MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N56 › Note

Helmholtz

A note onN56 Helmholtz's Berlin in the letters: Grove, Schwann, Traube, Tyndall, Helmholtz and Siemens, 1864–88
Engels's "since 1853" points to Helmholtz's lecture on Goethe's science, his first popular lecture, given that year (Wise pp. 245–46); MEW 34 places the remark at p. 19 by its index. The letter to Bracke (MEW 34, p. 279 by the index) concerns Helmholtz's ultimatum to the Berlin faculty over Dühring; Wise records Dühring's sneer at the laboratory men as "Handwerksgelehrte" (craftsman-scholars) (p. 236). Marx's Algiers letter (MEW 35 p. 49) is about the percussion of his chest. The Physical Society defined itself against Hegelian Naturphilosophie (G. F. Pohl, p. 225); Engels in 1874 heard in Tyndall's and Huxley's Belfast addresses "ihr Angstgeschrei nach einer rettenden Philosophie" (their cry of fear for a saving philosophy) and went back to Hegel's Logic (MEW 33). Wise never mentions Dialectics of Nature, where Engels criticises Helmholtz's Kraft and Spannkraft, the subject of his chapter 7; it is not in this corpus.