one whose labours had conferred more glory upon England than that of all the princes, statesmen, and warriors" (Daily News, 15 Sept. 1864). Verses printed in the Standard's report of the planting say the same: "Here do we help to stud his diadem / With Labour's sweat-drop—England's richest gem. / Here do the people write with blazing pen, / 'Shakespeare was born of England's Working Men'" (Standard, 25 Apr. 1864, snippet; which of the day's poems this was is not established).
- The tribute was theirs to give. Their address said that "the highest tribute that can be paid to genius is that which springs spontaneously from the mass of the people". It called him "the world's great teacher", to whom "mankind owe … a common reverence", and spoke of "the humanising influence of his mighty genius". The memorial was to be paid for "chiefly by the pence of the people", and London should not lag behind the colonies and the United States, all "actively engaged in raising Shakespeare monuments" (Daily News, 2 Sept. 1864).
- They could read him. Howell said that English working men "not only spoke the language but thought the thoughts of Shakespeare", and that the memorial "would show that English working men were not ungrateful for the teaching of their illustrious bard". Others had failed in the same project from disunion, he said, but the working men "would succeed by union" (Daily News, 15 Sept. 1864). Moore had called the demonstration "a healthy exercise of their intellectual faculties", a way to "show to those who came after them the appreciation the working classes of England had for doing honour to Shakespeare's great name" (Standard, 1 Apr. 1864).
- It was not politics. Before the Board of Works the committee insisted that "there was nothing in the present circumstances to excite the least political or religious feeling", that "all sects and all parties concurred", and that after the planting the bands would play "God save the Queen" "as a manifestation of the loyalty of the working people" (Standard and Daily News, 1 Apr. 1864). Cowper took them at their word. He found it "an evidence of the great progress that had been made in comparatively recent times among the working classes in reference to the standard literature of the country", but still refused them Hyde Park (Daily News, 1 Apr. 1864, read in full).
Reading it. The movement put Shakespeare to two uses. He was a national, classless poet who had been born a working man, and working men honoured him in order to show that they were respectable, literate and loyal. That is the case for the vote that the same men (Howell, Cremer, Odger) carried into the Reform League a year later. Hence the 1867 sneer that the reformers should account for the Shakespeare pennies before asking for "manhood suffrage and vote by ballot". Nothing found here quotes Shakespeare against the employers or the state. The radical claim is the one about ownership: that the greatest English writer belonged to the working class, which could therefore stand for the nation.