N102 › Note
Furnivall against Collier
A note onN102 The Working Men's College and the Collier affair: Furnivall against CollierFreeman and Freeman (2004) call Furnivall one of "the severe heirs of Collier's pioneering and corrupt editorial corpus" and "later one of Collier's wariest debunkers". He still accepted Collier's forged "Agincourt" ballad in 1868 (p. 695 n.) and reprinted "Lady Jane's Lament" for the Ballad Society only "for completeness' sake" (p. 512); in February 1874 he exposed misreadings in Collier's Henslowe and answered Collier's attempt to blame his assistants in the Athenaeum (pp. 362, 365); in his revision of Thynne for the EETS (1875) he called a Bridgewater inscription the work of "the forger of the other notorious Bridgewater-Library documents" (p. 288). By 1880 Collier treated him as his "new enemy", perhaps arranging a gift to Ouvry to frustrate Furnivall's edition of Stubbes for the New Shakspere Society (p. 964 n.), and Halliwell said he had stayed friends with every editor "save only F. J. Furnivall" (p. 905). The society Eleanor joined (N47) carried part of that campaign.