N31 › Note
The two Potters are one
A note onN31 Edmund Potter: the "manufacturers' manifesto" in Capital and the Manchester School of ArtIn the chapter on the working day Capital already cites "E. Potter in Brief an Times vom 24. März 1863" (II/5 p. 235 n. 182) as the manufacturers' voice against the Factory Acts, on the same page that records the Printworks Act as "a failure, both with reference to its educational and protective provisions". In the accumulation chapter (pp. 465–67) the letter, written against emigration by unemployed cotton workers during the cotton famine, becomes Marx's example of capital claiming the worker as its "living machinery". A year later Potter, as chairman of the Manchester School of Art, told the Select Committee on Schools of Art that artisans valued the school "very little. I judge by their attendance" (Macdonald p. 151, citing the 1864 evidence, pp. 108, 129). Macdonald adds that the elementary drawing the calico printers were offered "was as stultifying as the putting-on and squaring-up they did in the factory pattern-shops during the day" (p. 152). Rifkin's analysis of the Manchester school in 1845, whose largest group of students was calico printers' draughtsmen, and of its council of businessmen who employed over 400 workers but sent six, belongs here too (pp. 93–94).