N57 › Note
The debate
A note onN57 The General Council debates education, August 1869: "national without being governmental" and "what the middle class understood by technical education"Eccarius opened by proposing that the Council keep to the Geneva resolution of 1866 and settle only who should provide. Milner wanted children taught "the laws that regulate the value of the produce of their labour" (p. 141); Jung answered that the economists themselves disagreed; Harris said he had been suspended as a schoolmaster for teaching grammar and algebra and that compulsory schooling in Prussia "gave instruction to murder" (pp. 144–45); Harriet Law wanted the Church's property turned over to schools; Reclus wanted state examinations to raise "the best" to the highest degrees (pp. 145–46). Lucraft's practical programme was a ladder of talent; Marx kept political economy out of the classroom and in "the everyday struggle of life". The minutes break off unsigned after Marx's second speech (p. 147). MECW 21 p. 398 prints the two speeches; the Bee-Hive reports of 14 and 21 Aug 1869 have not been seen.