MxSMarx's Shakespeare
N113 › Note

Did Halliwell-Phillipps come to meetings?

A note onN113 Who was in the room: the New Shakspere Society members at Eleanor's meetings, the editors she copied for, and H. B. Wheatley
No record places him in the room. Every appearance in the Notices of Meetings comes through Furnivall: his "Hint on the date of Coriolanus" was read "by Mr Furnivall" and "the thanks of the Meeting were given to Mr Halliwell and the Director" (26 June 1874); the Director "announced that Mr Halliwell was endeavouring to arrange for a search" of Lady Barnard's house (12 Mar 1875); his gift of 600 copies of Paget's essay was reported, "and the thanks of the Society had been expressed to Mr Halliwell" (14 May 1875); his Memoranda on the Midsummer Night's Dream was "read by the Director", and his view "not accepted by any of the Members present" (17 Oct 1879). He is never in a list of speakers. He became a member only on 9 May 1879 ("J. O. Halliwell-Phillips" among the new members announced), having refused the Committee in December 1873, and broke with the Society in 1881; so he was a member when Eleanor read her paper of 9 April 1880, but nothing puts him there. Spevack shows the other side of the post: Furnivall reported meetings to him by letter ("Your 'Hint' was very well received at the New Shakpere Society last night", 27 June 1874; "in the Meeting of 30, there was not one person who agreed with you", 17 Oct 1879), calls him "a hardly visible member of the Society, nor intended to be one", and quotes his resolve of 6 Aug 1876 "never again to join large parties of any kind". From 1878 he lived mostly at Hollingbury Copse near Brighton, though he kept 11 Tregunter Road. Furnivall's "Meeting of 30" is the only head-count found for an ordinary meeting.