MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N102 › Note

The College and the Collier affair

A note onN102 The Working Men's College and the Collier affair: Furnivall against Collier
Freeman and Freeman's index (about 1,560 surnames) was checked against J. F. C. Harrison's history of the Working Men's College (about 280), and Freeman's full text was searched for the College's people. The vice-principal was one of Collier's examiners. J. S. Brewer, one of the first teachers and vice-principal until 1872 (Harrison pp. 9, 44, 88, 99), joined "the sceptical faction" with Gairdner and Hardy in July 1859 (p. 736); at the Rolls House he was one of six authorities, with Romilly, Palgrave, Hardy, Madden and Hamilton, who examined a Collier paper: "we all came to the conclusion that the paper was a Forgery!" (p. 761); on 10 July 1860 he was at Stationers' Hall with Madden and Hardy when the register was found "meddled with" (p. 501). He went too far once, condemning the Wray–Dyer opinion among the Bridgewater papers, which Madden "rightly" held genuine (pp. 756 n., 811), and Ingleby's Complete View (1861) lists him among its experts (pp. 822, 1199). Harrison's history of the College does not mention any of this.